Skip to content

Apple

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile181 entries · Page 5 of 10

  1. 2022

    Russia fines Apple for failure to localize Russian users' personal data

    Fine or penalty

    In 2022, a Moscow magistrate's court found Apple Inc. guilty of refusing to localize Russian users' personal data in Russia and fined the company two million rubles. The ruling addressed Apple's failure to comply with the requirement to store Russian users' personal data within Russia. The court's decision was reported by RAPSI, a Russian legal news agency. The event is recorded as a regulatory and legal action concerning data localization obligations for the company in Russia.

    Source excerpt

    • MOSCOW, July 12 (RAPSI) – Apple Inc was fined 2 million rubles (over $32,500) on Tuesday for refusal to store Russian users’ data on the territory of Russia, RAPSI was told in the press service of Moscow’s Tagansky District Court.
    • The company was found guilty of breaching the Russian personal data legislation, the court held.
    • A magistrate's court in Moscow's Tagansky district has found Apple Inc. guilty of the refusal to localize personal data of Russian users on Russian territory, an Interfax correspondent reported from the courtroom.
  2. 2022

    Brazil orders Apple to stop selling iPhones without chargers

    Ban or restriction

    In September 2022, Brazil's Ministry of Justice ordered Apple to stop selling iPhones without chargers. Brazilian officials said that selling the phones without a power adapter provided customers with an incomplete product and was a deliberate discriminatory practice toward consumers. The order was reported in connection with the charger-less iPhone sales.

    Company response

    • Ongoing disclosure — Apple

      Apple has not complied with that order as it is appealing the ruling, with the company also planning to appeal today's Sao Paulo decision.

    Source excerpt

    • Brazilian authorities ordered "the immediate suspension of the distribution of iPhone brand smartphones, regardless of model or generation, that are not accompanied by a battery charger."
    • Apple has been barred from selling iPhones without a charger in Brazil and fined more than $2 million over the issue, the government said on Tuesday (Wednesday in Manila)
    • In addition to a fine of R$ 12.275 million (~$2.34 million), the Ministry of Justice ordered Apple to stop sales of all iPhone models that don’t include a power adapter.
  3. 2022

    French court orders Apple to pay €1 million over app developer terms

    Fine or penalty

    A French court ordered Apple to pay €1 million for imposing unfair conditions on app developers and to bring its practices in line with new European Union regulations. Apple said it would examine the ruling in detail and continue to support developers while offering a safe platform for consumers.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Apple

    Source excerpt

    • A French court on Monday, December 19, ordered Apple to pay €1 million ($1.06 million) for imposing unfair conditions on app developers and to bring its practices in line with new regulations of the European Union.
    • According to the ruling, the Paris commercial court considered there to be "significant disequilibrium" and "considerable legal and economic insecurity" due to the developers' impossibility to renegotiate the terms of their contract or contest the suspension of their app.
    • Apple told AFP that it would examine the ruling in detail and would continue to support developers while offering a safe platform for consumers.
  4. 2022

    Class-action lawsuit filed against Apple over alleged AirTag stalking

    Lawsuit filed

    A class-action lawsuit was filed against Apple after two women alleged that former partners used AirTags to stalk them and put them in danger. The claims are allegations in the lawsuit. The event was reported on December 7, 2022.

    Source excerpt

    • A class-action lawsuit has been filed against Apple after two women claim the company’s AirTags were used to stalk them and put them in danger.
    • This class action case, which was filed last week in the Pennsylvania Eastern District Court, is a companion to one that was filed in November, 9to5 Mac writes.
    • Another class action lawsuit has been filed against Apple for allegedly gathering and transferring analytics data from iPhone customers without their consent.
  5. 2022

    Apple files patent infringement lawsuit against AliveCor

    Lawsuit filed

    Apple filed a patent infringement lawsuit against AliveCor. According to the source, AliveCor's patents concern wearable sensors and cardiac monitoring technology. The report does not state that a final court determination has been reached in this lawsuit.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple has filed a patent infringement lawsuit against AliveCor
  6. 2022

    Foxconn responds to worker protests and hiring error at Zhengzhou plant

    Company response

    After workers protested at Foxconn's Zhengzhou plant over alleged overdue pay and COVID-related workplace concerns, Foxconn said a technical error occurred during recruitment, apologized for a computer-system input error, and said it would address workers' concerns. Apple said it had team members at the facility and was reviewing the situation with Foxconn.

