Skip to content

Amazon

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile172 entries · Page 7 of 9

  1. 2021

    D.C. attorney general sues Amazon over pricing practices

    Lawsuit filed

    Washington, D.C. Attorney General Karl Racine sued Amazon, alleging that pricing contracts with third-party sellers unfairly raised consumer prices and suppressed innovation. Amazon disputed the allegations, saying sellers set their own prices.

    Stated objective. Amazon seeks a declaratory judgment that the state laws the OAG seeks to enforce are preempted by federal law and an injunction against their enforcement against Amazon.

    Company response

    • Denial — Amazon

      An Amazon spokesperson said Tuesday: "The DC Attorney General has it exactly backwards — sellers set their own prices for the products they offer in our store."
    • Denial — Amazon

      Amazon disputes these arguments.

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit alleges Amazon illegally maintained monopoly power through pricing contracts with third-party sellers.
    • Washington, D.C., Attorney General Karl Racine announced Tuesday he's suing Amazon on antitrust grounds, claiming the company's practices have unfairly raised prices for consumers and suppressed innovation.
    • An Amazon spokesperson said Tuesday in a statement: “The DC Attorney General has it exactly backwards — sellers set their own prices for the products they offer in our store.
  2. 2021

    Amazon apologizes for tweet about drivers urinating in bottles

    Company response

    Amazon apologized for a tweet denying that its delivery drivers urinate in bottles while working, acknowledged that the tweet was incorrect, and said drivers can have difficulty finding restrooms.

    Company response

    • Apology — Amazon

      Amazon apologized Friday for a snide tweet it sent last week denying the well-documented occurrence of its delivery drivers peeing in bottles while on the job.
    • Apology — Amazon

      We apologize to Representative Pocan.

    Source excerpt

    • "Regardless of the fact that this is industry-wide, we would like to solve it," the company said. "We don’t yet know how, but will look for solutions."
    • Amazon went on to call the tweet "incorrect" and to say the company was wrongly focusing on fulfillment centers, which have dozens of restrooms.
    • On Friday, Amazon apologized to Pocan.
  3. 2021

    EU court annuls Amazon-Luxembourg tax ruling

    Ruling

    The EU General Court annulled the European Commission's ruling that a tax deal between Amazon and Luxembourg amounted to illegal state support, finding that the Commission had not proved an undue reduction in the tax burden of an Amazon group subsidiary to the required legal standard. Amazon welcomed the decision.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Amazon

      Amazon said it welcomed the court’s decision, which is “in line with our long-standing position that we followed all applicable laws and that Amazon received no special treatment,”

    Source excerpt

    • a court on Wednesday annulled a ruling by the European Commission that a tax deal between Amazon and Luxembourg's government amounted to illegal state support.
    • But judges at the EU's General Court said the European Commission didn't prove “to the requisite legal standard that there was an undue reduction of the tax burden of a European subsidiary of the Amazon group."
    • Amazon said it welcomed the court’s decision, which is “in line with our long-standing position that we followed all applicable laws and that Amazon received no special treatment,”
  4. 2021

    Customer sues Amazon over scam warnings

    Lawsuit filed

    Amy Oates is suing Amazon, alleging the company should do more to warn customers about scams in which scammers impersonate Amazon. Amazon declined to comment on the lawsuit.

    Source excerpt

    • Oates is suing Amazon, saying the company should do more to warn its customers about the scam.
    • Amazon is facing a lawsuit filed by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), which is seeking the reinstatement of an employee it believes was filed in retaliation.
  5. 2021

    EU preliminary report flags potential competition concerns in the smart-home and IoT sector

    Issue disclosure

    The European Commission's preliminary report on the Internet of Things said that a small number of companies, including Apple, might engage in anticompetitive conduct. The report did not conclude that Apple or other companies had violated competition law.

