Skip to content

Express Scripts

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile4 entries

  1. 2026

    Florida sues Prime Therapeutics and Express Scripts over alleged drug price fixing

    Lawsuit filed

    Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier filed a lawsuit alleging that Prime Therapeutics and Express Scripts entered into an illegal agreement to fix prices on otherwise affordable drugs. The suit cites a December 2019 collaboration in which Prime adopted Express Scripts' lower reimbursement rates. The filing was reported on August 27, 2026.

    Stated objective. Recover overpayment stemming from the alleged pricing scheme

    Company response

    • Denial — Eli Lilly

      In an emailed statement, a spokesperson for Eli Lilly called the complaint “baseless”
    • Denial — CVS

      Spokespersons for CVS and Novo Nordisk said they intend to “vigorously defend” against the claims in the lawsuit.
    • Denial — Novo Nordisk

      Spokespersons for CVS and Novo Nordisk said they intend to “vigorously defend” against the claims in the lawsuit.
    • Denial — Sanofi

      Sanofi said its pricing practices have “always complied with the law.”

    Source excerpt

    • Attorney General James Uthmeier says Prime Therapeutics and Express Scripts entered into an illegal agreement to fix the prices on otherwise affordable drugs.
    • Florida is suing two major pharmaceutical companies for allegedly fixing drug prices.
    • The lawsuit cited a collaboration in December 2019 when Prime adopted Express Scripts’ lower reimbursement rates, an adjustment that remains in effect today.
  2. 2023

    AHF announces protest against Cigna over Express Scripts practices

    Public backlash

    AIDS Healthcare Foundation announced a protest against Cigna and its pharmacy benefit manager Express Scripts, alleging that Express Scripts’ practices disrupt patient care and harm access to patients’ chosen pharmacies. The protest was scheduled for August 24, 2023.

    Source excerpt

    • WHEN: Thursday, August 24, 2023 at 10:30 a.m. (ET)
    • Healthcare advocates from across the country affiliated with AIDS Healthcare Foundation (AHF) will protest Cigna – and, in particular, its pharmacy benefit manager (PBM) Express Scripts (ESI) – for its unethical practices that disrupt patient care and harm patient access to their chosen pharmacies.
    • The plaintiff alleges that the defendants were supposed to bill the copay assist program after processing the claim through health insurance to obtain proper payment from the copay assist program. Instead, the plaintiff states that the defendants called to harass for the payment of the copays directly and refused to send an emergency dose for the minor child resulting in an increased amount of seizures and inflammation.
  3. 2017

    Anthem pricing dispute

    Anthem alleged in court filings that Express Scripts had overcharged it by approximately $3 billion. The disagreement accompanied Anthem’s decision to terminate the PBM relationship and develop IngenioRx with CVS Health.

  4. 2004

    New York rebate and savings allegations

    New York Attorney General Eliot Spitzer filed a lawsuit alleging that Express Scripts retained tens of millions of dollars in rebates owed to the state and overstated the financial benefits of switching members to selected medicines. The matter was reported as settled in 2008.