    After workers protested at Foxconn’s Zhengzhou plant over alleged overdue pay and COVID-related workplace concerns, Foxconn said a technical error occurred during recruitment, apologized for a computer-system input error, and said it would address workers’ concerns. Apple said it had team members at the facility and was reviewing the situation with Foxconn.

    Company response

    • Investigation — Foxconn

      Our team has been looking into the matter and discovered a technical error occurred during the onboarding process
    • Apology — Foxconn

      We apologize for an input error in the computer system and guarantee that the actual pay is the same as agreed and the official recruitment posters.
    • Remediation — Foxconn

      The Taiwanese company said it would try to solve concerns and meet worker demands, with "corresponding care subsidies" offered to those who want to return to their hometowns.
    • Investigation — Apple

      We are reviewing the situation and working closely with Foxconn to ensure their employees' concerns are addressed

    Source excerpt

    • Workers said in videos circulated on social media that they had been informed that Foxconn intended to delay bonus payments. Some workers also complained they were forced to share dormitories with colleagues who had tested positive for COVID.
    • We have Apple team members on the ground at our supplier Foxconn's Zhengzhou facility. We are reviewing the situation and working closely with Foxconn to ensure their employees' concerns are addressed,
    • Apple said on Thursday it has team members on the ground at the Foxconn Zhengzhou iPhone manufacturing facility, which was hit by worker protests in recent days.
  7. 2022

    Xpeng denies involvement in former Apple employee’s trade-secret case

    Company response

    Xpeng issued a statement saying it was not involved in U.S. authorities’ investigation of a former Apple employee accused of stealing Apple trade secrets, and that it had no related dispute with Apple.

    Company response

    • Clarification — 小鹏汽车

      小鹏汽车发布声明称,小鹏汽车今日从媒体上获悉前苹果员工张小浪涉嫌窃取苹果商业秘密案件的最新进展。案件至今已经四年多,小鹏汽车并不了解案件的具体情况,也未介入美国司法机关对案件的后续调查,该公司与苹果公司之间也没有相关的争议,与该案件也无任何关联。

    Source excerpt

    • 小鹏汽车发布声明称,小鹏汽车今日从媒体上获悉前苹果员工张小浪涉嫌窃取苹果商业秘密案件的最新进展。案件至今已经四年多,小鹏汽车并不了解案件的具体情况,也未介入美国司法机关对案件的后续调查,该公司与苹果公司之间也没有相关的争议,与该案件也无任何关联。
  8. 2022

    Apple sued over alleged sexual harassment on film set

    Lawsuit filed

    Alicia Kelly sued Apple, Lionsgate Entertainment and Jerry Bruckheimer, among others, alleging that the companies failed to protect her from sexual harassment and fostered a workplace environment in which harassment, intimidation and sexual battery against female workers were allowed. These are allegations in the lawsuit.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple is being sued by a woman who claims the tech giant failed to protect her from sexual harassment while she was employed in a COVD support role on the set of the Will Smith thriller “Emancipation,” reports Bloomberg.
    • Alicia Kelly also sued production companies Lionsgate Entertainment Inc. and Jerry Bruckheimer Inc., as well as her direct employers, claiming the companies fostered a workplace environment where sexual harassment, sexual intimidation and sexual battery were allowed against female workers.
  9. 2022

    Texas judge denies Apple request for another patent trial

    Ruling

    A Texas judge rejected Apple's motion for a third trial in its patent dispute with Optis. The ruling confirmed that Apple must pay Optis $300 million, subject to any appeal to a higher court.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple has been denied a third trial in its patent dispute with Optis technology by a Texas judge, and will now have to pay $300 million to the outfit over claims it willfully infringed on patents relating to wireless connectivity.
    • Judge Gilstrap confirmed the rejection on May 17.
  10. 2022

    Krafton sues Apple and Google over sales of alleged game copies

    Lawsuit filed

    Krafton filed a U.S. lawsuit alleging that a Singapore-based company made rip-off versions of its game and that Apple and Google refused to stop selling them.

    Company response

    • Denial — Garena

      A company spokesperson said, “Krafton’s claims are groundless.”
    • Denial — Garena spokesperson

      Garena’s spokesperson says to the lip Crafton’s allegations are unfounded.

