Skip to content

Apple

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile178 entries · Page 2 of 9

  1. 2024

    Apple Maps incorrectly lists Queensland restaurant as permanently closed

    Issue disclosure

    A report stated that Apple Maps listed a Thai restaurant on Queensland's Sunshine Coast as permanently closed. According to the report, the restaurant's owners said the error severely affected their livelihood. The report also said that after contacting Apple support, they had difficulty correcting the listing. The report did not specify how or when the listing was changed, nor did it describe any response or resolution from Apple.

    A report says Apple Maps listed a Thai restaurant on Queensland’s Sunshine Coast as permanently closed, and the restaurant’s owners said the error severely affected their livelihood. The report says they had difficulty correcting the listing after contacting Apple support.

    Source excerpt

    • Chris Pyatt才發現他們的餐廳營業資訊在蘋果(Apple)的Apple地圖上顯示「永久關閉」。震驚之餘,更讓他們的生計受到極大影響。
    • Chris Pyatt致電蘋果客服卻收到非蘋果客戶而無法給予協助,後續雖然按照蘋果說明透過瀏覽器更新他的
  2. 2024

    Apple’s App Store policy draws developer criticism

    Public backlash

    In January 2024, Apple introduced changes to its App Store payment policies that drew sharp criticism from software developers. Critics argued that a 27% commission on purchases made through alternative payment methods would increase costs for developers and consumers. The reporting describes the criticism directed at the policy; it does not present a legal determination on the matter.

    Apple’s new App Store payment policies drew sharp criticism from software developers, who argued that the 27% commission on purchases made through alternative payment methods would increase costs for developers and consumers. The article reports the criticism, not a legal determination.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple’s new fees have drawn sharp criticism from the app-developer community, with opponents arguing the 27% commission the company will now impose on in-app purchases made through alternative payment methods will cost developers and, ultimately consumers, more money.
    • Apple’s new App Store payment policies are stirring outrage among software developers who say the iPhone maker is skirting the intention of a court ruling.
  3. 2024

    Apple updates App Store guidelines on music links and game emulators

    Company response

    Apple updated its App Store guidelines to allow music streaming apps in the European Economic Area to link to websites containing alternative purchasing information, and to permit retro game console emulator apps to offer game downloads. According to the source, the change to the music-app rule complied with an anti-steering mandate from the European Commission and followed the Commission's fine against Apple for anti-competitive conduct.

    Stated objective. Comply with an anti-steering mandate levied by the European Commission.

    Source excerpt

    • In addition to updating its streaming music rules, Apple today also added games from retro game console emulator apps to the list of permitted software allowable under guideline 4.7.
    • Apple today updated its App Store guidelines to comply with an anti-steering mandate levied by the European Commission.
    • The European Commission in March fined Apple $2 billion for anti-competitive conduct against rival music streaming services.
  4. 2024

    Apple rebuts allegations in US antitrust case

    Company response

    In March 2024, Apple responded to antitrust allegations brought by the US Department of Justice. Apple rebutted the allegations, stating that its rules and restrictions were intended to protect user privacy, safety and experience. The company presented this position as its answer to the government's claims, framing its policies as measures designed for user protection rather than as conduct harmful to competition.

    Apple responded to the US Department of Justice's antitrust allegations, rebutting them and saying its rules and restrictions were intended to protect user privacy, safety and experience.

    Company response

    • Denial — 苹果公司

      苹果公司最近发布了回应,并逐一反驳了所有指控。
    • Denial — Apple

      Apple said in a statement that it disagreed with the premise of the lawsuit and that it would defend against it.
    • Denial — Apple

      We believe this lawsuit is wrong on the facts and the law, and we will vigorously defend against it.

    Source excerpt

    • 对此,苹果公司回应称这种说法具有误导性,并强调所有规则和限制都是为了保护用户隐私、安全和体验。
    • 日前,美国司法部对苹果公司提起反垄断诉讼,指责其在智能手机市场的垄断行为。根据《谢尔曼反托拉斯法》第二条,司法部指控苹果公司在七个方面存在违反行为。苹果公司最近发布了回应,并逐一反驳了所有指控。
    • The US Justice Department, along with over a dozen states, has filed a significant antitrust lawsuit against Apple, alleging that the tech giant has unlawfully monopolized the smartphone market.
  5. 2024

    EU opens Digital Markets Act investigations into Google, Apple and Meta

    Investigation

    The European Commission opened investigations into whether Alphabet, Google, Apple and Meta comply with the Digital Markets Act. Regulators raised concerns about app-store practices, search rankings, browser choice and Meta's options for ad-free services and data use.

