Skip to content

Facebook

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile172 entries · Page 5 of 9

  1. 2021

    Russian court found Facebook guilty over prohibited content

    Ruling

    A Moscow magistrates' court found Facebook guilty under Russian administrative law for failing to remove information when Russian law required its removal. According to the source, most of the multimillion-dollar fines concerned posts about unauthorized rallies or calls for rallies. The ruling addressed the platform's non-compliance with Russian content-removal requirements.

    Source excerpt

    • The court ruled that Facebook was found guilty under Part 2 Article 13.41 of the Code of Administrative Offenses of the Russian Federation (the owner of an information resource on the Internet that does not delete information or a webpage in the event when Russian law envisages such an obligation),
  2. 2021

    Phhhoto files antitrust lawsuit against Facebook

    Lawsuit filed

    Phhhoto filed an antitrust lawsuit against Facebook, alleging that Facebook and Instagram cloned its app and used their market share in ways that caused Phhhoto's business to fall behind. A Meta spokesperson said the suit was without merit and that Meta would defend itself vigorously.

    Company response

    • Denial — Meta

      A Meta spokesperson declined the allegations and said, 'This suit is without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously.'

    Source excerpt

    • A Meta spokesperson declined the allegations and said, 'This suit is without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously.'
    • The suit claims that Facebook and Instagram then created a clone that does the same job and then used the market share to get the other app to fall behind in the race.
    • As Facebook Inc (FB) fights off a monopoly lawsuit charged by the FTC, another predicament hits the company as photo app Phhhoto has filed an antitrust lawsuit against the tech giant claiming that it has cloned their app and ruined their business.
  3. 2021

    HD Media files antitrust suit against Google and Facebook

    Lawsuit filed

    HD Media filed an antitrust suit against Google and Facebook in federal court in West Virginia, alleging that Google monopolized the online ad market and that Google and Facebook conspired to further their dominance. The suit asks for unspecified damages and an end to the alleged conduct.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Google

      Google referred a reporter to a blog post published in mid-January by its director of economic policy, Adam Cohen, that defends Google’s business against antitrust charges brought by the Texas attorney general in December.

    Source excerpt

    • A West Virginia news publisher has filed an antitrust suit against Google and Facebook, who together receive roughly half of all digital ad dollars in the U.S. and are facing antitrust charges from federal and state authorities.
    • HD Media claims Google has so monopolized the online ad market that “it threatens the extinction of local newspapers across the country.” The suit also alleges that Google and Facebook conspired to further their dominance with a secret agreement, referring to a suit filed by 10 Republican attorneys general in December.
    • HD Media filed in federal court in West Virginia and asked for a jury trial. It asked for unspecified damages and that the court stop Google and Facebook from the uncompetitive conduct it is alleging.
  4. 2021

    Instagram restores posts of film poster and apologizes

    Company response

    After removing posts showing the Madres Paralelas poster for violating its nudity rules, Instagram said it restored posts sharing the poster under an artistic-context exception and apologized for the confusion.

    Company response

    • Apology — Facebook

      We’ve therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we’re really sorry for any confusion caused,
    • Remediation — Facebook

      We’ve therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we’re really sorry for any confusion caused,

    Source excerpt

    • We've therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we´re really sorry for any confusion caused,
    • Instagram has apologised for removing the official poster for Spanish director Pedro Almodóvar's new film from the social network because it showed a female nipple, after the poster's designer complained of censorship.
    • We’ve therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we’re really sorry for any confusion caused,
  5. 2021

    Facebook executive apologizes for mistakenly blocked pages

    Company response

    A Facebook executive apologized for implementation errors in the platform's Australian news-content ban, which also removed pages belonging to charities, businesses and government departments.

    Company response

    • Apology — Facebook

      We are sorry for the mistakes we made in some of the implementation
    • Apology — Facebook

      “This is a really hard thing to do. We’ve never done it before. We are sorry for the mistakes we made in some of the implementation,” Mr Milner said.

    Source excerpt

    • A Facebook executive has apologised for accidentally banning pages not initially meant to be included in the platform's sudden ban on Australian news content.
    • In the process, pages of charities, businesses and government departments were also wiped.
    • Facebook eventually apologized for the "mistake" and restored the posts.
  6. 2021

    Facebook loses bid to block EU-US data-flow decision

    Ruling

    Facebook lost a bid to block a European Union privacy decision that could suspend its ability to send information about European users to U.S. computer servers.

    Source excerpt

    • Facebook Inc. lost a bid to block a European Union privacy decision that could suspend its ability to send information about European users to U.S. computer servers, opening a pathway toward a precedent-setting interruption of its data flows.
  7. 2021

    Arbitrator ordered transfer of lookalike domains to Facebook

    Ruling

    An arbitrator ordered Proofpoint to transfer five lookalike domain names to Facebook within ten business days. The article reports that the domains would be transferred unless a U.S. District Court overturned the decision.

