Skip to content

Telstra

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile8 entries

  1. 2026

    Telstra files Federal Court action against former executive over Vocus role

    Lawsuit filed

    Telstra started legal action against former senior executive John Ieraci in the Federal Court of Australia on September 30, 2026, seeking to block him from participating in any product development related to security and managed services for rival telecommunications provider Vocus. The action was filed the day before he was due to start at Vocus.

    Stated objective. Block a former senior executive from participating in any product development related to security and managed services for rival telecommunications provider Vocus

    Source excerpt

    • The telco started the legal action against John Ieraci in the Federal Court of Australia on September 30, the day before he was meant to start at Vocus.
    • Telstra has gone to court to block a former senior executive from participating in any product development related to security and managed services for rival telecommunications provider Vocus.
  2. 2021

    Indigenous customer sales-practices case

    The Federal Court found that Telstra had encouraged some Indigenous customers to sign up for plans they did not need or could not afford and ordered the company to pay a penalty.

  3. 2021

    ACMA fines Telstra over unlisted-number data failures

    Fine or penalty

    The Australian Communications and Media Authority fined Telstra $2.53 million after finding that it failed to correctly upload nearly 50,000 customers’ requests for unlisted numbers, leaving those numbers publicly identifiable. Telstra said it accepted the findings and paid the infringement notice.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Telstra

      We self-reported these issues to Acma and took steps to correct them.

    Source excerpt

    • We self-reported these issues to Acma and took steps to correct them.
    • Telstra failed to correctly upload nearly 50,000 customers’ choices to have their number unlisted in the database, meaning those numbers were publicly identifiable.
    • Telstra has paid $2.5m in fines for failing to list close to 50,000 people as private numbers to prevent them being listed in public phone directories.
  4. 2021

    Federal Court orders Telstra to pay A$50 million penalty

    Ruling

    The Federal Court of Australia ordered Telstra to pay a $50 million penalty within 30 days from 13 May, following unconscionable sales conduct involving Indigenous customers. The ACCC said Telstra admitted the conduct and had breached Australian Consumer Law.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Telstra

      the telco will provide remediation to affected consumers, improve its existing compliance program, review and expand its Indigenous telephone hotline and enhance its digital literacy program for consumers in certain remote areas.
    • Refund or compensation — Telstra

      Telstra previously said it had taken steps to waive the debts arising from the unconscionable conduct, refund money paid and put in place steps to reduce the risk of similar conduct in the future.
    • Apology — Telstra

      Again, I want to apologise to all of the Indigenous customers affected by this.
    • Apology — Telstra

      In a statement, Telstra CEO Andy Penn apologised to the Indigenous customers affected by his company’s conduct.

    Source excerpt

    • According to the ACCC, Telstra admitted it acted unconscionably when sales staff at five licensed Telstra-branded stores in Alice Springs, Casuarina and Palmerston, Arndale and Broome signed up 108 Indigenous consumers to multiple post-paid mobile contracts, which they did not understand and could not afford, between January 2016 to August 2018.
    • Now, Federal Court judge Justice Debra Sue Mortimer, has handed down a judgment ordering Telstra to pay the proposed pecuniary penalty of $50 million within 30 days from 13 May, along with the ACCC’s costs related to the case and other expenses incidental to the proceedings.
    • “This conduct included manipulating credit assessments, misrepresenting products as free, and exploiting the social, language, literacy and cultural vulnerabilities of these Indigenous customers,” ACCC Chair Rod Sims said.
  5. 2020

    Horizon Power fined over unsafe electrical work

    Fine or penalty

    The Perth Magistrates Court fined Horizon Power $40,000 for incorrect work in Kununurra that caused a fire and made telecommunications equipment at various properties potentially unsafe. Horizon Power had earlier pleaded guilty to breaching the Electricity Regulations 1947.

    Source excerpt

    • Horizon Power was also ordered to pay $1,516.40 in costs, after earlier pleading guilty to breaching the Electricity Regulations 1947.
    • Regional electricity provider Horizon Power was fined $40,000 by the Perth Magistrates Court on 4 February 2020 for incorrect work in Kununurra that caused a fire and the telecommunications equipment at various properties to become potentially unsafe.
  6. 2020

    Telstra agrees to $50 million penalty over Indigenous sales

    Fine or penalty

    Telstra agreed to pay a $50 million penalty over sales of mobile plans to more than 100 Indigenous Australians that left them in thousands of dollars of debt. The ACCC accepted the penalty, which still requires Federal Court approval.

    Source excerpt

    • Telstra has agreed to pay a $50 million penalty over the sale of mobile plans to more than 100 Indigenous Australians, which left them in thousands of dollars of debt.
    • The penalty, which was accepted by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission but requires Federal Court approval, would be the second-largest fine in the history of Australian consumer law.
    • Telstra has paid a $1.5 million penalty for failing to allow consumers to keep existing local phone numbers when changing telephone companies.
  7. 2011

    Customer mailing-list privacy breach

    A mailing-list error caused the personal information of approximately 60,300 customers to be sent to other customers. The privacy regulator found a breach but described it as a one-off human error and recognised Telstra's remedial response.

  8. 2007

    WotNext user-generated-content controversy

    Telstra closed its WotNext video-publishing website after media criticism concerning sexually explicit user-uploaded material.