Skip to content

Twitter

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile76 entries · Page 2 of 4

  1. 2023

    Indian government restricts airing of BBC documentary

    Ban or restriction

    The article reports that the Indian government used emergency powers to order Twitter and YouTube to block content related to the BBC documentary The Modi Question, and intervened in attempts to screen it in India.

    Source excerpt

    • The government has claimed that the documentary, which is based on detailed research and interviews with multiple witnesses and experts, is propaganda, and has since used its Information and Technology law, and the emergency powers contained within it, to order Twitter and YouTube to block content related to the documentary on their platforms.
  2. 2023

    HateAid and EUJS sue Twitter over reported tweets

    Lawsuit filed

    HateAid and the European Union of Jewish Students filed a civil lawsuit against Twitter in Berlin, alleging that the platform failed to act immediately on reported racist and antisemitic tweets. The Berlin court later allowed the case to move forward.

    Company response

    • Denial — Twitter

      Twitter dismissed accusations made in The Guardian’s article on Monday about the six tweets, saying the report is “extremely misleading.”

    Source excerpt

    • HateAid and EUJS filed the civil action lawsuit against Twitter on January 25 in Berlin District Court, saying that Twitter’s failure to act immediately against these tweets violates the platform’s Rules and Policies, which are part of the Terms of Service for users.
    • The Berlin court recently determined the legitimacy of the case, allowing it to move forward, and Twitter has now been sent and received the lawsuit, EUJS said on Tuesday.
    • Twitter dismissed accusations made in The Guardian’s article on Monday about the six tweets, saying the report is “extremely misleading.”
  3. 2023

    UK employees sue Twitter over alleged unlawful firings

    Lawsuit filed

    A group of employees from Twitter's UK offices filed a lawsuit alleging that their firings were unlawful.

    Source excerpt

    • A group of employees from Twitter’s United Kingdom offices has filed a lawsuit against the company, alleging that they had been illegally fired.
    • Unlike rival social medias TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and Snapchat, Twitter has not bought licences for music featuring on the site, giving it an “unfair advantage,” publishers said.
    • Plaintiffs, including the likes of Universal Music and Sony, asked the court to sue Twitter for up to US$150,000 for each of the near 1,700 song violations.
  4. 2023

    Twitter sued over alleged failure to give contract workers layoff notice

    Lawsuit filed

    A proposed class action filed in federal court in San Francisco accused Twitter of laying off contract workers employed by TEKsystems without the 60 days’ advance notice allegedly required by US and California law. Twitter has denied wrongdoing.

    Stated objective. Support dismissed and remaining Twitter employees.

    Company response

    • Denial — Twitter

    Source excerpt

    • Twitter Inc. faced a lawsuit on Tuesday accusing the social media giant of illegally laying off contract workers without notice after Elon Musk bought the company last year, the latest action stemming from its massive job cuts.
    • The proposed class action, filed in San Francisco federal court, claims Twitter in November laid off numerous workers employed by staffing firm TEKsystems Inc. without the 60 days of advance notice required by U.S. and California law.
    • 上周六(2月11日)上午,民众聚集在推特总部外,抗议马斯克(Elon Musk)裁减数千名推特员工。
  5. 2022

    Dispute over Elon Musk's acquisition agreement

    Musk attempted to withdraw from the agreed acquisition, citing concerns including the prevalence of automated and spam accounts. Twitter sued to enforce the agreement, and the matter ended when Musk completed the purchase in October 2022.

  6. 2022

    Twitter sues Elon Musk over merger agreement

    Lawsuit filed

    In a legal dispute over the merger agreement, Twitter filed a lawsuit against Elon Musk in Delaware. The company alleged that Musk breached the $44 billion purchase agreement. Twitter asked the court to require him to complete the merger. The action was reported on July 12, 2022.

    Twitter sued Elon Musk in Delaware, alleging that he breached the $44 billion purchase agreement, and asked the court to require him to complete the merger.