    Source excerpt

    • The Sunnyvale, Calif.-based email security vendor was hit Jan. 25 with a decision from an arbitrator ordering the transfer of five lookalike domain names from Proofpoint to Facebook within ten business days.
    • Security company Proofpoint has sued Facebook in order to keep hold of several typo domains that are deliberately intended to look like its Facebook and Instagram brands.
    • Proofpoint wants an Arizona court to declare that facbook-login.com, facbook-login.net, instagrarn.ai, instagrarn.net and instagrarn.org are not cases of cybersquatting because they were not registered in bad faith.
  8. 2021

    Facebook expands protections for journalists and human-rights defenders

    Company response

    Facebook announced that it would classify activists and journalists as involuntary public figures and expand restrictions on attacks against public figures, aiming to strengthen protections against harassment and bullying.

    Stated objective. To strengthen protection for activists and journalists from harassment and bullying.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Facebook

      面簿将把维权人士与记者列为“非自愿”公众人物(Public Figure),以加强保护他们免受骚扰与霸凌。

    Source excerpt

    • 戴维斯说,面簿也扩大不允许用户对公众人物发动的攻击类型,以减少女性、有色人种与LGBTQ(同性恋、双性恋、跨性别及酷儿)族群面临的诸多攻击。
    • 面簿将把维权人士与记者列为“非自愿”公众人物(Public Figure),以加强保护他们免受骚扰与霸凌。
  9. 2021

    Rhode Island retirement system files lawsuit over Facebook data-privacy scandal

    Lawsuit filed

    The Employees’ Retirement System of Rhode Island filed a lawsuit against certain Facebook officers and board members, alleging breaches of fiduciary duties related to the Facebook-Cambridge Analytica data-privacy scandal and resulting harm to Facebook and its shareholders.

    Source excerpt

    • In the years leading up to the 2016 Presidential election, Facebook user data was obtained by Cambridge Analytica without users’ consent and then used to promote the campaigns of Donald Trump for President, Ted Cruz for Senate, and the pro-Brexit movement.
    • this month, the Employees’ Retirement System of Rhode Island filed a lawsuit against certain officers, including co-founder and CEO Mark Zuckerberg and Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg, and members of the board of directors of Facebook (NYSE: FB) alleging breaches of fiduciary duties pertaining to the Facebook-Cambridge Analytica data-privacy scandal.
  10. 2021

    Meta files lawsuit over phishing attacks targeting its platforms

    Lawsuit filed

    Meta filed a federal lawsuit in California court seeking to disrupt phishing attacks that targeted users of Facebook, Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp. Meta said the campaign used nearly 40,000 websites impersonating the platforms’ login pages to collect users’ credentials.

    Stated objective. to disrupt phishing attacks targeting users of Meta’s platforms

    Source excerpt

    • "On these websites, people were prompted to enter their usernames and passwords, which Defendants collected."
    • Meta (formerly known as Facebook) has filed a federal lawsuit in California court to disrupt phishing attacks targeting Facebook, Messenger, Instagram, and WhatsApp users.
    • The attackers behind these phishing campaigns used almost 40,000 phishing pages that would impersonate the four platforms' login pages.
  11. 2021

    Science Feedback removes erroneous label and apologizes to Reason editor

    Company response

    Science Feedback acknowledged that it had incorrectly applied a false-information rating to a Reason article, removed the label, and apologized. Facebook said its fact-checking partners independently review and rate content and handle appeals.

    Company response

    • Apology — Science Feedback

      The flag has been removed. We apologize for the mistake.

    Source excerpt

    • “Thanks for reaching out and appealing directly to Science Feedback,” was the response he received from Facebook communications manager Ayobami Olugbemiga. “As you know, our fact-checking partners independently review and rate content on our apps and are responsible for processing your appeal.”
    • The flag has been removed. We apologize for the mistake.
    • Soave then reached out to both Facebook and Science Feedback seeking a correction or clarification and the fact-checking organization admitted that it had mistakenly flagged his article and agreed to remove the “false information” label.
  12. 2021

    Federal judge approves $650 million Facebook biometric privacy settlement

    Settlement

    A federal judge in San Francisco approved a $650 million class-action settlement resolving claims that Facebook stored biometric data, including facial scans, without users' approval.

  13. 2021

    Facebook announces removal of posts with false vaccine claims

    Company response

    Facebook announced that it would remove posts containing incorrect claims about vaccines, expanding its policy from down-ranking misleading vaccine information to removing it. The article says the changes followed a Facebook Oversight Board ruling that the company's health-content policy was too vague.

    Source excerpt

    • Facebook announced on Monday that it would remove posts that contain incorrect claims about vaccines, including the conspiracy theory that they cause autism.
    • Facebook's old policy on misleading vaccine information was to down-rank posts, pushing them further down the newsfeed, but now they will be removed entirely.
    • The new changes follow a ruling from the Facebook Oversight Board, an independent body that evaluates decisions made by the company.
  14. 2021

    Instagram teen research findings reported

    Issue disclosure

    A Wall Street Journal report, which Facebook did not dispute, described internal research finding that Instagram worsened body-image concerns and was blamed by some teenagers for increased anxiety and depression.

