Skip to content

Apple

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile181 entries · Page 7 of 10

  1. 2021

    Apple bans employee pay-equity discussion channel

    Issue disclosure

    In 2021, Apple reportedly banned an employee Slack channel that had been created to discuss pay information and statistics. According to the report, an employment attorney said the ban could violate labor law and characterized it as retaliation. The article also reports that the legal question remained unresolved. The report does not state any further outcome or additional allegations beyond the channel ban, the attorney's comments, and the unresolved legal question.

    Source excerpt

    • For them to try and impair employees’ ability to discuss pay equity and diversity in the workplace is a clear-cut act of retaliation.
    • Apple had recently banned the channel, created to openly discuss information and statistics on pay of employees within the company.
    • According to employment attorney Vincent P. White, Apple’s inconsistent enforcement of Slack rules at the company may be considered in violation labor law.
  2. 2021

    Apple settles U.S. app developers' class action

    Settlement

    Apple settled a class action lawsuit brought by U.S. app developers. The settlement is subject to court approval and includes changes to App Store practices, including allowing developers more flexibility to advertise payment options outside their iOS apps. The developers had alleged that Apple broke antitrust laws through practices including commissions of up to 30%.

    Apple settled a class action lawsuit with U.S. app developers. The settlement is subject to court approval and includes changes to App Store practices, including allowing developers more flexibility to advertise payment options outside their iOS apps. The developers had alleged that Apple broke antitrust laws through practices including commissions of up to 30%.

    Source excerpt

    • The settlement, which is subject to court approval, reportedly will include $100 million worth of payments to app makers ranging from $250 to $30,000 per developer.
    • A group of smaller software developers filled lawsuit in 2019, alleging that Apple broke antitrust laws with practices such as charging commissions of up to 30%.
    • Apple Inc. (AAPL) has settled a wide-ranging class action lawsuit with U.S. app developers.
  3. 2021

    Small-claims ruling over defective iPhone

    Ruling

    In a small-claims case brought by Janet Carlson over a defective iPhone, the magistrate agreed with her claim. Carlson later received a $2,800 check from Apple. The source article does not state the date of the magistrate's decision. The event is recorded as a controversy note concerning Apple, based solely on the details and source quote provided.

  4. 2021

    Italy's competition authority fines Apple and Google

    Fine or penalty

    In November 2021, Italy's competition authority fined Apple and Google approximately $11.3 million each for violations of the country's Consumer Code. According to the reported event, the violations concerned insufficient information and aggressive practices related to the acquisition and use of consumer data for commercial purposes. The authority applied the penalties to both companies over these consumer-protection breaches. The event summary does not specify further details about the proceedings, the companies' responses, or subsequent outcomes.

  5. 2021

    Italy fines Amazon and Apple over sales restrictions

    Fine or penalty

    Italy's antitrust authority fined Amazon and Apple over alleged anti-competitive cooperation in the sale of Apple and Beats products. According to the authority, provisions in a 2018 agreement restricted which resellers could sell these products on Amazon.it, and it ordered the companies to end the restrictions. Apple denied wrongdoing and said it planned to appeal.

    Company response

    • Denial — Apple

      Apple denied any wrongdoing and said it plans to appeal against the fine.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple denies doing anything wrong
    • Italy's antitrust authority (AGCM) has issued Amazon and Apple with large fines after concluding the two companies worked together to control sales of Apple and Beats products.
    • The so-called anti-competitive cooperation has landed Amazon with a $77 million fine, while Apple suffers a larger $151 million fine.
  6. 2021

    Apple sues NSO Group over alleged targeting of Apple users

    Lawsuit filed

    Apple announced that it is suing NSO Group for the "surveillance and targeting of Apple users" and is seeking to block access to its mobile devices. The lawsuit also includes NSO Group's parent company Q Cyber Technologies. The announcement was made on November 23, 2021.

    Source excerpt

    • Then, the Pegasus's users can remotely surveil the iPhone owner's activities, including by accessing the device's microphone and camera, and collect emails, text messages, and browsing history, Apple alleged in its lawsuit.
    • In federal court on Tuesday, Apple sued NSO Group, an Israeli firm that sells software to government agencies and law enforcement that allows them to hack iPhones and read the data on them, including messages and other communications.
    • Apple is seeking a permanent injunction to ban NSO Group from using Apple software, services, or devices. It's also seeking damages over $75,000.
  7. 2021

    UK regulator contacts Apple and Google among 40 companies over children's data practices

    Investigation

    In 2021, the UK Information Commissioner's Office contacted 40 companies in social media, gaming, video and music streaming, including Apple and Google, as part of its examination of how their services interact with children and whether they comply with privacy requirements. Research cited in the report alleged that the companies' app stores did not do enough to prevent underage users from downloading age-inappropriate apps.