    Source excerpt

    • 初步报告并没有说苹果或其他公司违反了竞争法。
    • 在所有消费物联网领域,大量受访者指出,开发新产品和服务的主要障碍是没有能力与Google、亚马逊和苹果竞争
    • 一份关于物联网的初步报告得出结论,包括苹果在内的少数公司可能存在反竞争行为。
  6. 2021

    FlexBooker reports cyberattack and access to system data

    Issue disclosure

    FlexBooker said its account on Amazon's AWS servers was compromised on December 23, 2021, and that system data was accessed and downloaded. It said the incident temporarily prevented service to customer accounts and that it restored operations within 12 hours.

    Company response

    • Remediation — FlexBooker

      In response to the outage, we worked closely with Amazon to restore a backup, and were able to restore operations within 12 hours.

    Source excerpt

    • On December 23, 2021, starting at 4:05 PM EST our account on Amazon's AWS servers was compromised, resulting in our temporary inability to service customer accounts, and preventing customers from accessing their data,
    • As part of the incident, our system data storage was also accessed and downloaded.
  7. 2021

    Amazon sues India’s Enforcement Directorate over investigation

    Lawsuit filed

    Amazon filed a case in the Delhi High Court seeking to quash the Enforcement Directorate’s investigation into one of its 2019 deals. In its filing, Amazon described the inquiry as a “fishing and roving” exercise.

    Stated objective. Quash the investigation

    Source excerpt

    • The US e-commerce giant said in its filing to the Delhi High Court on Dec. 21.
    • Amazon.com Inc is taking India's financial crime fighting agency to court, seeking to quash an investigation into one of its 2019 deals, a court filing seen by Reuters shows.
  8. 2021

    Pennsylvania Supreme Court rules on Amazon employee bag-search pay

    Ruling

    The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled 5–2 that employees should be compensated for time spent waiting in security lines for bag checks. Amazon had argued that the time did not count as work; the article reports that Amazon will pay some 42,000 workers a total of $8.67 million.

    Source excerpt

    • At the heart of the issue was whether time spent in security lines, waiting for bag checks, counted as time worked.
    • Amazon will now pay some 42,000 workers a total of $8.67 million
    • The Pennsylvania Supreme Court disagreed, ruling 5-2 that employees should be compensated for that time.
  9. 2021

    Reports allege Amazon removed critical reviews in China

    Issue disclosure

    The article reports allegations, attributed to Reuters, that Amazon complied with a Chinese government demand to remove reviews below five stars of a government-published book from Amazon.cn. It also reports that Amazon partnered with an arm of China’s propaganda apparatus to create the China Books portal on Amazon.com.

    Source excerpt

    • the internal document and interviews show, Amazon partnered with an arm of China’s propaganda apparatus to create a selling portal on the company’s U.S. site, Amazon.com – a project that came to be known as “China Books.”
    • Amazon agreed to Beijing’s demand to have anything below a five-star review of Xi Jinping’s book The Governance of China removed from its Chinese site
  10. 2021

    CCI revokes approval for Amazon–Future Coupons transaction

    Ban or restriction

    India’s Competition Commission revoked its approval for Amazon’s transaction to acquire a stake in Future Coupons.

    Source excerpt

    • 印度反垄断监管机构“印度竞争委员会”(CCI)今日撤销了 亚马逊收购印度未来零售有限公司(Future Retail Ltd)旗下子公司Future Coupons交易的许可。
    • 同时,亚马逊还因为隐瞒交易事实而被CCI罚款20亿卢比(约合2630万美元)。
    • In an order on Friday, the CCI said Amazon ought to have notified the combination and Future Retail (FRL)shareholding agreement for the purpose of acquisition of strategic rights over FRL through FCPL shareholders' agreement (SHA); and commercial agreements between Amazon and Future groups, for the purpose of establishing strategic alignment and partnership between Amazon Group and FRL as well as have a 'foot-in-the-door' in the India retail sector.
  11. 2021

    EU General Court rules in Amazon’s favor in state-aid case

    Ruling

    The European General Court ruled that Amazon’s cost-sharing arrangement in Luxembourg did not breach EU competition law and found that the European Commission had not proved an undue reduction in Amazon’s tax base. The court said the Commission’s 2017 findings were incorrect in several respects.