    Stated objective. To determine whether the companies are complying with the Digital Markets Act.

    Source excerpt

    • European Union regulators on Monday launched probes into whether Apple, Google and Meta are violating the bloc’s tough new rules to combat the anticompetitive practices of Big Tech.
    • The European Commission said it opened investigations into Alphabet, Google’s parent company, as well as Apple and Meta to determine whether they are complying with the Digital Markets Act, which went into force earlier this month.
    • In a statement on March 25, the commission, which is executive of the 27-nation European Union bloc said that it was investigating Alphabet's rules on steering in Google Play and self-preferencing on Google Search, Apple's rules on steering in the App Store and the choice screen for Safari and Meta's "pay or consent model".
  6. 2024

    Court denies Apple’s motion to dismiss AirTag stalking lawsuit

    Ruling

    A San Francisco federal judge denied Apple’s request to dismiss a class-action lawsuit alleging that AirTags were used for stalking, ruling that the suit had sufficient claims of negligence and product liability against Apple.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple's request to dismiss the class-action lawsuit over alleged use of its AirTags for stalking was denied after a US Federal Court ruled in favor of the plaintiffs, Bloomberg reported.
    • San Francisco District Judge Vince Chhabria ruled on Friday that the lawsuit has sufficient claims that there was negligence and product liability on Apple's part with the stalking.
    • 根据彭博社报道,美国加州一名法官Vince Chhabria在当地时间周五裁定,三名原告已经就疏忽和产品责任提出了充分的索赔。
  7. 2024

    Apple settles shareholder lawsuit over China sales comments

    Settlement

    Apple settled a class-action lawsuit for $490 million over allegations that Tim Cook misled investors about iPhone demand in China in 2018. The settlement was reported in a preliminary filing and requires approval by a U.S. district judge.

    Source excerpt

    • This week, Apple has settled a class-action lawsuit to the tune of $490 million USD over allegations of defrauding investors.
    • The lawsuit against Apple alleges that Tim Cook intentionally mislead investors about the iPhone's underperforming demand in China before lowering production in the region.
    • The settlement of this lawsuit was reported this week in a preliminary filing with the U.S. District Court in Oakland, California. It will require approval by presiding U.S. District Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers
  8. 2024

    European Commission fines Apple over music subscription restrictions

    Fine or penalty

    The European Commission imposed a €1.84 billion fine on Apple over its ban on developers fully informing iOS users about alternative and cheaper music subscription services outside the app. The Commission said Apple abused its dominant position in the distribution of music streaming apps through the App Store.

    Company response

    • Denial — Apple

      Apple rejects the findings and will appeal the decision
    • Clarification — Apple

      Apple says the EU has found no evidence of consumer harm, and “ignores the reality of a market that is thriving, competitive and growing fast”.

    Source excerpt

    • In a statement from the EU’s competition chief Margrethe Vestager, the company was said to have “abused its dominant position in the market for the distribution of music streaming apps through the App Store.”
    • The fine of 1.84 billion euros was imposed on Apple for its ban on developers from “fully informing iOS users about alternative and cheaper music subscription services outside of the app”.
    • Apple rejects the findings and will appeal the decision, as indicated by its just-published strongly worded press release.
  9. 2024

    Backlash over Apple’s “Crush” ad

    Public backlash

    Apple’s iPad Pro advertisement “Crush” drew criticism from celebrities and viewers over its depiction of creative objects being crushed.

    Company response

    • Apology — Apple

      Apple issued an apology
    • Clarification — Apple

      Tor Myhren, VP of marketing communications at Apple, acknowledged the misstep, emphasizing the company's commitment to fostering creativity worldwide.
    • Apology — Apple

      We missed the mark with this video, and we’re sorry.
    • Apology — Apple

      “We missed the mark with this video, and we’re sorry,” the company told AdAge.

    Source excerpt

    • The advertisement's reception among viewers mirrored the sentiments of the celebrities, with many expressing disappointment and concern over its message.
    • Reacting to the backlash, Apple issued an apology and withdrew the ad from television airings.
    • Our goal is to always celebrate the myriad of ways users express themselves and bring their ideas to life through iPad. We missed the mark with this video, and we’re sorry
  10. 2024

    Apple faces criticism over iPad Pro advertisement

    Public backlash

    Apple's iPad Pro advertisement, which showed an industrial press crushing creative objects to promote the new iPads, drew online criticism. Critics described it as destructive and said it depicted symbols of human creativity being crushed. Apple had not immediately responded to a request for comment at the time of the report.

