Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile181 entries · Page 6 of 10
2022
EU charges Apple over Apple Pay competition
Investigation
The European Union charged Apple over keeping rivals away from its payment technology. The report says Apple could face a fine, while providing no final determination or penalty in the supplied text.
Source excerpt
European Union charges Apple for keeping rivals away from its pay tech
Apple could face a fine up to 10 per cent of its global turnover or $36.6 billion based on its revenue last year, though EU penalties rarely reach the cap
EU antitrust chief Margrethe Vestager said Apple unfairly shielded its Apple Pay wallets from competition
2022
Ericsson files patent lawsuits against Apple
Lawsuit filed
Ericsson filed another set of patent infringement lawsuits against Apple in the United States over royalty payments for the use of 5G wireless patents in iPhones.
Source excerpt
Published - January 18, 2022 10:53 pm IST
Sweden's Ericsson has filed another set of patent infringement lawsuits against Apple in the latest salvo between the two companies over royalty payment for use of 5G wireless patents in iPhones.
2022
Apple adjusts App Store rules for Dutch dating apps
Company response
Apple said it was making additional adjustments to its App Store plan for dating apps in the Netherlands after discussions with the Dutch regulator and at the regulator’s request. The changes concern external-purchase entitlements, user-interface requirements, and payment-processing-provider criteria.
Stated objective. Comply with the regulator’s order
Company response
Remediation — Apple
Because Apple is committed to constructive engagement with regulators, we are making the additional changes at the ACM’s request.
Source excerpt
Apple said that following productive conversations with the Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), the company is introducing additional adjustments to Apple’s plan to comply with the regulator’s order about dating apps on the App Store in the Netherlands.
“Because Apple is committed to constructive engagement with regulators, we are making the additional changes at the ACM’s request. As we have previously said, we disagree with the ACM’s original order and are appealing it,” the company said.
2022
Teen and mother file class-action lawsuit against Snap, Apple and Google
Lawsuit filed
A 16-year-old girl and her mother filed a class-action lawsuit against Snap, Apple and Google, alleging the companies' platforms and policies failed to protect teen users from abuse and the spread of child sexual abuse material. The allegations are claims in the lawsuit, not stated court findings.
Company response
Clarification — Snapchat
A Snapchat spokesperson told Insider it could not comment on active litigation but called the situation "tragic."
Source excerpt
In L.W.'s case, an adult man, identified in the lawsuit as B.P., began requesting nude photos from her when she was 12 years old.
B.P, who was an active-duty Marine, acknowledged he used Snapchat because he knew his chats would disappear, the lawsuit states.
2021
EU regulators accuse Apple of anti-competitive App Store rules
Investigation
EU regulators accused Apple of distorting competition in music streaming. The European Commission's preliminary charge concerned App Store rules requiring developers to use Apple's in-app payment system and preventing them from informing users about other purchasing options; the case could lead to concessions or a fine.
Company response
Denial — Apple
Apple rebuffed the EU charge.
Source excerpt
The EU competition enforcer, in its so-called statement of objections setting out the charge, said the issue related to Apple's restrictive rules for its App Store that force developers to use its own in-app payment system and prevent them from informing users of other purchasing options.
EU regulators have accused Apple of distorting competition in the music streaming market, siding with Spotify in a case that could lead to a hefty fine and changes in the iPhone maker's lucrative business practices.
Apple rebuffed the EU charge.
2021
Judge partially rejects Apple’s motion to dismiss iTunes “Buy” button lawsuit
Ruling
In a class-action lawsuit alleging that Apple’s iTunes “Buy” button is misleading, a federal judge partially rejected Apple’s motion to dismiss. The judge found it plausible that consumers would expect access to purchased content not to be revoked; the unjust-enrichment claim was dismissed.
In the class-action lawsuit alleging Apple’s iTunes “Buy” button is misleading, a federal judge partially rejected Apple’s motion to dismiss. The judge found it plausible that consumers would expect access to purchased content not to be revoked; the unjust-enrichment claim was dismissed.
Source excerpt
A new lawsuit against Apple alleges that the company's 'Buy' button on iTunes content is misleading and deceptive because Apple can terminate your access to content at any time.
Apple filed a motion to dismiss the suit, however, Judge John Mendez rejected the attempt (in part)
The judge also rejected Apple's claim that the alleged injury was speculative in the case, stating that "the injury is that at the time of purchase, he paid either too much for the product or spent money he would not have but for the misrepresentation.
2021
Russian antitrust authority fines Apple over App Store rules
Fine or penalty
Russia's Federal Anti-Monopoly Service fined Apple 906.3 million roubles, equivalent to about $12.1 million, for alleged abuse of dominance in the mobile applications market. Apple said it disagreed with the decision and planned to appeal.
Company response
Denial — Apple
Apple has said that it "respectfully" disagrees with the FAS's decision and plans to appeal it.
Source excerpt
Tuesday April 27, 2021 10:40 am PDT by Juli Clover
Russia's Federal Anti-Monopoly Service (FAS) has levied a $12 million fine against Apple for alleged abuse of its dominance in the mobile applications market, reports
Apple has said that it "respectfully" disagrees with the FAS's decision and plans to appeal it.
