Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile94 entries · Page 3 of 5
2023
Hold Security sues Microsoft over alleged credential misuse
Lawsuit filed
Hold Security sued Microsoft in King County Superior Court, alleging that Microsoft misused a database of stolen account credentials beyond the scope of their agreement and retaliated against Hold. Microsoft said the allegations mischaracterized the contract and that it would seek dismissal.
Company response
Denial — Microsoft
Because the claims in the lawsuit do not accurately reflect the contract’s terms, Microsoft will be seeking a dismissal of the claims.
Source excerpt
The Redmond-based company says it will seek to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Hold Security this week in King County Superior Court in Seattle.
The firm, Hold Security LLC, based in the Milwaukee area, says Microsoft didn’t keep its promise to destroy its copies of credentials not associated with Microsoft logins after using them to help secure its own customers.
2023
Microsoft agrees to pay $20 million to settle FTC charges
Settlement
Microsoft will pay $20 million to settle government charges concerning the collection and retention of personal information from children without parental consent. The FTC alleged that Microsoft collected the information through Xbox sign-ups from 2015 to 2020.
Company response
Remediation — Xbox
The company signaled compliance with the fine and announced an update to its account creation process that will require children under 13 to have a legal and verified parent or guardian provide consent for the account’s creation.
Source excerpt
Further, Microsoft must take additional steps to strengthen privacy protections for minor children who use Xbox consoles and Xbox Live, subject to that order’s approval by a federal judge.
The FTC announced the penalty on Monday. The monetary settlement covers violations of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act of 1998 (COPPA), which involve “children who signed up to [the] Xbox gaming system without notifying their parents or obtaining their parents’ consent, and by illegally retaining children’s personal information,” the FTC said in a statement.
That “glitch” was fixed, and the data since deleted.
2023
UK regulator blocks Microsoft–Activision Blizzard merger
Ban or restriction
The UK's Competition and Markets Authority decided not to approve the proposed Microsoft–Activision Blizzard merger. The report says the regulator was concerned about competition in cloud gaming and the potential effects on UK players.
Source excerpt
CMA在报告中裁定,微软在自家游戏订阅服务Xbox Game Pass上提供动视暴雪游戏对某些客户可能有益,但无法抵销合并对竞争造成的损害
CMA还认为,微软提出的方案未能有效解决云游戏领域的担忧,且存在重大缺陷。
4月26日,针对微软收购动视暴雪这一交易,英国竞争与市场管理局(CMA)拒绝批准。
2023
Microsoft fined for sanctions violations
Fine or penalty
The US Treasury and Commerce Departments ordered Microsoft to pay over $3 million in fines after its products and services reached blacklisted companies and individuals, including in Crimea. US authorities cited failures to obtain accurate end-customer information and possible intentional circumvention of screening controls by some employees. The Treasury Department also acknowledged that Microsoft discovered, investigated, and self-reported the violations.
Company response
Investigation — Microsoft
Microsoft self-discovered the violations, investigated them, and self-reported them to the government.
Ongoing disclosure — Microsoft
we voluntarily disclosed them to the appropriate authorities
Remediation — Microsoft
the company has also made significant changes to its enforcement policies and measures.
Source excerpt
the company has also made significant changes to its enforcement policies and measures.
The violations reportedly took place between July 2012 and April 2019
The settlement is related to the company’s potential civil liability arising due to exporting its services and products from the United States to sanctioned jurisdictions or blocked persons, violating the agency’s sanctions programs.
2022
Microsoft agrees to undertakings on Xbox subscriptions in Britain
Settlement
In a controversy note concerning Microsoft's Xbox subscriptions in Britain, the UK Competition and Markets Authority said it secured undertakings from Microsoft. According to the regulator, the undertakings concern Xbox subscription auto-renewals, price-rise information, cancellation assistance for inactive customers and pro-rata refunds. The source report is dated 26 January 2022.
