Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile11 entries
2024
CCI orders investigation into Google Play billing policy
Investigation
India’s Competition Commission ordered an investigation into Google Play’s new billing policy following complaints alleging unfair and discriminatory service fees, denial of market access and other anticompetitive conduct. The Commission said it prima facie found merit in the allegations; the investigation was ordered, not concluded.
Source excerpt
The Competition Commission of India (CCI) on March 15 ordered an investigation into Google Play’s new billing policy based on complaints received from app developers and media industry bodies alleging unfair and discriminatory service fees, denial of market access, restrictions to technical development, and the abuse of dominance in one market to enter others.
The competition watchdog said that it prima facie finds merit in the allegations and ordered its Director General to conduct an investigation and submit a report in sixty days.
2023
US antitrust settlement over Google Play practices
Google agreed to pay US$700 million, largely for distribution to consumers, to resolve complaints brought by US states and consumers alleging anticompetitive conduct involving Google Play. The settlement also included measures intended to make alternative billing and direct application downloads easier.
2023
Jury finds Google Play Store payment system anticompetitive
Ruling
In a case brought by Epic Games, a federal court jury found that Google's Android app-store payment system was anticompetitive and harmed consumers and software developers. The judge was to determine remedies, and Google said it would appeal. The verdict concerned the Google Play Store's payment system and was reached by a jury in federal court.
Stated objective. Resolve allegations of stifling competition against its Android app store.
Company response
Remediation — Google
Google has agreed to implement changes to make it easier for consumers to download and install Android apps from alternative sources, not limited to its Play Store, over the next five years.
Source excerpt
Epic, which is based in Cary, North Carolina, filed its lawsuit against Google three years ago, alleging that the internet search giant has been abusing its power to shield its Play Store from competition in order to protect a gold mine that makes billions of dollars annually.
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Google lost an antitrust lawsuit over barriers to its Android app store, as a federal court jury has decided that the company's payments system was anticompetitive and damaged smartphone consumers and software developers.
Google said it will appeal the decision.
2023
Google tentatively settles US Play Store class action
Settlement
Google tentatively settled a class action lawsuit alleging that its U.S. Play Store violated federal antitrust rules by overcharging customers. The settlement details were not disclosed; the allegations had been made by plaintiffs and are not presented as a court determination.
Source excerpt
Details of the settlement were not disclosed.
Alphabet’s Google on Tuesday tentatively settled a class action suit alleging that its U.S. Play Store had violated U.S. federal antitrust rules by overcharging customers, according to a court filing.
Google reached a settlement with the US legal officials back in September and we now get the complete settlement details which include a $700 million contribution to a settlement fund and some shifts in the functioning of the Play Store in the US.
2023
Brazilian prosecutors investigate Google Play listing of Slavery Simulator
Investigation
Brazil’s Public Prosecutor’s Office opened an investigation into how the Slavery Simulator game became available on Google Play and gave Google three days to provide documentation about its approval for public consumption.
Source excerpt
The Brazilian Public Prosecutor’s Office has opened an investigation into how a "Slavery Simulator" game was made available on Google's Play Store, giving the tech giant three days to provide documentation about on how it was approved for public consumption.
2022
Google agrees to $90 million developer settlement
Settlement
Google agreed to pay $90 million to small US developers as part of a class-action lawsuit settlement. Developers alleged that Google used agreements with smartphone makers to close the app ecosystem and ensure developers used Google Play and its 30% transaction fee. The settlement terms were subject to court approval.
Stated objective. To support US developers who earned $2 million or less in annual revenue through Google Play during each year from 2016 to 2021.
Source excerpt
As part of a class-action lawsuit settlement, Google has agreed to pay $90 million to small US developers.
original lawsuit was filed in a federal court in San Francisco, with developers arguing that Google was using agreements with smartphone makers to "close the app ecosystem" and make sure devs would use Google Play -- and its 30% fee on transactions.
