Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile187 entries · Page 3 of 10
2024
32 European media organizations sue Google over advertising technology
Lawsuit filed
A group of 32 European media organizations filed a lawsuit against Google, seeking €2.1 billion in damages. The plaintiffs alleged that Google's advertising technology practices were anticompetitive and had harmed their advertising revenues; these are allegations in the lawsuit, not a determination in this report.
Source excerpt
包括Axel Springer和Schibsted在內的媒體公司稱,由於谷歌(Google)的「反 競爭力」策略,媒體的競爭力下降。
週三(2月28日),由32家 歐洲媒體機構組成的團體對谷歌提起訴訟,要求這家搜索巨頭賠償21億歐元(約22.8億美元),因谷歌的反競爭廣告技術,讓他們收入損失慘重。
2024
Google sued over alleged Pixel 6 Pro overheating defect
Lawsuit filed
Jennifer Hyatt filed a lawsuit in the United States alleging that her Pixel 6 Pro phones continued to overheat after replacements and that the model had a design defect. She alleged Google knew of the defect and failed to warn consumers; she requested an announcement, a recall, and refunds. The source says it was unclear whether the case would proceed to trial.
Source excerpt
Hyatt 认为谷歌对该缺陷知情,并作为证据指出了谷歌官网上的一篇关于防止 Pixel 手机过热的文章。
她表示,谷歌在明知手机存在缺陷的情况下,并未向消费者发出任何警告,反而在宣传中刻意隐瞒了这一问题。
其中一位用户近日在美国提起诉讼,要求谷歌为其 Pixel 6 Pro 的过热问题负责。
2023
School district sues YouTube, TikTok and Snapchat over alleged harm to students
Lawsuit filed
A US school superintendent and school board filed a lawsuit against YouTube, TikTok and Snapchat, alleging that the platforms were designed to be addictive and contributed to a mental health crisis among students. The article reports that the suit also alleges negligence, racketeering, public nuisance and unfair competition law violations.
Company response
Clarification — Google
We have an external group of child development experts that help advise us on how to build age-appropriate experience and protect kids on YouTube
Clarification — TikTok
prioritises the safety and well-being of teens
Clarification — Snap
the company works "closely with leading mental health organisations to provide in-app tools for Snapchatters and resources to help support both themselves and their friends"
Source excerpt
the company works "closely with leading mental health organisations to provide in-app tools for Snapchatters and resources to help support both themselves and their friends"
A US-based school has filed a lawsuit against YouTube, TikTok and Snapchat, alleging they are purposefully designed to be addictive, having "carefully cultivated" a mental health crisis among students.
We have an external group of child development experts that help advise us on how to build age-appropriate experience and protect kids on YouTube
2023
School district sues social media companies
Lawsuit filed
Prince George's County Public Schools filed a lawsuit naming Meta, Google, ByteDance, and Snap Inc. School officials alleged that social media apps contribute to student mental-health challenges and cyberbullying. Google denied the allegations.
Company response
Denial — Google
The allegations in these complaints are simply not true.
Source excerpt
The allegations in these complaints are simply not true.
Meta, Google, ByteDance, and Snap Inc. were all named in the lawsuit.
School officials say apps like Facebook and TikTok are contributing to a student mental health crisis and the rise in cyber-bullying.
2023
Google settles Texas lawsuit over Pixel 4 radio ads
Settlement
Google settled a lawsuit with Texas concerning advertising for the Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL, with Texas receiving $8 million. The lawsuit centered on radio-host endorsements that were described as deceptive because the hosts had not used the products before reading the scripts. The settlement resolved the dispute over the advertisements.
Google settled a lawsuit with Texas over its advertising for the Pixel 4 and Pixel 4 XL, and Texas is receiving $8 million. The lawsuit concerned radio-host endorsements described as deceptive because the hosts had not used the products before reading the scripts.
Source excerpt
Google has settled its second lawsuit surrounding the way it handled advertising for its Pixel 4 and 4 XL smartphones between 2019 and 2020. The state of Texas is receiving $8 million USD (roughly $10.8 million CAD) from the search giant.
Various endorsements of the Pixel 4 line by radio hosts were found to be “deceptive,” as the individuals had not actually used the product prior to reading the scripts they were given.