    Stated objective. Twitter asked the court to order Musk to complete the merger.

    Source excerpt

    • Twitter Inc. sued Elon Musk on Tuesday for violating the $44-billion US deal to buy the social media platform and asked a Delaware court to order the world's richest person to complete the merger at the agreed $54.20 US per Twitter share, according to a court filing.
    • The lawsuit accused Musk of "a long list" of violations of the merger agreement that "have cast a pall over Twitter and its business."
    • The social media company filed a lawsuit against the world’s richest man on Tuesday, saying that he is refusing to “honor his obligations” under their agreement and seeking to make him complete the deal.
  7. 2022

    Twitter responds to Elliot Page deadname trending

    Company response

    In July 2022, after Elliot Page's deadname trended on Twitter, the company stated that the term should not have appeared in Trends. Twitter said it had removed the term and prohibited it from appearing there again, and described the incident as a mistake.

    After Elliot Page’s deadname trended on Twitter, the company said it should not have appeared in Trends, said it had been removed and prohibited from appearing there, and called the incident a mistake.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Twitter

      The term you referenced should not have been allowed to appear in trends, and it has since been removed and prohibited from appearing in trend.

    Source excerpt

    • The suspension, however, led to a wave of anti-trans hate directed at Page, which led to more deadnaming.
    • Twitter spokesperson Trenton Kennedy told that allowing Elliot Page’s deadname to trend was a mistake and one that Twitter rectified.
    • The term you referenced should not have been allowed to appear in trends, and it has since been removed and prohibited from appearing in trend.
  8. 2022

    Former Twitter security head alleges foreign agents worked at the company

    Issue disclosure

    In September 2022, former Twitter security head Peiter Zatko testified before a U.S. Senate committee, alleging that foreign agents worked at Twitter and that the company's cyber defenses were weak. Twitter rejected the allegations, describing them as a false narrative and stating that its hiring process was not subject to foreign influence. The dispute centered on Zatko's claims about the company's security practices and workforce, which Twitter disputed.

    Company response

    • Denial — 推特

      推特则回应说,扎特科对公司的指控是“虚假叙述”,“充斥着前后矛盾和不准确之处”。

    Source excerpt

    • 推特则回应说,扎特科对公司的指控是“虚假叙述”,“充斥着前后矛盾和不准确之处”。
    • 被推特公司解雇的前安全主管佩特·扎特科当地时间13日出席参议院司法委员会一场听证会,陈述自己对老东家推特公司的上述指控。
    • 他称,推特在网络防御方面的力量很薄弱,公司高层也不愿付出努力“根除外国特工”。
  9. 2022

    Ireland's privacy regulator expands inquiry to Twitter data breach

    Investigation

    Ireland's Data Protection Commission announced that it would expand its inquiry into Twitter to include a recently disclosed data breach that may affect more than 400 million users. The regulator said it would examine Twitter's compliance with data-protection law in relation to the security issue.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Twitter

      the 0-day vulnerability has been patched
    • Ongoing disclosure — Twitter

      Twitter said it was notifying every affected user

    Source excerpt

    • The DPC indicated today that it will expand the scope of the inquiry to include the latest data breach disclosed this week.
    • Ireland’s privacy regulator today announced that it will examine a recently disclosed data breach that may affect more than 400 million Twitter Inc. users.
    • The DPC has engaged with Twitter in this inquiry and will examine Twitter’s compliance with data-protection law in relation to that security issue.
  10. 2022

    Twitter seeks dismissal of disability bias lawsuit

    Lawsuit filed

    Twitter asked a federal judge in California to dismiss a proposed class action alleging that its return-to-office mandate and expectations of long working hours discriminated against employees with disabilities. Twitter argued that the plaintiffs had not alleged actions targeted at people with disabilities or a disproportionate impact on them.