If the court approves the terms of the settlement, "developers that qualify will be notified and allowed to receive a distribution from the fund,"
2022
India’s CCI fines Google over Play Store policies
Fine or penalty
India’s Competition Commission of India imposed a penalty of Rs 936.44 crore on Google, finding that it abused its dominant position with respect to its Play Store policies. The regulator also issued a cease-and-desist order and directed Google to implement corrective measures.
Source excerpt
The commission has also issued a cease-and-desist order in which the regulator prescribed eight corrective measures that Google Play needs to implement to correct the anti-competitive practices.
The regulator found that Google didn't use the billing system for its own apps, which it said constituted an "imposition of discriminatory conditions."
India’s anti-trust regulator, the Competition Commission of India (CCI), on October 25 imposed a penalty of Rs 936.44 crore on Google for abusing its dominant position with respect to its Play Store policies.
2021
Attorneys general file antitrust lawsuit against Google over Play Store
Lawsuit filed
In 2021, a bipartisan coalition of 37 attorneys general filed an antitrust lawsuit against Google concerning its operation of the Google Play Store. The lawsuit alleged that Google's operation of the store unfairly restricted competition and harmed consumers. Among the allegations, the lawsuit stated that Google required developers to use Google Play Billing for in-app purchases. The filing was reported in connection with the coalition's action against Google over the app store.
Stated objective. Google said it aims to use the litigation to set legal precedents to protect users.
Source excerpt
According to the complaint, Google also requires that developers offering apps through the Google Play Store use Google Billing, which forces them to pay Google’s exorbitant commission—up to 30 percent—on in-app purchases made by consumers.
BOSTON — Attorney General Maura Healey today joined a bipartisan coalition of 37 attorneys general in filing a lawsuit against Google for using its market dominance to unfairly restrict competition within the Google Play Store for Android mobile devices, harming consumers by limiting choice and driving up app prices.
Match group, which also include dating apps such as OkCupid and PlentyofFish, are suing the makers of the Android operating system in a San Francisco federal court for breaking antitrust laws by making the demand in order to use its Play Store marketplace.
2021
Google updates Play Store loyalty-program policy
Company response
Google updated and broadened its Play Store policy on gaming loyalty programs, specifying guidance for programs tied to qualified monetary transactions and offering cash or cash-equivalent prizes. The update followed confusion and backlash in India over the guidance.
Stated objective. to help developers better understand the practices that are permitted
Company response
Clarification — Google
The company said on Thursday that it now specifies guidance on gamified loyalty programs that are based on a qualified monetary transaction in an app and offer prizes of cash or other real-world cash equivalent perks.
Source excerpt
Google has updated and broadened its Play Store policy on gaming loyalty programs to help developers better understand the practices that are permitted, months after confusion about the guidance prompted some backlash in India, the biggest Android market by users.
2020
Google removes nearly 600 apps over mobile ad fraud
Issue disclosure
Google said nearly 600 apps were removed from the Play Store for mobile ad fraud; the article says the apps included all those associated with Cheetah Mobile, and that they were also barred from Google Ad Manager and Google AdMob.
Source excerpt
The same apps have also been barred from Google Ad Manager and Google AdMob, monetization channels often used on this platform.
Google has released a blog post explaining why nearly 600 apps have just been removed from Android's Play Store. These apps were deemed guilty of "mobile ad fraud", which contravenes the Mountain View giant's policies. The apps in question include all those associated with the company Cheetah Mobile.
2019
Google Play faced criticism over a conversion-therapy app
Public backlash
Google faced criticism for making an app promoting gay conversion therapy available in Google Play. Truth Wins Out petitioned for the app’s removal, and the petition had received more than 40,000 signatures toward its 50,000-signature goal.
Source excerpt
The petition for the app’s removal has received more than 40,000 signatures of its 50,000 goal.
Google is facing criticism for having an app promoting gay conversion therapy available in its Google Play store.