Skip to content

SolarCity

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile3 entries

  1. 2023

    Delaware Supreme Court upholds judgment in Tesla–SolarCity acquisition dispute

    Ruling

    The Delaware Supreme Court ruled that Elon Musk had not forced Tesla to overpay for SolarCity in the 2016 acquisition and said the lower court’s overall findings supported the conclusion that Tesla paid a reasonable price. Shareholders had challenged the deal and sought the return of Tesla shares Musk received.

    Source excerpt

    • 周二,特拉华州最高法院裁定,马斯克在 2016 年并购太阳能城公司(SolarCity)时,并没有迫使特斯拉公司高价收购这家屋顶太阳能公司。
    • 该州最高法院表示,虽然特拉华州切茨瑞法院(Delaware Court of Chancery)的一位法官在部分分析中有误,但他的整体论证仍然支持他的判断,即特斯拉为太阳能城支付了合理的价格。
    • 当时,马斯克是两家公司的最大股东,特斯拉的一些股东指控马斯克推动特斯拉董事会做出这笔交易,以拯救他在太阳能城这家陷入困境的公司的投资
  2. 2019

    Shareholders challenge Tesla’s SolarCity acquisition

    Lawsuit filed

    Tesla shareholders alleged in court filings that Tesla misvalued its 2016 acquisition of SolarCity and misled investors about the transaction. The article does not report a court determination.

    Company response

    • Denial — Tesla

      此外,该公司还对指控予以驳斥,表示这些指控不仅虚假并且还具有误导性。

    Source excerpt

    • 特斯拉的股东认为,特斯拉错误地评估了这起有关SolarCity的交易,并且对投资者产生了误导。
    • 投资者还在诉讼中表示,SolarCity的运转靠的是SpaceX的资金。
    • 北京时间9月24日消息,据国外媒体报道,周一公布的法庭文件显示,包括一些养老基金在内的许多特斯拉大型投资者认为,特斯拉在2016年斥资26亿美元收购SolarCity的交易本不应该发生。根据股东就特斯拉收购案提起的这起诉讼的开场摘要,股东们指责特斯拉对这笔交易的估值不当,提供有缺陷的分析并误导投资者。
  3. 2016

    Shareholder challenge to Tesla's SolarCity acquisition

    Shareholders challenged Tesla's acquisition of SolarCity, raising questions about conflicts of interest, the relationship between Elon Musk and SolarCity, and whether Tesla paid an excessive price. In 2022, the Delaware Court of Chancery ruled for Musk, finding that the board had meaningfully evaluated the deal and that the evidence supported a fair price.