Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile9 entries
2026
P&G investor questions LGBTQ giving as reputational 'risk,' seeks report
Issue disclosure
A Proctor and Gamble investor has raised questions about the company's giving to LGBTQ causes, describing it as a reputational "risk," and is seeking a report from the company. The investor's request concerns the company's donations to LGBTQ causes and frames such giving as a potential reputational concern. The company has been asked to provide a report in response.
A P&G investor has questioned the company's giving to LGBTQ causes as a reputational 'risk' and is seeking a report from the company.
Stated objective. To obtain a report on LGBTQ giving as a reputational risk
Source excerpt
P&G investor questions LGBTQ giving as reputational 'risk,' seeks report
2024
P&G recalls laundry products in the United States and Canada
Recall announced
Procter & Gamble announced a recall of about 8.26 million bags of laundry products sold in the United States and Canada because of a defect in the child-resistant packaging. The reported defect could expose children to detergent chemicals. The recalled products include Tide, Gain, Ace and Ariel products; no injuries directly linked to the defect had been confirmed in the article.
Company response
Refund or compensation — Procter & Gamble
对于已经购买召回产品的消费者,宝洁公司提出,消费者应该立即将产品放置在儿童无法接触和看到的地方,并联系宝洁公司的辛辛那提总部以获得全额退款,以及免费更换用于存放洗涤剂的儿童安全袋存储产品。
Remediation — Procter & Gamble
消费者还可以收到一个橱柜锁,用于保护洗衣产品。
Refund or compensation — brands affected by the recall
Consumers can get a refund by contacting the brands affected by the recall.
Recall — Procter & Gamble
The FDA hasn't received any reports of adverse effects, but the company is pulling the products just to be safe.
Source excerpt
当地时间4月5日,宝洁公司宣布,由于包装存在缺陷,将在美国和加拿大召回约826万袋宝洁公司的洗衣凝珠等产品,包括Tide(汰渍)洗衣球、Gain洗衣粉囊、Ace洗衣球和Ariel洗衣球
虽然到目前为止尚未确认与该缺陷直接相关的伤害案例
据宝洁公司及美国和加拿大产品安全监管机构发布的通知,召回的原因是洗衣产品的儿童安全包装存在问题。据报道,外包装可能会在拉链轨道附近裂开,使儿童暴露在洗涤剂的化学物质中,进而会导致癫痫发作、昏迷、严重的呼吸障碍、眼睛损伤和烧伤。
2023
P&G and Oral-B named in lawsuit over text messages
Lawsuit filed
A federal lawsuit seeking class-action status names Procter & Gamble and its Oral-B brand. The suit alleges that P&G promoted Oral-B products by sending unsolicited, repeated text messages, including after consumers opted out.
Source excerpt
The legal action also names P&G’s Oral-B brand of oral hygiene products such as toothbrushes, toothpaste, mouthwashes and dental floss.
It alleges P&G promotes Oral-B services and products by sending unsolicited and continuous text messages, even after consumers opt out, in violation of the law.
A Fortune 500 company headquartered in Cincinnati, Procter & Gamble Co. is being sued over toothbrush texts.
2022
CAO Group files patent complaint against P&G over Crest whitening strips
Lawsuit filed
In a controversy noted in the brand's wiki, CAO Group filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California alleging that Procter & Gamble's Crest teeth whitening strip products infringe CAO patents. The source reports the allegation only and does not state that a court has reached any determination on the claim.
Source excerpt
The CAO Group, Inc. (CAO), a world leading high-technology dental company, has filed a complaint with the United States District Court for the Central District of California against The Procter & Gamble Company and The Procter & Gamble Distributing LLC, declaring that their Crest® teeth whitening strip products infringe claims of CAO's U.S. patents 10,603,259 and 10,646,419.
2022
P&G subsidiary fined for advertising violations
Fine or penalty
Guangzhou P&G Co., Ltd. was fined RMB 700,000 by the Guangzhou Huangpu District Market Supervision Administration for advertising that it determined violated Chinese advertising law, including using gender-based body-odor comparisons and citing material without accurate attribution. The company had deleted the advertisement and canceled the account before the penalty was imposed.
Company response
Remediation — 广州宝洁有限公司
鉴于当事人已主动改正,删除广告,注销公众号,积极配合行政机关调查。
Source excerpt
经中国经济网记者查询,广州宝洁有限公司为宝洁(中国)有限公司全资子公司;宝洁(中国)有限公司为香港宝洁有限公司(PROCTER& GAMBLE HONG KONG LIMITED)全资子公司。
当事人在其公众号发布标题为“女人的脚臭是男人的五倍?不信现在闻一下”的广告的行为引起多媒体报道,造成较大的社会影响,鉴于当事人已主动改正,删除广告,注销公众号,积极配合行政机关调查。
广州市黄埔区市场监督管理局指出,当事人利用男女体臭对比发布广告的行为违反了《中华人民共和国广告法》第九条第(七)项:“广告不得有下列情形:(七)妨碍社会公共秩序或者违背社会良好风尚”的规定,当事人的广告使用引证内容未标明出处、不准确的行为违反了《中华人民共和国广告法》第十一条第二款:“广告使用数据、统计资料、调查结果、文摘、引用语等引证内容的,应当真实、准确,并表明出处。引证内容有适用范围和有效期限的,应当明确表示”的规定。
2021
P&G recalls aerosol dry shampoo and conditioner products over benzene
Recall announced
The Procter & Gamble Company announced a voluntary consumer-level recall of specified aerosol dry conditioner and dry shampoo products from Pantene, Aussie, Herbal Essences, Waterless, Old Spice, and Hair Food after benzene was detected in some products. The company said the benzene came from the propellant and offered reimbursement for eligible products.
