Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile178 entries · Page 3 of 9
2023
Customers sue Apple over mobile payments competition
Lawsuit filed
Four customers filed a proposed class action lawsuit against Apple. The lawsuit alleged that Apple's agreements with Venmo and Cash App restricted competition in peer-to-peer payment apps and contributed to rapidly inflating prices. These are allegations in the lawsuit.
Company response
Denial — Apple
the company would never “do anything to intentionally shorten the life of any Apple product, or degrade the user experience to drive customer upgrades”
Source excerpt
The filing accuses Apple of having violated US antitrust law by way of the agreements it had with mobile payments providers Venmo and Cash App.
PayPal’s Venmo and Block’s Cash App customers have sued Apple Inc. in a proposed class action lawsuit accusing the iPhone maker of having required consumers to pay “rapidly inflating prices” by manipulating mobile payments market competition.
We believe this lawsuit is wrong on the facts and the law, and we will vigorously defend against it,
2023
Labor complaint filed against Apple over union-worker benefits
Investigation
A regional director of the U.S. National Labor Relations Board filed a complaint alleging that Apple violated federal labor law by refusing higher benefits to union employees at a Towson, Maryland, retail store. The complaint centers on the denial of increased benefits to unionized workers at that location. The filing was reported on November 22, 2023.
Source excerpt
美国国家劳工关系委员会的一名地区主任向联邦劳工委员会提出了申诉,指责苹果违反了联邦劳动法,并拒绝为马里兰州陶森市的一家苹果零售店的工会员工提供更高的福利。
2023
Appeals court pauses import ban on Apple Watch models
Ruling
The U.S. Court of Appeals paused the import ban on certain Apple Watch products following Apple's appeal. The decision allowed sales of Apple Watch Series 9 and Ultra 2 to resume while U.S. Customs and Border Protection considers whether Apple's changes would avoid the patent dispute underlying the ban.
Source excerpt
The U.S. Court of Appeals on Wednesday paused a ban on certain Apple Watch products that had been banned by the International Trade Commission because of a patent dispute ruling.
The decision allows sales of its Apple Watch Series 9 and Ultra 2 products to resume.
10月美國國際貿易委員會(International Trade Commission,ITC)支持法院一月的判決,仍然認定蘋果侵權,並已頒布禁售令
2023
Apple clarifies App Store rules in response to phone-listening claim
Company response
Apple contacted iMore to clarify that apps must obtain explicit consent and indicate when recording user activity, responding to claims that Cox Media Group could listen to conversations through devices and sell the information.
Company response
Clarification — Apple
Now Apple has contacted iMore to clarify that this would be in breach of its App Store guidelines.
Source excerpt
Apps must request explicit user consent and provide a clear visual and/or audible indication when recording, logging, or otherwise making a record of user activity.
Cox Media Group Local Solutions -- a marketing company connected to one of the biggest telecom companies in the US -- claims it can listen to conversations through phones and other devices and was selling that information, iMore reported last week. Now Apple has contacted iMore to clarify that this would be in breach of its App Store guidelines.
2023
EU court orders reconsideration of Apple tax-aid case
Ruling
The European Court of Justice determined that the EU General Court had made legal errors and instructed it to reconsider its decision in the case concerning alleged preferential tax treatment for Apple in Ireland. Apple said it believed the earlier ruling should be upheld.
Company response
Denial — Apple
The General Court’s ruling was very clear that Apple received no selective advantage and no state aid, and we believe that should be upheld.
Source excerpt
The General Court’s ruling was very clear that Apple received no selective advantage and no state aid, and we believe that should be upheld.
In 2016, the European Commission accused Apple of receiving preferential treatment and enjoying tax cuts in Ireland, with the company being subjected to a 1% corporate tax rate instead of the standard 12.5%, contravening EU fair competition rules.
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) determined that the EU General Court had made several legal mistakes and has instructed a reconsideration of its decision.