    Source excerpt

    • Another day, another lawsuit. Krafton Inc., the maker of the game “PlayerUnknown’s Battlegrounds” says in a new U.S. lawsuit that a Singapore-based company made rip-off versions of its game, and Apple and Google have refused to stop selling them, reports Reuters.
    • Krafton, the developer behind PlayUnknown’s Battlegrounds,” and the maker of PUBG Mobile, last year’s No. 6 top-grossing mobile game on a global basis, is suing the app stores and a rival game maker, Garena, over copyright infringement involving Garena Online’s Free Fire games.
    • The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California on January 10, 2022.
  11. 2022

    Arigna Technology sues seven companies over Qualcomm components

    Lawsuit filed

    Arigna Technology filed a complaint in the Western District of Texas against Alphabet, Apple, Lenovo, Microsoft, OnePlus, Samsung, and TCL, alleging that their devices incorporated Qualcomm envelope-tracking modules covered by its patent.

    Source excerpt

    • Arigna's new case, over the '835 patent, has been assigned to District Judge Alan D. Albright. 2/10, Western District of Texas.
    • Arigna Technology Limited, one of several plaintiffs associated with Dublin-based patent monetization firm Atlantic IP, has filed a single complaint against Alphabet (Google), Apple, Lenovo, Microsoft, OnePlus, Samsung, and TCL (6:22-cv-00151) in the Western District of Texas.
    • infringement accusations in Arigna's complaint target various devices and computers (e.g., desktops, laptops, tablets, and smartphones) of the defendants over their alleged incorporation of the Qualcomm QET4100 and/or QET5100-series envelope tracking modules.
  12. 2022

    Apple complaints featured in 2021 electronics blacklist report

    Issue disclosure

    A report on Black Cat Complaint’s 2021 electronics rankings placed Apple among the brands with poor complaint-response and resolution performance. It reported complaints about automatic charges in the Apple Store and users’ reports of red or green screens on new iPhone 13 devices. These are reported complaints, not established findings.

    Source excerpt

    • 大量用户投诉Apple商店自动扣费,质量问题中较为典型的是苹果iPhone13新机出现红绿屏
    • 平台发布2021年度红黑榜榜单
    • 而Apple、索尼、柠檬悦读、金正、罗技回复及响应解决情况较差,位于数码产品领域黑榜。
  13. 2022

    Parents sue Apple over alleged AirPods hearing injury

    Lawsuit filed

    The parents of a teenager sued Apple, alleging that an AMBER Alert played through AirPods at a volume that injured their child’s hearing and that the AirPods were defective. They seek $75,000, excluding interest and costs.

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit, filed on Tuesday (May 16) and shared by
    • B.G. and his family are seeking $75,000, "excluding interest and costs" in their lawsuit.
    • The lawsuit accused Apple of producing "defective" AirPods that didn't automatically reduce volume during alerts or equalize notification and alert volumes, which led to the hearing damage.
  14. 2022

    Apple receives ninth Netherlands fine over dating-app payment systems

    Fine or penalty

    The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets imposed another €5 million weekly penalty on Apple over its assessment that Apple had not sufficiently met requirements for alternative payment systems for dating apps in the Netherlands. The article reports that Apple had accumulated €45 million in fines.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Apple

      为了符合荷兰反垄断监管机构几个月前的命令,使得荷兰的约会APP可以使用非苹果支付方式,苹果周一(3月21日)提交了一项新提案。

    Source excerpt

    • The Dutch Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM) said that Apple had sent it "new proposals" on Monday in an attempt to resolve the company's dispute over allowing dating app developers to use third-party payment methods in the Netherlands. The ACM did not disclose any details about Apple's newly proposed remedy, which it said it would now assess, and the organization continued to impose its ninth weekly penalty of €5 million on the company.
    • “我们现在将评估这些提案的内容,”荷兰消费者和市场管理局 (ACM) 发言人 Murco Mijnlieff 表示,“我们的目标是尽快完成这项评估。”
    • 为了符合荷兰反垄断监管机构几个月前的命令,使得荷兰的约会APP可以使用非苹果支付方式,苹果周一(3月21日)提交了一项新提案。
  15. 2022

    Apple settles App Store lawsuit brought by FlickType developer

    Settlement

    Apple settled a lawsuit brought by developer Kosta Eleftheriou, whose suit alleged that Apple made it difficult to sell his FlickType app on the App Store and used its market power to disadvantage developers. The article reports the settlement but gives no terms or admission of wrongdoing.