Stated objective. The CMA said the undertakings would help gamers avoid paying for services they no longer use.
Company response
Clarification — Microsoft
Microsoft has also agreed to provide clear and timely information on price hikes, and help inactive Xbox customers end their subscriptions if required and claim a pro-rata refund, the CMA said.
Source excerpt
That would help gamers avoid paying for services they no longer use.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) said it had secured undertakings from the U.S. tech giant to inform customers upfront about auto-renewals for Xbox Live Gold and Game Pass subscriptions.
Microsoft has also agreed to provide clear and timely information on price hikes, and help inactive Xbox customers end their subscriptions if required and claim a pro-rata refund, the CMA said.
2022
Microsoft agrees to changes to Xbox subscription practices in Britain
Settlement
The UK's Competition and Markets Authority obtained undertakings from Microsoft regarding concerns about Xbox subscription auto-renewals. Under the commitments, Microsoft agreed to provide upfront information about auto-renewal, contact inactive customers with guidance on stopping payments, give clearer notice of future price increases, and offer eligible annual subscribers an option to end their contracts and claim pro-rata refunds. The undertakings addressed the competition authority's concerns about how the subscription practices were presented to customers.
The UK's Competition and Markets Authority secured undertakings from Microsoft addressing concerns about Xbox subscription auto-renewals. Microsoft agreed to provide upfront auto-renewal information, contact inactive customers with guidance on stopping payments, give clearer notice of future price hikes, and offer eligible annual subscribers an option to end contracts and claim pro-rata refunds.
Stated objective. Clearer information will help gamers avoid being charged for services they have stopped using.
Company response
Clarification — Microsoft
Microsoft has also agreed to contact inactive customers to remind them how to stop payments and provide clearer notifications about future price hikes.
Refund or compensation — Microsoft
Additionally, existing customers on recurring one-year subscriptions will be given an option to end their contracts and claim pro-rata refunds.
Source excerpt
Additionally, existing customers on recurring one-year subscriptions will be given an option to end their contracts and claim pro-rata refunds.
Microsoft will begin offering more information to customers about how it automatically renews Xbox online gaming subscriptions in Britain, the UK's competition watchdog said on Wednesday.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) secured undertakings from Microsoft for the U.S. tech giant to tell customers upfront about auto-renewals for Xbox Live Gold and Game Pass subscriptions that start at 7 pounds ($9.50) a month.
2022
Microsoft reverses Microsoft Store policy on open-source pricing
Company response
In July 2022, Microsoft revised its Microsoft Store policies after receiving negative feedback regarding a ban on selling open-source software. The original policy had restricted the sale of open-source software in the Microsoft Store. Following the criticism, Microsoft updated the policies to remove references to open-source pricing. The change was reported by BetaNews, which noted that Microsoft had changed its policy against the sale of open-source software in the Microsoft Store.
After negative feedback over a ban on selling open-source software in the Microsoft Store, Microsoft updated its policies to remove references to open-source pricing.
Stated objective. Microsoft said the previous policy was intended to help protect customers from misleading product listings.
Company response
Clarification — Microsoft
Microsoft has also clarified just why it put the ban in place.
Remediation — Microsoft
In a statement Microsoft said that it had "introduced key changes to our cookie practices even before this investigation started."
Clarification — Microsoft
"We continue to respectfully be concerned with the CNIL's position on advertising fraud," it said, adding that it believes the French watchdog's "position will harm French individuals and businesses."
Source excerpt
Having previously upset software developers by implementing a ban on the sale of open source software in its app store, Microsoft has reversed its decision.
The company says that it has listened to feedback -- which was vocal and negative -- and has updated the Microsoft Stores Policies, removing references to open source pricing.
The French regulator said that after investigations it found that “when users visited this site, cookies were deposited on their terminal without their consent, while these cookies were used, among others, for advertising purposes.”