2023
Apple settles DOJ hiring discrimination allegations
Settlement
Apple agreed to pay $25 million to resolve U.S. Department of Justice allegations that it discriminated in hiring for certain positions by favoring immigrant workers over U.S. citizens and green card holders. The DOJ said Apple violated federal law; Apple said it had unintentionally not followed the DOJ standard. Apple also described a remediation plan and agreed to align recruitment practices for PERM jobs with its normal procedures, broaden recruitment, and train employees on anti-discrimination laws.
Stated objective. Apple said its remediation plan aims to ensure adherence to government agencies' standards.
Company response
Remediation — Apple
The company highlighted the implementation of a comprehensive remediation plan aimed at ensuring adherence to various government agencies' standards
Remediation — Apple
Apple has agreed to align its recruiting practices for PERM jobs with its normal procedures. The company will also undertake broader recruitment efforts and provide training for employees on anti-discrimination laws
Source excerpt
The DOJ made the announcement on Thursday, 9 November 2023, marking the largest-ever settlement by the company in a case involving discrimination based on citizenship.
The Justice Department issued a statement asserting that Apple violated federal law by neglecting to recruit U.S. citizens or permanent residents for positions eligible for a federal program enabling employers to sponsor immigrant workers for green cards.
In a groundbreaking settlement, technology giant Apple Inc. will pay $25 million to resolve allegations by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) that the company engaged in discriminatory hiring practices favoring immigrant workers over U.S. citizens and green card holders for specific job positions.
2023
Apple acknowledges iPhone 15 overheating issue
Hazard disclosure
Apple said it had identified conditions that could cause iPhone devices to run warmer than expected, amid complaints about iPhone 15 models overheating. Apple said it was working on an iOS 17 update to address the issue.
Company response
Remediation — Apple
The US company said it was working on an update to the iOS17 system that powers the iPhone 15 lineup to prevent the devices from becoming uncomfortably hot
Source excerpt
Apple is blaming a software bug and other issues tied to popular apps such as Instagram and Uber for causing its recently released iPhone 15 models to heat up and spark complaints about becoming too hot to handle.
The US company said it was working on an update to the iOS17 system that powers the iPhone 15 lineup to prevent the devices from becoming uncomfortably hot
2023
Apple France retail unions call strike over pay and working conditions
Public backlash
Apple retail unions in France called for a strike on September 22–23 after a disagreement over pay and working conditions. The unions sought a 7% wage increase, while Apple reportedly offered 4.5%.
Source excerpt
Apple retail unions, which include CGT, Unsa, CFDT and Cidre-CFTC, are demanding a 7 per cent wage increase to compensate for inflation, however Apple have reportedly only offered a 4.5 per cent pay increase.
Apple employees in France plan to walk out this weekend during the launch of the iPhone 15 following a disagreement about pay and working conditions.
“Management having decided to ignore our perfectly legitimate demands and concerns, the four unions of Apple Retail France... call for a strike on 22-23 September,” CGT Apple Retail said in a statement on social media platform X, formerly Twitter, on Wednesday.
2023
Apple customer-service image draws criticism in China
Public backlash
Apple faced online discussion after an image of a customer-service representative on its website prompted some people to say it could be discriminatory toward Chinese people. The article also reports that Apple customer service had received feedback and took it seriously.
Source excerpt
蘋果官網專家一對一選購頁面上一名客服人員的辮子引發了一些類似於清朝“豬尾巴”的聯想。有人認為這涉嫌歧視中國人。
本文發表前,蘋果客服表示已收到反饋,也很重視,後續可以關注官網的回應。
2023
French regulator asks Apple to withdraw iPhone 12 from sale
Ban or restriction
France’s ANFR said testing found that the iPhone 12 exceeded the permitted level of electromagnetic energy absorbed by the body and asked Apple to withdraw the model from the French market. ANFR said Apple must correct affected phones already sold or recall them.