    Source excerpt

    • Another slide said teenagers blamed Instagram for increased levels of anxiety and depression
    • The Wall Street Journal's report, not disputed by Facebook, finds:
    • The Wall Street Journal said Instagram has had research illustrating this mental stress for two years.
  15. 2021

    Russia fines Facebook and Instagram

    Fine or penalty

    Russia’s communications regulator said Facebook and Instagram had been fined millions of rubles for failing to remove prohibited content and for non-compliance with Russian data-localization legislation.

    Source excerpt

    • The Federal Service for Supervision of Communications, Information Technology and Mass Media of Russia (known as Roskomnadzor) said on Friday that Facebook and Instagram had been fined millions of rubles for not taking down “prohibited” content online.
    • “The total amount of fines for not removing prohibited information is 43 million rubles. For non-compliance with the requirements of Russian data localization legislation – 4 million rubles,”
    • Helen Dixon, Data Protection Commissioner, on fines imposed on Facebook and Instagram following two inquiries into the processing of personal data for the purposes of targeted online advertising.
  16. 2021

    Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp sue over allegedly infringing domain names

    Lawsuit filed

    Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp filed a complaint in Pennsylvania against New Ventures Services Corp. and individuals, alleging that they registered and profited from domain names identical or confusingly similar to the brands’ trademarks. The allegations are claims in the complaint, not court findings.

    Source excerpt

    • On Thursday, social media giant Facebook, as well as its subsidiaries Instagram and WhatsApp (together referred to as Facebook), filed a complaint in the Middle District of Pennsylvania against defendant New Ventures Services, Corp. as well as some unknown individuals
    • The plaintiffs alleged that the Infringing Domain Names “either incorporate Plaintiffs’ Trademarks or are confusingly similar misspellings of Plaintiffs’ Trademarks”
  17. 2021

    Robinson Communications sued Google and Facebook over alleged antitrust conduct

    Lawsuit filed

    Robinson Communications filed a complaint accusing Google of exercising monopoly power in digital advertising and Google and Facebook of conspiring to engage in anticompetitive conduct under the alleged “Jedi Blue” agreement. These are allegations in the complaint.

    Source excerpt

    • According to a Western District of Washington complaint filed on Monday, Robinson Communications Inc. is taking two tech giants for conduct it argues crippled the country’s newspaper industry.
    • The filing both accuses Google LLC of exercising monopoly power of the digital advertising market and both Google and Facebook Inc. of unlawfully conspiring to engage in anticompetitive conduct per the so-called “Jedi Blue” agreement, constituting an automatic violation of the Sherman Act.
    • The publisher claims the social media giants have violated federal antitrust and monopoly laws to an extent that "threatens the extinction of local newspapers across the country."
  18. 2021

    RSF files lawsuit against Facebook over hate speech and false information

    Lawsuit filed

    Reporters Without Borders filed a lawsuit in France against Facebook, accusing it of allowing large-scale proliferation of hate speech, including against journalists, and false information despite promises to provide a safe online environment. The article reports allegations, not a court determination.

    Source excerpt

    • Reporters Without Borders (RSF) has filed a lawsuit against Facebook in France over hate speech and false information, the global media watchdog said in a statement on Tuesday.
    • RSF said that in a lawsuit filed with the public prosecutor in Paris on Monday, it accuses Facebook of allowing large-scale proliferation of hate speech - notably against journalists - and false information despite promises to provide a safe online environment.
    • It added that the suit concerned Facebook France and Facebook Ireland and is based on the French consumer code, under which companies using deceptive commercial practices can be liable to fines of up to 10% of annual turnover.
  19. 2021

    Biden accuses Facebook and other platforms of allowing vaccine misinformation

    Issue disclosure

    U.S. President Joe Biden accused Facebook and other platforms of allowing COVID-19 vaccine misinformation on their services, saying it was causing deaths. The supplied report attributes the allegation to Biden; Facebook did not respond to a request for comment.

    Source excerpt

    • Facebook没有回应置评请求。
    • 周五(7月16日),美国总统拜登表示,Facebook等平台允许在其服务上发布新冠疫苗错误信息,导致人们死亡。
  20. 2021

    CMA investigation into Facebook's Giphy takeover remains ongoing

    Investigation

    The Competition and Markets Authority said its investigation into Facebook's takeover of Giphy remained ongoing.

    Company response

    • Denial — Facebook

      Facebook hit out at the fine in a statement. "We strongly disagree with the CMA's unfair decision to punish Facebook for a best effort compliance approach, which the CMA itself ultimately approved.
    • Ongoing disclosure — Facebook

      "We will review the CMA's decision and consider our options," it added.

    Source excerpt

    • The watchdog also said its investigation into Facebook's takeover of Giphy remains ongoing.
    • Britain’s competition watchdog fined Facebook $69.4 million Wednesday Oct. 20, 2021, for violating rules during the U.K. investigation into the social media giant’s purchase of Giphy.
    • The CMA says that Facebook breached the IEO by “consciously refusing to report all the required information,” resulting in a $70 million fine.