2022
RealD sues Microsoft over alleged use of its display-imaging technology
Lawsuit filed
RealD Spark LLC filed a lawsuit accusing Microsoft of breach of contract, trade-secret theft and patent infringement relating to RealD's SocialEyes video-conferencing technology. The allegations are claims in the complaint, not findings of liability.
Source excerpt
Consumer display technology company RealD Spark LLC accused Microsoft Corporation of stealing its proprietary video conferencing innovation in a breach of contract, theft of trade secrets, and patent infringement suit filed on Wednesday.
2022
Microsoft-Activision Blizzard deal faces EU and UK antitrust investigations
Investigation
Microsoft's proposed $69 billion acquisition of Activision Blizzard was reported to face in-depth investigations by antitrust regulators in the European Union and the United Kingdom amid concerns that the deal could be anti-competitive.
Source excerpt
北京时间9月16日下午消息
拟议的微软(Microsoft)690亿美元收购游戏发行商动视暴雪(Activision Blizzard)的交易将面临欧盟(EU)和英国反垄断监管机构的深入调查,因为人们越来越担心这笔交易可能会被证明是反竞争的。
2022
Microsoft fined over advertising cookies on Bing
Fine or penalty
France's National Commission for Information Technology and Civil Liberties fined Microsoft €60 million for advertising-cookie regulation violations on Bing. The regulator said cookies were placed on users' devices without consent and users lacked the required option to accept or decline them.
Source excerpt
cookies were placed on their terminal without their consent
The National Commission for Information Technology and Civil Liberties in France has fined Microsoft Inc. €60 million ($64 million) for violating regulations about advertising cookies on its search engine Bing, Al Bawaba reports.
2022
FTC sues to block Microsoft's acquisition of Activision Blizzard
Lawsuit filed
The U.S. Federal Trade Commission filed a complaint seeking to block Microsoft's proposed acquisition of Activision Blizzard, citing concerns that the deal could harm competition. Microsoft said it would fight the FTC's challenge.
Company response
Denial — Microsoft
Microsoft President Brad Smith said the company would fight the FTC.
Denial — Microsoft
我们对FTC继续追查这个明显薄弱的案件感到失望,我们反对进一步推迟案件进展的努力。
Source excerpt
Microsoft President Brad Smith said the company would fight the FTC.
Published On 8 Dec 20228 Dec 2022
The United States trade regulator has filed a complaint aimed at blocking tech giant Microsoft’s $69bn bid to buy “Call of Duty” games maker Activision over concerns the deal would deny rivals access to popular games.
2022
German regulators report concerns about Microsoft 365 GDPR compliance
Issue disclosure
A working group of German data protection regulators reported that Microsoft 365 may be incompatible with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The group stated that Microsoft had not resolved its compliance concerns so far. The report raised questions about whether the productivity suite meets GDPR requirements, and the working group indicated that the concerns remained unresolved at the time of the report.
Company response
Clarification — Microsoft
“We respectfully disagree with the concerns raised by the [DSK] and have already implemented many suggested changes to our data protection terms. We remain committed to working with the DSK to address any remaining concerns.”
Source excerpt
After looking into the software for around two years, a working group of German data protection regulators has found that Microsoft 365 may be incompatible with GDPR – and that Microsoft has not resolved any of the compliance concerns raised by the group so far.
In response to the German report, Microsoft told TechCrunch that its 365 products “meet the highest industry standards for the protection of privacy and data security”.
“We respectfully disagree with the concerns raised by the [DSK] and have already implemented many suggested changes to our data protection terms. We remain committed to working with the DSK to address any remaining concerns.”
2022
Class action lawsuit filed over GitHub Copilot
Lawsuit filed
Programmer and designer Matthew Butterick filed a class action lawsuit against GitHub, Microsoft, and OpenAI challenging the legality of GitHub Copilot and alleging that the defendants violated creators’ rights by training AI systems on code shared under open-source licences.