2023
Google faces class action over alleged AI training data use
Lawsuit filed
A proposed class action lawsuit was filed in federal court in California against Google. The suit alleged that Google scraped data from millions of users without consent and violated copyright laws in order to train and develop its AI products. The report describes these as allegations made in the lawsuit, not as findings established in the supplied report. The filing is recorded as a controversy note concerning Google's alleged use of data for AI training.
A proposed class action lawsuit filed in federal court in California accused Google of scraping data from millions of users without consent and violating copyright laws to train and develop its AI products. These are allegations in the lawsuit, not findings established in the supplied report.
Company response
Denial — Google
Calling the claims “baseless,” Google general counsel Halimah DeLaine Prado denied that the company had been collecting data in secret
Source excerpt
Google was hit with a far-reaching lawsuit on Tuesday that accuses the tech giant of scraping data from millions of users without their consent and violating copyright laws to train and develop its artificial intelligence (AI) products.
The proposed class action suit, filed in a federal court in California by Clarkson Law Firm, targets Google, its parent company Alphabet, and Google's AI subsidiary DeepMind.
The lawsuit, brought forth by public interest law firm Clarkson, names Google, its parent company Alphabet, and AI research subsidiary Google DeepMind as the defendants.
2023
French authority fines Google over search and app-store information
Fine or penalty
France's DGCCRF fined Google two million euros over incomplete information in its search engine and app store. The agency said Google had abused its dominant market position and failed to comply with French consumer law. Google said it regretted that changes it had made were not taken into account and said it was open to working with regulators.
Company response
Remediation — Google
Google has corrected part of the sanctioned shortcomings, but the DGCCRF still imposed the fine.
Source excerpt
The DGCCRF said that Google's practices were "particularly serious" and that the company had abused its dominant position in the market to impose its own services on users.
Google has corrected part of the sanctioned shortcomings, but the DGCCRF still imposed the fine.
Authorities in France Tuesday slapped a two-million-euro ($2.2 million) fine on tech giant Google for not showing complete results in its search engine and app store, in violation of the rights of the French users.
2023
Advocacy groups challenge YouTube and Google’s children’s advertising practices
Public backlash
In 2023, Fairplay, the Center for Digital Democracy, and two other nonprofits filed a complaint with the FTC urging an investigation into Google and YouTube’s data and advertising practices on children’s videos. The complaint raised concerns about how the platforms handle data and advertising in content aimed at children. Google disputed the claims, stating that personalized ads on kids’ content were prohibited. The complaint and Google’s response together frame a public dispute over children’s privacy and advertising on YouTube.
Company response
Denial — Google
Michael Aciman, Google's spokesperson, disputed the claims, emphasizing that personalized ads on kids' content were prohibited and advertisers can't target children.
Clarification — Google
Google reaffirmed adherence to child privacy standards agreed upon with the FTC.
Source excerpt
A recent research report unveiled that YouTube's advertising practices targeted at children's videos might compromise young viewers' privacy.
Consequently, Fairplay, the Center for Digital Democracy, and two nonprofits lodged a complaint with the FTC, urging an investigation into Google and YouTube's data and advertising practices on children's videos.
However, the test resulted in all 1,446 test ads running on the identified "made for kids" channels, according to the report.
2023
Jury finds Google discriminated against Ulku Rowe
Ruling
A jury found Google guilty of sexual discrimination against Google Cloud executive Ulku Rowe and awarded her $1.1 million. The jury reportedly found that she had not proven that Google violated New York law by paying her less than two male counterparts. Google disputed the finding of discrimination and retaliation.
Company response
Denial — Google
We disagree with the jury’s finding that Ms. Rowe was discriminated against on account of her gender or that she was retaliated against for raising concerns about her pay, level, and gender.
Source excerpt
We disagree with the jury’s finding that Ms. Rowe was discriminated against on account of her gender or that she was retaliated against for raising concerns about her pay, level, and gender.
Eventually, as the case was taken to court, a jury decided that Google was guilty of sexual discrimination.
2023
Google receives formal warning in Australian child-safety transparency review
Fine or penalty
In a review of child-safety transparency notices by Australia's eSafety Commissioner, X was fined $610,500 for failing to comply with a notice by not answering some questions or providing answers that were wrong or incomplete. The same article reported that Google received a formal warning for answers that were irrelevant, generic, or non-specific. The report did not describe any further outcome for Google beyond the warning.
Australia’s eSafety Commissioner fined X $610,500, finding that it failed to comply with a notice by not answering some questions or providing answers that were wrong or incomplete. The article also reports that Google received a formal warning for irrelevant, generic, or non-specific answers.