Source excerpt
路透社报导,巴罗告诉《巴黎人报》报,法国国家频率管理局(ANFR)通知苹果公司决定禁止销售iPhone 12,因测试显示该机型的特定吸收比率(Specific Absorption Rate,SAR)略高于法律允许水平。
(巴黎13日讯)美国苹果公司发布新的iPhone 15之际,法国数码经济部部长巴罗在《巴黎人报》当地时间周二发表的采访中表示,由于iPhone 12的辐射水平超过阈值,苹果公司必须停止在法国销售该机型。
法国国家频率管理局(ANFR)通知苹果公司决定禁止销售iPhone 12,因测试显示该机型的特定吸收比率(Specific Absorption Rate,SAR)略高于法律允许水平。
2023
Court allows Apple’s lawsuit against Rivos to proceed
Ruling
A California district court ruled that Apple could continue its lawsuit against Rivos and three former employees. Apple alleges that former employees stole trade secrets for Rivos to use in designing custom SoC processors; the ruling also rejected Apple's claims against seven other former employees, while allowing Apple to refile amended claims.
Source excerpt
苹果公司认为,有充足的证据表明公司前雇员为 Rivos 公司窃取商业机密,而 Rivos 公司再将这些机密用于设计、定制其片上系统(SoC)处理器。
圣何塞地区法院的爱德华・达维拉(Edward Davila)法官裁定,苹果公司可以继续维权,对三名前雇员和 Rivos 展开诉讼。
2023
Potential settlement reached in Caltech patent case against Apple and Broadcom
Settlement
Caltech reached a potential settlement in its patent lawsuit against Apple and Broadcom over Wi-Fi chips, according to a court filing. The report said it was unclear whether the agreement involved both companies; the settlement details were not disclosed.
Source excerpt
It was unclear if the agreement involved both Apple and Broadcom.
The California Institute of Technology has reached a "potential settlement" in a high-stakes patent infringement lawsuit against Apple and Broadcom over Wi-Fi chips, according to a Thursday filing in federal court.
The details of the settlement are unknown, but Caltech has agreed to dismiss the case “with prejudice,” meaning it can’t be refiled.
2023
Russian court fines Apple and Wikimedia over hosted content
Fine or penalty
A Moscow court fined Apple 400,000 roubles for not deleting content it described as inaccurate about the war in Ukraine. The sources also report a fine against the Wikimedia Foundation for the same offence, but give different amounts: 3 million roubles in one report and 300,000 roubles in another.
Source excerpt
A Moscow court fined Apple 400,000 roubles ($4,274) on Thursday for not deleting “inaccurate” content about what Russia calls a “special military operation” in Ukraine, Russian news agencies reported.
The Wikimedia Foundation was also found guilty of the same offense, per Reuters, and assessed a fine of 300,000 rubles, or just under $32,000, for hosting "inaccurate" content.
A Moscow court fined Apple 400,000 roubles ($4,274) on Thursday for not deleting "inaccurate" content about what Russia calls a "special military operation" in Ukraine on apps and podcast...
2023
Spain's antitrust watchdog fines Amazon and Apple
Fine or penalty
Spain's antitrust watchdog said it imposed fines totaling 194.1 million euros on Amazon and Apple for colluding to limit online sales of Apple and competitors' devices in Spain. The companies said they intended to appeal.
Company response
Denial — Amazon
“We reject the suggestion made by CNMC that Amazon benefits from excluding sellers from its market place, as our business model hinges precisely on the success of the companies selling through Amazon,” the Amazon spokesperson said in an emailed statement.
Source excerpt
Spokespeople from Apple and Amazon separately said their respective companies intend to appeal the fines.
MADRID—Spain’s antitrust watchdog on Tuesday said it had imposed fines worth a total 194.1 million euros ($218.03 million) on Amazon and Apple for colluding to limit the online sale of devices from Apple and competitors in Spain.