2021
Taction Technology sues Apple over Taptic Engine patents
Lawsuit filed
Taction Technology filed a lawsuit against Apple, alleging that Apple's Taptic Engine infringed two patents owned by Taction. Taction also claimed that Apple procured and reverse-engineered two Kannon headphones; according to the report, the cited support for that allegation appeared to be order and shipping receipts. The available account does not specify the patents' subject matter, the relief sought, or any court outcome.
2021
Apple faces class action over iPhone water-resistance descriptions
Lawsuit filed
A class-action filing accused Apple of making claims about iPhone water resistance. The source describes the complaint but does not provide a filing date or outcome. The event is recorded as a controversy note concerning the brand's iPhone water-resistance descriptions, based solely on the available report.
Source excerpt
这份长达13页的文件被列为“集体诉讼”,控诉内容是苹果公司在对iPhone的防水性能的描述。
被列为"集体诉讼申诉",安托瓦内特·史密斯(Antoinette Smith)被列为原告,"代表所有其他处于类似地位的人",这份长达13页的文件将矛头直指苹果提及的耐水性。
The lawsuit also says that Apple usually rejects warranty of devices whose contact indicator has turned red, despite the fact that the company advises customers to rinse iPhones that might have gotten wet from liquids like juice or coffee, but in a way that could cause the indicator to turn red and thus allow them to reject the warranty.
2021
Ransomware attack exposes Apple product plans
Issue disclosure
A news report described a ransomware attack in which hackers breached Quanta, an Apple supplier, and stole confidential information about upcoming Apple products. According to the report, the hackers sought payment and threatened Apple with the release of the data. The report did not specify the amount demanded, the identity of the attackers beyond the ransomware context, or whether any payment was made or data released. The event was framed as a controversy involving Apple and its supply chain, highlighting concerns about the exposure of confidential product information through a supplier breach.
2021
German watchdog investigates Apple’s market position
Investigation
In June 2021, Germany’s Federal Cartel Office said it was investigating whether Apple had paramount significance across markets. The authority identified Apple’s iOS ecosystem and the App Store as among the areas of focus in the proceeding. The announcement concerned an examination of Apple’s market position rather than a final finding, and the source report did not state a conclusion or any penalty at that stage.
2021
Jawbone sues Apple over AirPods Pro noise-cancellation technology
Lawsuit filed
Jawbone filed a lawsuit against Apple alleging that technology used in the AirPods Pro's active noise cancellation may infringe eight patents it owns related to limiting background noise. The source does not report a determination of the allegations.
2021
Jawbone files patent infringement suits against Apple and Google
Lawsuit filed
Jawbone filed two patent infringement suits against Google and Apple, claiming it is entitled to royalties for its noise-cancelling technology. The suits were reported on 24 September 2021. According to the source, Jawbone's claim concerns royalties for the noise-cancelling technology at issue in the two cases. The reports do not state the amounts sought, the courts involved, or any outcome of the litigation.
2021
Apple and Google face criticism after removing Navalny's app
Public backlash
Apple and Google faced criticism after removing Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny's tactical voting app from their stores under pressure from the Kremlin. A Navalny ally described the removal as political censorship.
2021
Court orders Apple to pay trade-in value
Ruling
A court ruled that Apple had a trade-in contract with Mr. Xia and ordered Apple to pay him the promised 4,200 yuan after he returned his computer. The court found the available evidence insufficient to show the computer had a quality problem when it was handed over.
2021
Class-action lawsuit alleges M1 MacBook display defect
Lawsuit filed
A class-action lawsuit was filed against Apple in California alleging that the displays in the 13-inch MacBook Pro with M1 and the MacBook Air with M1 have a defect that can cause cracking and other display problems. The suit further alleges that Apple concealed the defect or engaged in deceptive marketing. These are allegations made in the lawsuit and not a court determination. The filing concerns the M1 models identified in the complaint and centers on the claimed display issue and Apple's alleged conduct regarding it.
2021
Taiwan consumer group criticizes Apple's iPhone accessory policy
Public backlash
In 2021, Taiwan's Consumers' Foundation criticized Apple's policy of no longer including a power adapter and wired earphones with new iPhones. The foundation argued that the policy harms consumer interests and may amount to an indirect price increase. It urged Apple to reconsider the policy and to offer accessory options that protect consumer rights.
2021
Court issues ruling in Epic–Apple case
Ruling
A US federal judge issued a ruling in the Epic–Apple case. According to the report, Epic prevailed on one of ten claims under California's Unfair Competition Law, resulting in a permanent injunction barring Apple from prohibiting developers from directing users to alternative payment options. The judge rejected Epic's other claims and found that Epic had breached its contract with Apple.
2021
Apple delays planned child safety features for further review
Company response
Apple stated that it would take additional time to collect feedback and improve its planned child safety features before releasing them. The company's decision followed feedback from customers, advocacy groups, researchers, and others. The announcement indicated a delay in the rollout of the features to allow for further review and refinement based on the input received.
2021
Judge allows Siri privacy claims to proceed
Ruling
In a legal proceeding concerning Apple's Siri voice assistant, Judge White found that the plaintiffs sufficiently demonstrated that their privacy was invaded when Siri was unexpectedly activated and listened to and recorded conversations they did not intend or want Siri to hear. The judge also stated that the suit did not show the economic harm necessary to support a claim that Apple deceptively marketed Siri. The ruling allowed the privacy claims to proceed while not sustaining the deceptive marketing claim on the grounds presented.