Skip to content

Mastercard

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile9 entries

  1. 2026

    Visa and Mastercard agree to $167.5 million class-action settlement over ATM fees

    Settlement

    Visa and Mastercard agreed to pay a total of $167.5 million to settle the class-action lawsuit Burke v. Visa Inc., et al. The plaintiffs alleged the payment networks violated federal and state antitrust laws by prohibiting independent ATM operators from lowering withdrawal fees and forcing cardholders to pay higher ATM access fees, which the suit called a "price fixing scheme across all ATMs." Consumers charged unreimbursed non-bank ATM fees between Oct. 24, 2007 and Aug. 14, 2026 may file claims by Feb. 10, 2027, with the final approval hearing scheduled for Feb. 17, 2027.

    Visa and Mastercard have agreed to pay a total of $167.5 million (approximately $88.8 million from Visa and $78.7 million from Mastercard) to settle the class-action lawsuit Burke v. Visa Inc., et al., in which plaintiffs alleged the payment networks violated federal and state antitrust laws by prohibiting independent ATM operators from lowering withdrawal fees and forcing cardholders to pay higher ATM access fees, which the suit called a 'price fixing scheme across all ATMs.' Consumers charged unreimbursed non-bank ATM fees between Oct. 24, 2007 and Aug. 14, 2026 may file claims by Feb. 10, 2027, with the final approval hearing scheduled for Feb. 17, 2027.

    Company response

    • Refund or compensation — Visa

      The two networks have agreed to pay $167.5 million in total, approximately $88.8 million from Visa and $78.7 million from Mastercard.
    • Refund or compensation — Mastercard

      The two networks have agreed to pay $167.5 million in total, approximately $88.8 million from Visa and $78.7 million from Mastercard.

    Source excerpt

    • The result, the suit claimed , amounted to a "price fixing scheme across all ATMs."
    • Plaintiffs in Burke v. Visa Inc., et al., alleged that the payment networks violated federal and state antitrust laws by forcing cardholders to pay higher ATM access fees than they otherwise would have.
    • The two networks have agreed to pay $167.5 million in total, approximately $88.8 million from Visa and $78.7 million from Mastercard.
  2. 2024

    Visa and Mastercard reach merchant antitrust settlement

    Settlement

    Visa and Mastercard reached an approximately $30 billion settlement with merchant plaintiffs in a longstanding antitrust lawsuit. The agreement includes lower card swipe fees and other terms, and requires final approval by a federal court. The companies denied wrongdoing in agreeing to the settlement.

    Stated objective. to protect UK businesses from unfair charges

    Source excerpt

    • 周二(3月26日)宣布的反垄断和解协议是美国历史上最大的和解协议之一,如果获得纽约东区联邦法院批准,将解决始于2005年的全国性诉讼中的大部分索赔。
    • 长期以来,商家一直指责Visa公司和万事达公司在顾客使用信用卡或借记卡时收取过高的刷卡费,并禁止他们引导顾客使用现金或者刷卡费更低的支付方式。但Visa公司和万事达公司在同意和解时均否认有不当行为。
    • NYSE: MA) has reached an agreement to reduce its U.S. credit card interchange rates for at least a five-year period as part of a legal settlement with merchants.
  3. 2022

    UK appeal court rejects Mastercard bid to exclude deceased claimants

    Ruling

    The Court of Appeal in London ruled that the class action should proceed from its original 2016 starting point, rejecting Mastercard's attempt to exclude about three million people who had died since the claim was first filed. The case concerns claims that Mastercard's interchange fees were unfair and breached competition law; the ruling does not determine the underlying merits.

    Company response

    • Denial — Mastercard

      This flawed claim is being pushed by lawyers and their financial backers primarily focused on making money for themselves

    Source excerpt

    • But the Court of Appeal in London on Tuesday ruled that the suit should proceed from the original starting point of 2016.
    • Mastercard lost a bid to narrow the size of the U.K.'s largest-ever class action claim over its payment fees after appeal judges rejected its attempt to exclude some 3 million people who died since the claim was first filed.
    • This flawed claim is being pushed by lawyers and their financial backers primarily focused on making money for themselves, and is likely to take years to conclude.
  4. 2022

    UK regulator fines Mastercard and four other companies over prepaid-card cartel

    Fine or penalty

    The UK Payment Systems Regulator fined Mastercard and four other companies over cartel behaviour in the prepaid-card market. The article says the companies admitted breaking the law and settled with the regulator; Mastercard was fined £31.6 million.

    Company response

    • Apology — Mastercard

      we apologise that the actions of two former employees resulted in the standards expected of us not being met in this instance
    • Remediation — Mastercard

      We have taken this issue very seriously and have put further controls and training in place to ensure it cannot occur again

    Source excerpt

    • During the investigation, all five parties admitted to breaking the law and settled with the PSR.
    • Mastercard got the heftiest punishment and will have to pay £31.6 million, out of a £33 million total.
    • The UK's Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) has fined Mastercard and four other companies for "cartel behaviour" in the pre-paid credit card market by agreeing not to poach each others' customers on cards offered by local authorities.
  5. 2021

    Mastercard agrees to pay provisional competition-law fine

    Fine or penalty

    The UK Payment Systems Regulator said Mastercard and other card providers had agreed not to compete for local-authority contracts. The findings remained provisional; Mastercard admitted involvement and agreed to pay a fine if the regulator later decided the law was broken.

    Source excerpt

    • The Payment Systems Regulator claims for six years, the firms agreed not to poach clients or compete for bids.
    • Published 31 March 2021
    • The findings are still provisional but Mastercard, Allpay and PFS have all admitted involvement and agreed to pay fines if in due course the regulator decides the law was broken.
  6. 2020

    Loyal Bank sues Mastercard over terminated license

    Lawsuit filed

    Loyal Bank filed a lawsuit against Mastercard International in federal court, alleging that Mastercard improperly terminated its debit-card license after the bank was indicted for money laundering. The filing characterizes Mastercard's termination of the license as improper. These are allegations asserted in the lawsuit and have not been established as findings. The dispute concerns the termination of the bank's debit-card license following the indictment.

    Loyal Bank sued Mastercard International in federal court, alleging that Mastercard improperly terminated its debit-card license when the bank was indicted for money laundering. The allegations are claims made in the lawsuit.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Mastercard

      Mastercard spokesman Seth Eisen responded that the company has just seen the filing and is reviewing it.

    Source excerpt

    • claiming that the Purchase company improperly canceled a debit card license when the bank was indicted for money laundering.
    • Loyal Bank Limited, based in Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, sued Mastercard International Inc. on March 11 in federal court in White Plains.
  7. 2005

    Merchant interchange-fee class action

    Merchants and trade associations sued Mastercard and Visa over alleged interchange-fee price fixing and restrictions on merchant steering. A proposed settlement received judicial approval in 2019, although some merchants opted out or challenged aspects of the agreement.

  8. 1998

    U.S. antitrust case over bank exclusivity rules

    The U.S. Department of Justice challenged Mastercard rules that restricted issuing banks from doing business with competing networks such as American Express and Discover. The government prevailed in 2001, and the result survived appeal; related private litigation also produced a settlement with American Express.

  9. 1996

    Merchant debit and credit fee litigation

    Merchants and retailers alleged that Mastercard and Visa used network rules and pricing practices that increased debit and credit-card acceptance costs. Related litigation led to a multibillion-dollar settlement in 2003 and continued to influence disputes over interchange fees.