Source excerpt
The report said Google also failed to comply, by providing irrelevant, generic or non-specific answers. It has been given a formal warning.
The commissioner’s report found said Twitter did not comply with its notice, by failing to respond at all to some questions or providing answers that were wrong or incomplete.
The company has been issued with a fine for $610,500, which it has 28 days to pay.
2023
Jury finds Google Play Store payment system anticompetitive
Ruling
In a case brought by Epic Games, a federal court jury found that Google's Android app-store payment system was anticompetitive and harmed consumers and software developers. The judge was to determine remedies, and Google said it would appeal.
Stated objective. Resolve allegations of stifling competition against its Android app store.
Company response
Remediation — Google
Google has agreed to implement changes to make it easier for consumers to download and install Android apps from alternative sources, not limited to its Play Store, over the next five years.
Source excerpt
Epic, which is based in Cary, North Carolina, filed its lawsuit against Google three years ago, alleging that the internet search giant has been abusing its power to shield its Play Store from competition in order to protect a gold mine that makes billions of dollars annually.
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Google lost an antitrust lawsuit over barriers to its Android app store, as a federal court jury has decided that the company's payments system was anticompetitive and damaged smartphone consumers and software developers.
Google said it will appeal the decision.
2023
Google apologizes and changes Google Maps routing after desert detours
Company response
Google Maps directed some drivers traveling between Los Angeles and Las Vegas onto remote desert roads, where drivers were stranded and some vehicles were damaged. Google apologized and said it would no longer route drivers traveling between Las Vegas and Barstow through those roads. Google said drivers making that trip were being routed through the reopened I-15.
After Google Maps directed some drivers between Los Angeles and Las Vegas onto remote desert roads, where drivers were stranded and some vehicles were damaged, Google apologized and said it would no longer route drivers traveling between Las Vegas and Barstow through those roads. Google said drivers making that trip were being routed through the reopened I-15.
Company response
Apology — Google
We apologize for the incident that happened last weekend
Remediation — Google
we'll no longer route drivers traveling between Las Vegas and Barstow down through those roads. Today, drivers making that trip are being routed through I-15, which has been reopened.
Source excerpt
The dangerous detours caused gridlock on some roads and stranded several drivers, including Easler and her family, who were stuck on the desert road for five hours before eventually getting their car towed because of the damage caused by the rough terrain.
Google has issued an apology after sending some drivers using Google Maps to travel between Los Angeles and Las Vegas on dangerous desert road detours, at least one of which turned out to be a road to nowhere that left people stranded.
We apologize for the incident that happened last weekend and can confirm that we'll no longer route drivers traveling between Las Vegas and Barstow down through those roads. Today, drivers making that trip are being routed through I-15, which has been reopened.
2023
YouTuber sues Google Spain over alleged wrongful dismissal
Lawsuit filed
In November 2023, a Spanish YouTuber filed a lawsuit against Google Spain over alleged wrongful dismissal, according to the Spanish union UGT. The union reported the legal action, which concerns the termination of the YouTuber's relationship with the company. The dispute centers on the claim that the dismissal was wrongful. No further details on the outcome of the case, the identity of the claimant, or the specific amounts involved were provided in the source. The matter was reported as a labor dispute between the individual creator and Google's Spanish entity.
A Spanish YouTuber is suing Google Spain over alleged wrongful dismissal, according to Spanish union UGT.
Source excerpt
A Spanish YouTuber is suing Google Spain, a unit of Alphabet Inc, for wrongful dismissal in a case that could set a precedent for content creators' labour rights, Spanish union UGT said on Thursday.
2023
Google agrees to settle incognito-tracking lawsuit
Settlement
Google and its parent Alphabet agreed to a preliminary settlement of a class action lawsuit alleging that Google secretly tracked users’ internet activity while they browsed privately. Settlement terms were not disclosed, and court approval remained pending.
Company response
Denial — Google
Despite the accusations, Google has denied wrongdoing in the case
Source excerpt
Google and its tech conglomerate parent company Alphabet have agreed to settle a lawsuit claiming it secretly tracked the internet use of millions of people who thought they were doing their browsing privately.
US District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers in Oakland, California, put a scheduled 5 February 2024 trial in the proposed class action on hold on Thursday, after lawyers for Google and for consumers said they had reached a preliminary settlement.