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit claims Musk’s ultimatum violated the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), which requires employers to offer reasonable accommodations to workers with disabilities.
    • Twitter’s lawyers late Wednesday filed a motion to dismiss the November lawsuit, saying the plaintiffs had not alleged that any of the company’s actions were targeted at people with disabilities or had a disproportionate impact on them.
    • 他因拒绝到办公室报到被推特解雇,并已于周三在旧金山联邦法院对该公司提起集体诉讼。诉讼称,许多推特残疾员工被迫辞职,因为他们无法达到马斯克要求的绩效和生产力标准。
  11. 2022

    PJS sues Twitter over unpaid flight charges

    Lawsuit filed

    Private Jet Services Group filed a lawsuit against Twitter alleging that Twitter refused to pay $197,725 for flights provided to an executive in October. The claims include breach of contract and breach of quasi-contract; the allegations are not established as findings.

    Source excerpt

    • Private Jet Services Group, LLC (PJS) filed the lawsuit in the U.S. District Court for the District of New Hampshire on Friday, stating that Twitter has refused to pay $197,725 that it is owed for flights that executive Leslie Berland took from Teterboro Airport in New Jersey to San Francisco and back on Oct. 26 and 27.
    • PJS is suing on grounds of breach of contract and breach of quasi-contract.
    • Private Jet Services Group is suing Twitter for over $200,000 in flight fees for two flights taken by former employees just before Elon Musk's takeover of the company.
  12. 2022

    Twitter stops enforcing its COVID-19 misinformation policy

    Issue disclosure

    Twitter said it was no longer enforcing its COVID-19 misleading information policy, effective November 23, 2022. The change was reported as a discontinuation of the policy's enforcement. The article notes the change and speculates that reduced moderation staffing may have contributed. No further details on the policy's removal or its consequences were provided in the source.

    Source excerpt

    • Effective Nov. 23, 2022, Twitter is no longer enforcing the Covid-19 misleading information policy.
  13. 2022

    U.S. national security review of Twitter acquisition

    Investigation

    The article reports that Elon Musk’s $44 billion acquisition of Twitter still faces U.S. national security review amid concerns that foreign partners could access user data.

    Source excerpt

    • 埃隆(Elon Musk)斥资440亿美元收购推特的交易仍面临马斯克的国家安全审查,因为美政府担心他的外国合作伙伴可能能够访问用户数据。
  14. 2022

    Twitter adds an “Official” label to some accounts to combat impersonation

    Company response

    Twitter Support said that Twitter had added an “Official” label to some accounts to combat impersonation amid reports of imposter accounts spreading misinformation.

    Source excerpt

    • Further, Twitter Support tweeted, "To combat impersonation, we've added an 'Official' label to some accounts."
    • Two days after its launch, Twitter has decided to suspend the $8 subscription program for its verification badge. The move triggered a lot of imposter accounts emulating major brands, reports say.
  15. 2022

    Twitter takeover faces backlash over Saudi financing

    Public backlash

    Elon Musk's Twitter purchase faced public criticism over funding from Saudi investor Kingdom Holding Company, amid concerns raised by critics about Saudi Arabia's record on free expression and human rights.

    Source excerpt

    • In a press release, Alwaleed confirmed that his company's shares in Twitter will "roll over" to the "'new' Twitter," making the company the social media giant's second-largest investor—only behind Musk.
    • Saudi Arabia has faced accusations of stifling free expression and alleged human rights abuses within their borders—and abroad.
    • Elon Musk's Twitter purchase is facing backlash for receiving funding from Saudi Arabian Prince Alwaleed bin Talal.
  16. 2022

    FTC and DOJ order Twitter to pay $150 million

    Fine or penalty

    The FTC and DOJ ordered Twitter to pay a $150 million penalty for violating a 2011 FTC order. The article says Twitter allowed advertisers to use account security data for marketing purposes, contrary to what users had been told.