    Source excerpt

    • The European Commission did not prove that Amazon had secured an “undue reduction” in its tax base, according to a May 12 ruling by the General Court.
    • The European General Court has ruled that Amazon’s cost-sharing arrangement in Luxembourg did not breach EU competition law.
  12. 2021

    Amazon apologizes and acknowledges drivers’ restroom difficulties

    Company response

    Amazon apologized to Representative Mark Pocan for an inaccurate tweet denying that workers urinated in bottles, acknowledged that drivers can have trouble finding restrooms, and said it would look for solutions. The article reports workers’ allegations about inadequate working conditions.

    Stated objective. Amazon said it would like to solve the restroom-access problem.

    Company response

    • Apology — Amazon

      We owe an apology to Representative Pocan,
    • Clarification — Amazon

      The tweet was incorrect. It did not contemplate our large driver population and instead wrongly focused only on our fulfillment centers,

    Source excerpt

    • Amazon has apologized to a congressman after falsely denying that some of its workers are forced at times to urinate in plastic bottles.
    • We owe an apology to Representative Pocan,
    • The workers' testimony underlined the complaints of many Amazon employees -- both in its processing facilities and among its drivers -- about what they say is a relentless work pace.
  13. 2021

    Italy fines Amazon €1.13 billion over alleged competition abuses

    Fine or penalty

    Italy's antitrust regulator fined Amazon €1.13 billion for competition-related abuses. The regulator alleged that Amazon's Italian subsidiary used its strong position to pressure retailers into using its logistics service. Amazon said it strongly disagreed with the ruling and would appeal.

    Company response

    • Denial — Amazon

      Amazon told reporters it "strongly disagreed" with the AGCM ruling and would appeal.

    Source excerpt

    • Italy's antitrust regulator on Thursday fined online retail giant Amazon 1.13 billion euros (1.28 billion U.S. dollars) for competition-related abuses.
    • Amazon told reporters it "strongly disagreed" with the AGCM ruling and would appeal.
    • Italy's Competition and Market Guarantor (AGCM) alleged Amazon's Italian subsidiary had used its strong position to force retailers to use its logistics service.
  14. 2021

    Amazon announces payments for eligible product injury claims

    Company response

    Amazon announced a policy under which it will pay customers for eligible property-damage or personal-injury claims involving products sold through Amazon.com, including claims under $1,000 and certain higher-value claims.

    Stated objective. Reduce the number of lawsuits the company faces over products that injure customers.

    Company response

    • Refund or compensation — Amazon

      Amazon will directly pay customers for claims under $1,000—which account for more than 80% of cases—at no cost to sellers

    Source excerpt

    • Amazon has announced a new policy that aims to reduce the number of lawsuits the company faces over products that injure customers.
    • Now, in the unlikely event a defective product sold through Amazon.com causes property damage or personal injury, Amazon will directly pay customers for claims under $1,000—which account for more than 80% of cases—at no cost to sellers, and may step in to pay claims for higher amounts if the seller is unresponsive or rejects a claim we believe to be valid.
  15. 2021

    OSHA opens probe into fatal Amazon facility collapse

    Investigation

    OSHA said it was launching an investigation into the fatal collapse of an Amazon facility in Illinois after a tornado struck it. Six people died. The article reports that the investigation may result in citations and proposed penalties if violations are found; it does not report a finding of violations.

    Source excerpt

    • The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) is launching a probe into the fatal collapse of an Amazon facility in Illinois after it was hit by a tornado, the agency said Monday.
    • Six people died and one was transferred to a regional hospital after a tornado hit the 1.1-million-square-foot delivery center on Friday, according to officials.
    • A tornado hit the warehouse on Friday night, killing six people.
  16. 2021

    Amazon settles six cases with the NLRB

    Settlement

    Amazon reached a settlement with the National Labor Relations Board in six cases. Under the settlement, Amazon agreed to post employee-rights notices at relevant facilities, contact affected employees, and not interfere with protected union and collective activities.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Amazon

      As part of the settlement, Amazon pledges not to retaliate against employees who discuss unionization outside of work facilities or on their own time.