“We reject the suggestion made by CNMC that Amazon benefits from excluding sellers from its market place, as our business model hinges precisely on the success of the companies selling through Amazon,” the Amazon spokesperson said in an emailed statement.
2023
Court grants Apple a stay in Epic Games case
Ruling
Apple won a 90-day stay of the requirement to allow developers to direct users to alternate payment options while it prepares an appeal to the US Supreme Court. The article reports the stay; it does not identify the court in the quoted passage.
Stated objective. give the company time to file
Source excerpt
Apple has won a 90-day hold on the requirement that it comply with the courts’ ruling and allow developers to direct users to alternate payment options to give the company time to file.
Both courts did, however, agree with Epic on one count, namely that developers should be allowed to direct customers to alternate payment methods instead of exclusively using Apple’s in-store options.
2023
CNIL fines Apple over App Store ad-personalisation consent
Fine or penalty
France’s privacy watchdog CNIL imposed an €8 million fine on Apple, citing shortcomings in user consent related to ad personalisation. CNIL said iPhone advertising-targeting settings were pre-checked by default even though this was not necessary for the device to function.
Source excerpt
CNIL determined that the complaint was valid and that the user had to perform “a large number of actions” to deactivate this setting.
France’s data privacy regulator, CNIL, has imposed an €8m fine on Apple over privacy violations that occurred on the company’s App Store.
"The advertising targeting settings available from the "Settings" icon of the iPhone were pre-checked by default", the CNIL said in a statement, even though that was not strictly necessary for the device's functioning.
2023
Concerns raised about explicit content on Kindle
Issue disclosure
Apple and Alphabet raised concerns with Amazon about sexually explicit content available through the Kindle app that children could access. Amazon said it was reviewing the information and taking action based on its findings.
Company response
Investigation — Amazon
We are reviewing all of the available information and are taking action based on our findings
Source excerpt
Amazon released a statement and said that they are taking this seriously as they are fully committed to providing a safe shopping and reading experience for their customers, especially children. "We are reviewing all of the available information and are taking action based on our findings," the statement added.
Apple and Alphabet have raised concerns with Amazon after exposing sexually explicit content in the Kindle app, which children can access.
2023
Appeals court throws out $502 million VirnetX verdict against Apple
Ruling
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit threw out a $502 million verdict for VirnetX against Apple after the Patent Trial and Appeal Board canceled the VPN patents VirnetX had accused Apple of infringing.
Source excerpt
Apple Inc on Friday convinced a U.S. appeals court to throw out a $502 million verdict for patent licensing company VirnetX Inc in a long-running fight over internet privacy technology.
Apple on Thursday won a U.S. appeals court decision to uphold a patent tribunal’s ruling that that imperils a $502 million verdict for patent licensing company VirnetX in the companies’ long-running fight over privacy-software technology.
2023
Actor sues Apple over vaccination mandate
Lawsuit filed
Actor Brent Sexton sued Apple LLC, alleging that Apple Studios withdrew a series role offer after he declined COVID-19 vaccination for medical reasons and requested an accommodation. These are allegations stated in the suit; the source reports no determination.
Source excerpt
Former “Deadwood” actor Brent Sexton is suing Apple LLC, alleging the company rescinded an offer to have him star in a new series because he declined to take the coronavirus vaccine due to medical reasons, costing him nearly $600,000.
An Apple representative did not immediately reply to a request for comment on the suit brought Monday.
2023
Users report persistent iOS 16 bugs
Issue disclosure
Users reported numerous bugs and performance problems in iOS 16, including after the iOS 16.2 update. Reported issues included app freezes, camera failures, and HomeKit accessory problems.
Source excerpt
推出四个月后,用户反映 iOS 16 仍然存在大量 Bug,包括键盘弹出过慢、随机重启、UI 故障、相机冻结等等。
在 Twitter、Reddit、MacRumors 论坛和苹果支持官网,用户反映在最近的 iOS 16 更新后遇到了异常多的错误和系统性能不佳的问题。