    Source excerpt

    • from 2014 to 2019, almost 150 million users provided personal information under the impression that they were doing so to secure their accounts. Instead of using the information solely for account security purposes, as disclosed to users, the social media giant allowed advertisers to target “specific ads to specific consumers by matching the information with data they already had or obtained from data brokers” in violation of their standing FTC order.
    • The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Department of Justice (DOJ) recently ordered Twitter to pay $150 million for violating a 2011 FTC order that prohibited the company from misrepresenting its privacy and data security practices.
  17. 2022

    Twitter faces a $150 million US fine over users' data use

    Fine or penalty

    US law-enforcement officials accused Twitter of illegally using users’ personal information to sell targeted advertising. The article reports that Twitter must pay a $150 million fine; the proposed settlement also includes compliance measures.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Twitter

      In reaching this settlement, we have paid a USD 150M USD penalty, and we have aligned with the agency on operational updates and program enhancements to ensure that people’s personal data remains secure and their privacy protected.
    • Clarification — Twitter

      In a statement, Twitter's Chief Privacy Officer Damien Kieran said the company has "cooperated with the FTC every step of the way."

    Source excerpt

    • Twitter in the US must pay a $150m (£119m) fine after law enforcement officials accused it of illegally using users' data to help sell targeted ads.
    • As the complaint notes, Twitter obtained data from users on the pretext of harnessing it for security purposes, but then ended up also using the data to target users with ads,
    • It accuses Twitter of breaching a 2011 FTC order that explicitly prohibited the company from misrepresenting its privacy and security practices.
  18. 2022

    George Galloway sues Twitter over account label

    Lawsuit filed

    George Galloway filed a High Court action in Dublin against Twitter, alleging defamation and unlawful processing of his personal data in connection with a label applied to his account.

    Source excerpt

    • The politician and broadcaster is also claiming in the legal proceedings that the social media company unlawfully processed his personal data by labelling and censoring his account.
    • Former British Labour MP George Galloway has taken a High Court action in Dublin against Twitter for defamation after it labelled his account "Russian state-affiliated media".
  19. 2022

    Twitter sues Indian government over block orders

    Lawsuit filed

    Twitter sued the Indian government in Karnataka High Court, alleging that it abused its power by ordering arbitrary and disproportionate removal of tweets and accounts.

    Source excerpt

    • Twitter on Tuesday filed a lawsuit against the Indian government, pushing back against orders to censor content on its platform.
    • Twitter has sued the Indian government to challenge some of the block orders on tweets and accounts, further escalating the tension in the key overseas market.
    • In its lawsuit, filed Tuesday in the Karnataka High Court in Bengaluru, Twitter alleges that New Delhi had abused its power by ordering it to arbitrarily and disproportionately remove several tweets from its platform.
  20. 2021

    Twitter faces criticism over Pelosi tweet moderation

    Public backlash

    In January 2021, Twitter users criticized the platform over its handling of a 2017 tweet by Nancy Pelosi that resurfaced and remained available on the site. The users described the moderation as inconsistent, contrasting the continued availability of the Pelosi tweet with Twitter's suspension of Donald Trump's account. The criticism centered on the platform's moderation standards rather than on any specific action taken regarding the Pelosi tweet.

    Twitter users criticized the platform for what they described as inconsistent moderation after a 2017 Nancy Pelosi tweet resurfaced and remained available, contrasting it with Twitter's suspension of Donald Trump's account.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Twitter

      The operator of the popular microblogging platform said it will now focus on “context, not fact-checking” when deciding whether to rule a tweet to be in violation of its policies.

    Source excerpt

    • Netizens have accused Twitter of double standards, reacting angrily to a resurfaced tweet by House Speaker Nancy Pelosi from May 2017 and containing claims the 2016 US presidential election "was hijacked".
    • Many Twitter users questioned the social media platform's consistency, arguing that Pelosi's tweet "incites violence", something used by Twitter as a pretext to permanently suspend US President Donald Trump's personal account last week.
    • “We are NOT attempting to address all misinformation,” Twitter says in one of the messages, posted under its Twitter Safety banner.