    Stated objective. To promote its new, ultra-thin iPads.

    Source excerpt

    • many people on social media were quick to criticize the commercial, calling it “destructive” and saying it is “crushing symbols of human creativity and cultural achievements to appeal to pro creators.”
    • To promote its new, ultra-thin iPads, the tech giant on Tuesday released an ad in which an industrial press crushes an array of creative objects to birth a new iPad.
    • The company's iPad Pro commercial, which debuted Tuesday, was met with criticism online.
  11. 2024

    Apple responds to iPhone parts-serialization controversy

    Company response

    Apple’s hardware engineering chief said in an interview that iPhones remain compatible with many third-party parts and that Apple’s parts pairing is used to identify components and calibrate them. He said Apple blocks pairing third-party parts for security-related Face ID and Touch ID functions.

    Company response

    • Clarification — 苹果公司

      很多消费者误以为我们 [苹果] 以某种方式,阻止 iPhone 中使用第三方零部件,但事实上我们并没有这样做过。

    Source excerpt

    • 很多消费者误以为我们 [苹果] 以某种方式,阻止 iPhone 中使用第三方零部件,但事实上我们并没有这样做过。
    • 特纳斯表示出于安全方面的考虑,我们禁止配对 Face ID 和 Touch ID 相关的第三方部件:
    • 在宣布这一消息的同时,苹果公司硬件工程主管约翰・特纳斯(John Ternus)接受了 TechCrunch 的采访,谈到了 iPhone 备受争议的“零件序列化”过程。
  12. 2024

    Users complain about Siri after iOS 17.4 update

    Public backlash

    A PTT user complained that after updating to iOS 17.4, Siri stopped directly displaying and explaining answers to some conversion questions and instead opened a webpage; the report says other users also discussed the complaint.

    Source excerpt

    • 然而在他更新到iOS 17.4後,卻僅僅跳出一個網頁讓使用者自己看。
    • 然而一名PTT網友卻以「ios17.4的Siri變蠢了?」為題在iOS版發文,抱怨iOS系統更新後Siri反而變得更難用,引起許多網友討論。
  13. 2024

    Apple reverses decision to block Epic Games in the EU

    Company response

    Apple reversed its decision to block Epic Games from launching a competing platform in the EU and permitted Epic Sweden AB to re-sign its developer agreement and join the Apple Developer Program. The change followed an EU investigation announcement and conversations with Epic.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple has quite suddenly changed its mind with regards to its choice to ban Fortnite maker Epic Games from launching a competing platform to the App Store in Europe.
    • Officials from the European Union had only just announced that they were starting an investigation into the App Store competition battle when Apple changed directions.
    • “Epic Sweden AB has been permitted to re-sign the developer agreement and accepted into the Apple Developer Program,” explained Apple in a recent statement on the matter.
  14. 2024

    Apple sues former employee over alleged leaks

    Lawsuit filed

    Apple sued former employee Andrew Aude in California state court, alleging that he breached a confidentiality agreement and violated labor laws by leaking sensitive information to media and employees at other technology companies. Apple is seeking damages in excess of $25,000.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple has filed a lawsuit against Andrew Aude, a former iOS Software Engineer, accusing him of leaking “information about more than a half-dozen different Apple policies and products.”
    • The lawsuit, filed in California this month and embedded below, includes several examples of Aude’s leaks over the years at Apple.
    • Apple this month sued its former employee Andrew Aude in California state court, alleging that he breached the company's confidentiality agreement and violated labor laws by leaking sensitive information to the media and employees at other tech companies.
  15. 2024

    European Commission seeks information on Apple’s web-app change

    Investigation

    The European Commission said it was examining Apple’s decision to remove home-screen web apps in Europe and had requested information from Apple and affected app developers. The information-gathering process could lead to a formal investigation.