The plaintiffs alleged that Google's analytics, cookies and apps let the Alphabet unit track their activity even when they set Google's Chrome browser to 'incognito' mode and other browsers to 'private' browsing mode.
2023
Helena World Chronicle sues Google over AI and publisher content
Lawsuit filed
Arkansas-based publisher Helena World Chronicle filed a class-action antitrust lawsuit against Google in the US District Court in Washington, DC. The publisher alleges that Google's AI technologies siphon publishers' content, readers, and advertising revenue; Google had not commented at the time of the report.
Source excerpt
Google was yet to comment on the lawsuit.
A US-based news publisher has filed a class-action antitrust lawsuit against Google, alleging that the tech giant is "siphoning off" news publishers' content, their readers and ad revenue via its AI technologies.
The lawsuit, filed in the US District Court in Washington, DC, cited new AI technologies like Google's Search Generative Experience (SGE) and Bard AI chatbot as worsening the problem, reports TechCrunch.
2023
Google sues alleged fraudulent DMCA takedown requesters
Lawsuit filed
Google filed a lawsuit alleging that the defendants submitted fraudulent DMCA takedown requests to suppress competitors’ websites and products in Google Search results. The allegations are described in the lawsuit; the article does not report a court determination.
Source excerpt
Google filed the lawsuit against Nguyen Van Duc and Pham Van Thien, who are both said to live in Vietnam, and 20 defendants whose identities are unknown. Google alleged that the defendants “appear to be connected with websites selling printed t-shirts, and their unlawful conduct aims to remove competing third-party sellers from Google Search results.”
2023
Google sues alleged scammers over fake Bard downloads
Lawsuit filed
Google filed a lawsuit in a California federal court against anonymous individuals it accused of marketing fake Bard downloads to install malware. Google said the malware could steal victims’ social-media login credentials and asked the court to block the scheme and award monetary damages.
Source excerpt
Upon downloading the file, users unwittingly installed malicious software on their devices, granting scammers access to their social media accounts.
In a lawsuit lodged in the Northern District of California, Google alleged that the scammers established social media accounts to encourage people to download a counterfeit version of Bard.
Technology company, Google, on Monday, said it is taking legal action against two groups of scammers.
2023
Arkansas mother files game-addiction lawsuit against gaming companies
Lawsuit filed
An Arkansas mother filed a lawsuit against Microsoft, Nintendo and Google, alleging that gaming companies intentionally designed games to be addictive to minors and that engagement tracking and in-game offers contributed to addictive behavior. The allegations had not been confirmed in the article.
Source excerpt
An Arkansas mother is taking a bold legal step against tech giants such as Microsoft, Nintendo, and Google in a lawsuit addressing the issue of game addiction.
It remains to be seen whether the allegations made will be confirmed.
As reported by KATV, the lawsuit was filed on November 3, and it alleges that major gaming companies have intentionally designed games to be addictive to minors, using artificial intelligence to analyze players' behaviors and track their engagement.
2023
Match and Google settle Play Store lawsuit
Settlement
Match and Google settled Match's US lawsuit alleging anticompetitive practices involving Google Play Store's billing policy. Under the agreement, Match will adopt Google's User Choice Billing and receive the return of $40 million held in escrow.
Source excerpt
As per the settlement, Match (Tinder, Hinge, OKCupid, Match.com) will adopt Google’s User Choice Billing, which allows developers to include their own choice of payment system for in-app purchases alongside Google’s billing system and pay Google a slightly reduced commission (4% less) if users pay through the alternative billing system. The $40 million placed in escrow will also be returned to Match as per the agreement.
Match and Google settled the lawsuit filed by the Tinder parent against Google in the US over alleged anticompetitive practices involving Play Store’s billing policy, Match said in its shareholders letter dated October 31.
2023
Widow sues Google over directions to collapsed bridge
Lawsuit filed
Alicia Paxson filed a lawsuit against Google and others after her husband died when he drove off a collapsed bridge while following Google directions. The lawsuit alleges negligence; the claims have not been determined in court.
Company response
Investigation — Google
“Our goal is to provide accurate routing information in Maps and we are reviewing this lawsuit.”
Source excerpt
The lawsuit reportedly alleges negligence and seeks a jury trial.
A North Carolina woman is suing Google after her husband died last year when he drove off a collapsed bridge while following GPS directions, according to multiple reports.
Paxson did not know the bridge had collapsed and was following directions from Google, which did not indicate that the bridge was down (via NBC News):