Source excerpt
Programmer/designer Matthew Butterick filed the case Thursday in San Francisco, saying it was on behalf of millions of GitHub users potentially affected by the $10-a-month Copilot service:
The lawsuit seeks to challenge the legality of GitHub Copilot, as well as OpenAI Codex which powers the AI tool, and has been filed against GitHub, its owner Microsoft, and OpenAI....
By training their AI systems on public GitHub repositories (though based on their public statements, possibly much more), we contend that the defendants have violated the legal rights of a vast number of creators who posted code or other work under certain open-source licences on GitHub,
2022
Microsoft confirms potential customer data exposure
Issue disclosure
Microsoft confirmed that a misconfigured server resulted in the potential for unauthenticated access to some business transaction data related to interactions with prospective customers. Microsoft said it found no indication that customer accounts or systems were affected and disputed SOCRadar's estimates of the scope.
Company response
Clarification — Microsoft
Microsoft has held its hands up and accepted the misconfigured server exposed data, but also suggested that SOCRadar “greatly exaggerated the scope of this issue.”
Source excerpt
Microsoft has held its hands up and accepted the misconfigured server exposed data, but also suggested that SOCRadar “greatly exaggerated the scope of this issue.”
Microsoft has confirmed that sensitive information pertaining to customers may have been exposed due to a misconfigured server.
This week, Microsoft confirmed in a that the issue “resulted in the potential for unauthenticated access to some business transaction data corresponding to interactions between Microsoft and prospective customers.”
2022
Microsoft sends Word Window a trademark opposition letter
Issue disclosure
Word Window founder Kate McKenzie said Microsoft sent her a letter concerning the product's name and threatened opposition to the Word Window trademark shortly before its planned launch. The article reports an ongoing dispute and negotiations; it does not report a filed lawsuit or a determination of infringement.
Source excerpt
It was basically a threat of opposition against the trademark Word Windows. They weren't happy about the trademark and they weren't happy about the company name.
She filed the patent for Word Window in October 2020 but received a "without prejudice" letter from Microsoft nine days before the launch on July 1.
McKenzie explained that the letter was a threat of opposition against the trademark Word Windows.
2022
DuckDuckGo browser allows Microsoft trackers under an agreement
Issue disclosure
A report said DuckDuckGo's browser allowed Microsoft-owned Bing and LinkedIn trackers to track browser users' activities. DuckDuckGo CEO Gabriel Weinberg acknowledged that the company could not block the trackers under its agreement with Microsoft and said it would discuss changing the contract terms.
Company response
Clarification — DuckDuckGo
DuckDuckGo's founder and CEO, Gabriel Weinberg, admitted that they could not block its trackers as per Microsoft's agreement. He further added that the company would be talking with Microsoft about modifying the clauses in the contract to maintain users' privacy and confidentiality.
Remediation — DuckDuckGo
Gabriel Weinberg has also said that more measures will be put in place to stop third-party trackers associated with Microsoft.
Source excerpt
The browser purposely allows third-party Microsoft trackers due to an agreement with Redmond.
Zach Edwards discovered that while DuckDuckGo blocks the Google and Facebook trackers, it allows the trackers of Microsoft owned Bing and LinkedIn to track searchers' activities on the browser.
DuckDuckGo's founder and CEO, Gabriel Weinberg, admitted that they could not block its trackers as per Microsoft's agreement. He further added that the company would be talking with Microsoft about modifying the clauses in the contract to maintain users' privacy and confidentiality.
2022
Microsoft outlines European cloud principles and licensing changes
Company response
Microsoft outlined European Cloud Principles and announced planned changes to its Cloud Solution Provider program and Windows Server licensing after criticism from European cloud providers and increased regulatory scrutiny. It said the changes would make licensing easier for virtual environments and expand support for European providers.
Stated objective. Better support European cloud providers and make it easier to license Windows Server for virtual environments.