    Stated objective. Assess Apple’s compliance with the Digital Markets Act.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple is removing the ability to install home screen web apps in Europe when iOS 17.4 is released, claiming it is too hard to keep offering the feature under the European Union’s new Digital Markets Act (DMA).
    • The EC confirmed it is seeking information from Apple and app developers who would be affected by the change, kicking off a process that could lead to a formal investigation.
    • Apple’s move seems designed to prevent web apps from becoming a viable competitor to the App Store model in which developers pay Apple commissions of up to 30 percent.
  16. 2024

    SEC rules against Apple’s bid to exclude shareholder proposal

    Ruling

    The SEC ruled against Apple’s bid to exclude from its 2024 annual-meeting proxy materials a shareholder proposal seeking an investigation and report on the company’s app-content curation standards and procedures.

    Source excerpt

    • The SEC message explained, “We are unable to concur in your view that the Company [Apple] may exclude the Proposal under Rule 14a-8(i)(10). In our view, the Company has not substantially implemented the Proposal.”
    • SEC ruled against Apple’s bid to exclude that proposal from its proxy materials for its 2024 Annual Shareholders Meeting.
    • ADF noted a goal for “Apple to investigate and report on how it is protecting the free speech and freedom of religion of its users from government interference.”
  17. 2023

    Italy's AGCM opens probe into Apple over alleged app-market abuse

    Investigation

    In 2023, Italy's antitrust agency AGCM opened a probe into Apple over alleged abuse of its dominant position in the apps market. According to AGCM, Apple disadvantaged third-party app developers through a more restrictive privacy policy and differences in the quality of data made available. The investigation concerns Apple's conduct in the apps market and its treatment of third-party developers relative to the privacy policy and data quality described by the agency.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Apple

      We respectfully disagree with the court's ruling on the one remaining claim under state law and are considering further review.

    Source excerpt

    • The watchdog said Apple penalized third-party app developers by imposing “a more restrictive privacy policy” than it applies to itself, from April 2021.
    • ROME — Italy’s antitrust agency AGCM said on Thursday it had opened a probe into U.S. technology giant Apple Inc for alleged abuse of its dominant position in the apps market.
    • As Bloomberg reports, the US Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court ruling, which rejected most of Epic's claims that Apple violated federal competition law by prohibiting alternative app stores on its devices.
  18. 2023

    Apple Beijing company fined over iPhone upgrade-plan advertisement

    Fine or penalty

    In 2023, Beijing market regulators fined Apple Electronics Products Trading (Beijing) Co., Ltd. 30,000 yuan over an advertisement for its iPhone upgrade plan. The regulators found that the homepage advertisement failed to clearly disclose that the plan could not be combined with business discounts, which could potentially mislead consumers. The fine concerned the advertisement's disclosure of the plan's terms rather than the plan itself.

    Source excerpt

    • 根据北京市市场监督管理局的调查结果,苹果电子产品商贸(北京)有限公司的广告行为违反了广告法相关规定。
    • 因此,市场监管部门决定对该公司处以3万元的罚款。
    • 该公司未在主页广告中明确标明与商务折扣不能同时享受的限制条件,导致消费者可能被误导。
  19. 2023

    Digital Will sues Apple over developer account termination

    Lawsuit filed

    Digital Will filed a five-count lawsuit against Apple, alleging intentional interference with contract relations and other claims. The suit concerns Apple's termination of Digital Will's Apple Developer Program account.

    Source excerpt

    • The article notes that the has filed a 5-count lawsuit against Apple:
    • the Japanese company Digital Will is suing Apple for intentional interference with contract relations and more.
  20. 2023

    Apple faces criticism over blocking Beeper Mini

    Public backlash

    In December 2023, Apple faced criticism after making a change that stopped the messaging app Beeper Mini from working, and the company said it would continue doing so. U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren criticized the move, describing it as an example of technology companies suppressing competitors to protect profits. The event centered on Apple's action against Beeper Mini and the public criticism that followed from the senator.

    Apple changed something that stopped Beeper Mini from working and said it would continue doing so. U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren criticized the move, describing it as an example of technology companies suppressing competitors to protect profits.

    Source excerpt

    • 苹果的决定已经引起了至少一位立法者的关注,美国参议员伊丽莎白·沃伦批评苹果关闭 Beeper Mini 的举动。
    • 这位马萨诸塞州参议员表示,这是科技公司“通过压制竞争对手来保护利润”的又一个例子。
    • 上周,Beeper Mini 首次亮相,作为一种将 Android 用户连接到 iMessage 的便捷方式,而无需交出他们的 Apple ID 凭据。然而,几天后,苹果做出了一项改变,停止了 Beeper Mini 的工作,并承诺将继续这样做。