Company response
Recall — The Procter & Gamble Company
The Procter & Gamble Company (NYSE: PG) today issued a voluntary product recall to the consumer level of aerosol dry conditioner spray products and aerosol dry shampoo spray products
Refund or compensation — P&G brands
Our brands will also offer reimbursement for consumers who have purchased products impacted by this recall.
Source excerpt
The Procter & Gamble Company (NYSE: PG) today issued a voluntary product recall to the consumer level of aerosol dry conditioner spray products and aerosol dry shampoo spray products from Pantene, Aussie, Herbal Essences, and Waterless produced in the United States, in addition to previously discontinued aerosol dry shampoo products from Old Spice and Hair Food, due to the presence of benzene detected in some products.
Our brands will also offer reimbursement for consumers who have purchased products impacted by this recall.
Procter & Gamble is recalling dozens of aerosol spray products, including dry shampoo and dry conditioner, that were distributed nationwide due to traces of benzene.
2021
US lawmakers condemn Beijing Olympics sponsors
Public backlash
A bipartisan US congressional group condemned US companies sponsoring the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics, saying they refused to condemn the Chinese government's treatment of Uyghurs. The companies' representatives testified at a hearing; Coca-Cola's representative said the company respected all human rights.
Source excerpt
马林诺夫斯基反复询问可口可乐是否会特别谴责中共政府对维吾尔人的任何虐待时,可口可乐全球人权事务副总裁拉利说,“我们尊重所有人权。”
出席听证会的公司包括爱彼迎(Airbnb)、可口可乐、英特尔、宝洁、Visa公司。
周二(7月27日),美国国会一个两党小组谴责了2022年北京冬奥会的几家美国企业赞助商,其中包括可口可乐、Visa公司和爱彼迎(Airbnb)。议员们称,这些公司为保住在中国的利润而拒绝谴责中共的种族灭绝行为。
2020
India's anti-profiteering authority fines three companies over GST benefits
Fine or penalty
India's National Anti-Profiteering Authority imposed a fine of more than Rs 241.5 crore on P&G Home Products, P&G Hygiene and Healthcare, and Gillette India, stating that they had not passed on GST rate-cut benefits to consumers. The companies were required to deposit half of the determined profiteered amount in the Central Consumer Welfare Fund and the other half in state and Union Territory funds. A P&G spokesperson said the companies had passed on the net commensurate benefit and that P&G would review the order and assess legal options.
India’s National Anti-Profiteering Authority imposed a fine of more than Rs 241.5 crore on P&G Home Products, P&G Hygiene and Healthcare, and Gillette India, saying they had not passed on GST rate-cut benefits to consumers. The companies were required to deposit half of the determined profiteered amount in the Central Consumer Welfare Fund and the other half in state and Union Territory funds. A P&G spokesperson said the companies had passed on the net commensurate benefit and that P&G would review the order and assess legal options.
Company response
Ongoing disclosure — Procter & Gamble
P&G will review the order by NAA, and assess all possible legal options, said the spokesperson, adding: “We are hopeful that our stand will be vindicated.”
Source excerpt
the National Anti-Profiteering Authority (NAA) has imposed a fine of over Rs 241.5 crore on P&G Home Products, P&G Hygiene and Healthcare and Gillette India Ltd for not passing on benefits of GST rate cut to the consumers.
P&G will review the order by NAA, and assess all possible legal options, said the spokesperson, adding: “We are hopeful that our stand will be vindicated.”
New Delhi, Nov 26 :
2020
Earth Island Institute sues companies over plastic packaging pollution in California
Lawsuit filed
Earth Island Institute filed a lawsuit in a California court against Coca-Cola, Pepsi, Nestle USA, Procter & Gamble and other companies, seeking unspecified damages and an order requiring them to clean up plastic waste. The group alleges that plastic packaging from the companies is fouling California waters and says their products contributed to a global pollution crisis; these are allegations in the lawsuit, not a court determination.
Stated objective. The lawsuit seeks unspecified damages and an order for the companies to clean up plastic waste.
Source excerpt
The Earth Island Institute asked for unspecified damages and an order for Coca-Cola, Pepsi, Nestle USA, Procter & Gamble and six other companies to clean up plastic waste that the group says has created a global pollution crisis.
Escalating a campaign to make corporations responsible for the waste they produce, an environmental group filed suit Wednesday against some of the world’s biggest food, beverage and consumer goods companies in a California court, arguing they should be held responsible for plastic packaging that is fouling the state's oceans, rivers and streams.
The suit names those companies, along with Nestle USA, Crystal Geyser Water, Clorox, Mars and Danone North America.