Company response
Clarification — Microsoft
Microsoft has outlined a new set of European Cloud Principles in response to criticism from rival European cloud providers and increasing regulatory scrutiny.
Remediation — Microsoft
Microsoft has also pledged to make it easier to license Windows Server for virtual environments by relaxing the licensing rules “that reflected legacy software licensing practices, where licenses are tied to physical hardware.”
Source excerpt
Microsoft also announced it would be expanding the Microsoft Cloud Solution Provider program, to better support European cloud providers.
Microsoft has outlined a new set of European Cloud Principles in response to criticism from rival European cloud providers and increasing regulatory scrutiny.
As a result, customers who were running Windows Server on AWS or Google Cloud were charged more than those running it on Azure.
2022
Arigna Technology sues seven companies over Qualcomm components
Lawsuit filed
Arigna Technology filed a complaint in the Western District of Texas against Alphabet, Apple, Lenovo, Microsoft, OnePlus, Samsung, and TCL, alleging that their devices incorporated Qualcomm envelope-tracking modules covered by its patent.
Source excerpt
Arigna's new case, over the '835 patent, has been assigned to District Judge Alan D. Albright. 2/10, Western District of Texas.
Arigna Technology Limited, one of several plaintiffs associated with Dublin-based patent monetization firm Atlantic IP, has filed a single complaint against Alphabet (Google), Apple, Lenovo, Microsoft, OnePlus, Samsung, and TCL (6:22-cv-00151) in the Western District of Texas.
infringement accusations in Arigna's complaint target various devices and computers (e.g., desktops, laptops, tablets, and smartphones) of the defendants over their alleged incorporation of the Qualcomm QET4100 and/or QET5100-series envelope tracking modules.
2022
Microsoft pledges policy review and public release of investigation results
Company response
Microsoft announced a review of its sexual-harassment and gender-discrimination policies and said it would publicly release results of investigations into allegations involving board members and senior leadership. The board said Microsoft would hire a third-party law firm to conduct the review.
Stated objective. assess the company’s practices, benchmark those policies against best practices adopted by other companies, and look at steps taken to hold employees and executives accountable
Company response
Investigation — Microsoft
The board announced that Microsoft would hire a third-party law firm to conduct a review
Source excerpt
The board announced that Microsoft would hire a third-party law firm to conduct a review
Microsoft will review of its policies regarding sexual harassment and gender discrimination, as well as publicly releasing the results of investigations into allegations involving members of the board of directors and senior leadership, including Bill Gates, the company announced Thursday.
The report follows a shareholder directive passed last year. The resolution called for a report on the effectiveness of the company's workplace sexual-harassment policies in light of claims of sexual harassment, including allegations that Gates sought inappropriate relationships with employees.
2021
Microsoft discloses Nobelium cyberattack and employee-account compromise
Issue disclosure
Microsoft reported a cyberattack campaign that it attributed to Nobelium. According to Microsoft, the group compromised Microsoft employee accounts and obtained software instructions governing how Microsoft verifies user identities. Microsoft stated that it removed the access and secured the affected device. The disclosure described the incident as a cyberattack campaign linked to Nobelium and addressed the compromise of employee accounts and the acquisition of identity-verification software instructions, along with the remedial steps the company said it took.
Microsoft reported a cyberattack campaign attributed to Nobelium and said the group had compromised Microsoft employee accounts and taken software instructions governing how Microsoft verifies user identities. Microsoft said it removed the access and secured the affected device.
Company response
Remediation — Microsoft
responded quickly, removed the access, and secured the device.
Source excerpt
Microsoft later said that the group had compromised its own employee accounts and taken software instructions governing how Microsoft verifies user identities.
The threat actor, which Microsoft identified as Nobelium, “used this information in some cases to launch highly-targeted attacks as part of their broader campaign.”
responded quickly, removed the access, and secured the device.