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit alleged that Apple used its monopoly power as maker of the iPhone and as the company in charge of the App Store to “crush” developers competing with it through “exploitive fees and selective application of opaque and unreasonable constraints.”
    • Kosta Eleftheriou has settled his lawsuit with Apple, according to a report from .
    • Prominent developer Kosta Eleftheriou has settled his 2021 lawsuit against Apple over its App Store review actions that he said hindered his ability to distribute apps on the platform while allowing copycat competitors to flourish, reports .TechCrunch
  16. 2022

    Consumers sue Apple over Powerbeats Pro battery life claims

    Lawsuit filed

    Consumers filed a lawsuit against Apple in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, alleging that Beats by Dre Powerbeats Pro earphones did not meet the advertised battery-life claim. The article reports the allegations and does not establish a court determination.

    Source excerpt

    • 众多消费者通过美国纽约南区地方法院指控苹果,认为其Beats by Dre Powerbeats Pro耳机对于电池续航的承诺不到位。
    • 苹果曾经宣称这款耳机充满一次电的续航可以达到9个小时,但实际却并非如此。
  17. 2022

    Apple faces criticism over App Store policies

    Public backlash

    Apple faced criticism over recent App Store changes. Spotify accused Apple of using complicated and confusing rules to disadvantage competitors, and Meta criticized Apple's decision to charge a 30 percent commission on social-media post boosts. These are allegations and criticism reported in the article, not a determination of wrongdoing.

    Source excerpt

    • Spotify on Tuesday accused Apple of engaging in anti-competitive behavior by using “complicated and confusing” rules on its app store to disadvantage competitors.
    • Similarly, Meta criticized Apple’s recent decision to charge a 30 percent commission on the sales of “boosts” for social media posts
    • Apple came under fire on Wednesday over recent changes to its app store, with some tech giants accusing the company of using its market dominance to undercut rivals.
  18. 2022

    Court dismisses lawsuit against Apple over Spectre and Meltdown claims

    Ruling

    A U.S. district judge dismissed a class-action lawsuit alleging Apple misled customers about the Spectre and Meltdown vulnerabilities. The judge ruled that the plaintiffs did not prove Apple knew about the vulnerabilities and withheld that information, or that security patches significantly slowed device performance.

    Source excerpt

    • A class-action lawsuit against Apple for allegedly misleading customers regarding the notoious Spectre and Meltdown vulnerabilities has been dismissed.
    • The judge says the plaintiffs failed to prove they relied on Apple’s marketing, when making their purchase choices.
    • Reuters reported U.S. District Judge Edward Davila, in San Jose, California, ruled that the plaintiffs did not prove Apple knew about the vulnerabilities and kept quiet, selling their products at inflated prices, as a result.
  19. 2022

    Apple accumulates €50 million in Dutch fines

    Fine or penalty

    Apple had accumulated €50 million in fines in its dispute with the Dutch competition regulator ACM over conditions for dating apps to use alternative payment options. The article says this was the tenth fine.

    Source excerpt

    • 该法则于 1 月生效,从那时起,苹果每周收到 500 万欧元的罚款。这是第 10 次罚款,总计 5000 万欧元。
    • ACM认为约会应用程序开发人员不需要在使用替代支付或应用内支付之间进行选择,并表示应用程序必须能够提供这两种选择。
  20. 2022

    Apple settles trade-secrets lawsuit against former employee

    Settlement

    Apple and former employee Simon Lancaster reached an agreement resolving Apple's lawsuit, which alleged that he stole trade secrets and shared them with a journalist. The settlement order provides for a monetary payment by Lancaster to Apple and dismissal of the claims; it also bars Lancaster from disclosing or using confidential information without Apple's written authorization.

    Source excerpt

    • The settlement order was approved by a judge this week.
    • The Verge says that, as part of the settlement, Lancaster will pay an undisclosed sum to Apple and is barred from “disclosing, communicating, transferring, discussing, or using any Confidential Information, in any form, without Apple’s express prior written authorization,” according to the order.
    • Apple has settled its lawsuit against Simon Lancaster, a former design architect, who the company accused of stealing trade secrets and sharing them with a journalist