    Source excerpt

    • As part of the settlement, Amazon pledges not to retaliate against employees who discuss unionization outside of work facilities or on their own time.
    • Amazon has reached a settlement with the National Labor Relations Board in six cases, helping to pave the way for workers to unionize as more seek a seat at the bargaining table.
    • The NLRB shared the settlement Thursday through a Freedom of Information Act request, stating that Amazon must post a notice to its relevant facilities for 60 days.
  17. 2021

    Amazon sues over fraudulent text scams

    Lawsuit filed

    Amazon announced that it was filing a federal lawsuit in the Western District of Washington against unnamed participants in text-message schemes that purported to be from Amazon and directed people to purchase unaffiliated products.

    Stated objective. Amazon said the lawsuit was intended to tackle text scams and hold accountable parties responsible.

    Source excerpt

    • The company is taking the fight to the scammers, filling a federal lawsuit in the Western District of Washington against a number of yet-to-be-named participants.
    • Amazon has announced it is launching a lawsuit to tackle text scams that purport to be from the e-commerce giant.
    • The text messages promise rewards or gifts, but direct people to sites where they must purchase products that have no affiliation with Amazon.
  18. 2021

    Lawsuit filed against Amazon over marijuana testing policy

    Lawsuit filed

    Michael Thomas sued Amazon, claiming that the company unlawfully rescinded his job offer after he tested positive for marijuana and that its pre-employment testing policy violated New York City Human Rights Law. The article reports allegations, not a court determination.

    Source excerpt

    • A New York City man is suing Amazon for its policy to weed out new hires — arguing it was illegal to rescind a job offer after he tested positive for marijuana on a drug test.
    • Filed in Brooklyn Federal Court on Friday, the suit claims that Amazon violated New York City Human Rights Law, which prohibits employers from drug-testing potential hires for marijuana except in certain cases, including if employees are going to operate heavy machinery.
  19. 2021

    Amazon book availability controversy

    Issue disclosure

    The article reported that Amazon appeared to make Ryan Anderson’s book “When Harry Became Sally: Responding to the Transgender Movement” unavailable. The article did not establish whether the unavailability was intentional.

    Source excerpt

    • A search this morning still found no availability of the book.
    • Amazon appeared to deplatform Ryan Anderson and his best-selling book, "When Harry Became Sally: Responding to the Transgender Movement."
  20. 2021

    Amazon settles lawsuit over online price listings

    Settlement

    Amazon agreed to pay $2 million in penalties and restitution to settle a lawsuit brought by San Diego County and five other California counties. The complaint alleged that some of Amazon’s online reference-price listings were misleading or potentially misleading. The stipulated judgment also required revisions to Amazon’s pricing disclosures.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Amazon

      The District Attorney’s Office statement said Amazon “worked promptly and cooperatively throughout the district attorneys’ investigation and has already implemented changes to its website and pricing algorithms consistent with the final judgment.”

    Source excerpt

    • In addition to the monetary penalties, the stipulated judgment reached Wednesday requires Amazon to make revisions to its pricing disclosures,which includes providing hyperlinks on its site that give consumers “clear definitions of the meaning of ‘was’ and `’list’ price advertisements, so they understand the nature of the advertised savings.”
    • The complaint filed last week in San Diego Superior Court alleged that the e-commerce giant’s use of “reference pricing” in some of its online advertisements was either misleading or potentially misleading.
    • Amazon has agreed to pay $2 million in penalties and restitution after settling a lawsuit with San Diego County and five otherCalifornia counties over potentially misleading price listings on its website, it was announced Thursday.