  8. 2021

    Dutch regulator rules against Apple App Store payment policies

    Ruling

    The Netherlands Authority for Consumers and Markets ruled that Apple’s commission policies on in-app payments violated Dutch competition law and ordered Apple to adjust the conditions applied to dating-app providers.

    Source excerpt

    • The Authority for Consumers and Markets (ACM), the competition regulator of the Netherlands, Friday ruled that Apple’s commission policies on in-app payments violates the country’s competition law and ordered the company to adjust the payment policies of its App Store.
  9. 2021

    Foxconn identifies accommodation and canteen deficiencies at Indian facility

    Issue disclosure

    Apple said an independent assessment at Foxconn’s Sriperumbudur facility found that conditions in some remote dormitories and the canteen did not meet requirements, following concerns about food safety and accommodation. Foxconn said it was restructuring local management and systems and had agreed to expand living areas, upgrade bathing facilities and provide drinking water.

    Company response

    • Apology — 富士康

      富士康为该事故做出了道歉
    • Remediation — 富士康

      富士康已同意扩大生活区,升级洗浴设施和提供饮用水,满足员工的需求
    • Personnel action — 富士康

      富士康正在重组其当地的管理团队和系统

    Source excerpt

    • 富士康正在重组其当地的管理团队和系统,并表示在进行必要整改以重新启动运营的同时,所有员工将继续领取工资,并为员工重返工作岗位提供支持。
    • 鉴于最近富士康Sriperumbudur工厂的食品安全和住宿条件引发担忧后,我们派出独立审计师进行了额外的详细评估,发现部分偏远宿舍住宿和餐厅条件不符合要求
    • 在发生员工食物中毒事件后,富士康为该事故做出了道歉,并承诺改进其在印度的管理和运营。
  10. 2021

    UK court rules that Apple infringed Optis patents

    Ruling

    A UK High Court judge ruled that Apple infringed two Optis patents and ordered Apple to pay a licence fee; the amount had not yet been determined in the report.

    Source excerpt

    • 202年6月,英国一家高等法院法官裁定苹果侵犯了Optis的两项专利,命令其支付许可费。
  11. 2021

    Apple settled lawsuit over repair workers’ disclosure of customer images

    Settlement

    Apple paid millions of dollars to settle a case after repair workers at an Apple repair contractor took explicit photos and videos from a customer's phone and posted them on Facebook. The article reports that the case was settled for an undisclosed amount.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple paid millions of dollars to a woman after iPhone repair workers took explicit photos and videos from a phone she had sent in to be fixed and posted them on Facebook.
    • Lawyers for the woman threatened to sue for invasion of privacy and emotional distress, but the case was settled for an undisclosed amount of money, though it totaled in the millions, The Telegraph reported.
    • The incident happened in 2016, when the woman sent her phone to Pegatron Technology Service, an Apple repair contractor in California.
  12. 2021

    Epic Games appeals ruling in Apple case

    Lawsuit filed

    Epic Games filed an appeal of the ruling in its case against Apple after losing on most of its complaints. The article reports that the court found Apple had operated in anti-competitive ways, while also finding that Apple acted lawfully in removing Fortnite for violating its terms of service.

    Source excerpt

    • Epic Games filed notice to appeal the overall ruling of its case with Apple over the weekend, as reported by AP News.
    • In the original ruling, California court Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers found that while Apple did operate in ways that were anti-competitive, it did .
  13. 2021

    Apple responds to an iOS 14.7 Apple Watch unlocking bug

    Company response

    Apple acknowledged that iOS 14.7 caused the “Unlock with iPhone” feature to stop working for some Apple Watch users with Touch ID-equipped iPhones, and said it would address the issue in a future software update. The article also reports that Apple provided a PIN-entry workaround.

    Company response

    • Remediation — 蘋果

      蘋果也會在不久的未來推出軟體更新解決此問題

    Source excerpt

    • 而蘋果方面也已經知道這項問題並在官方支援網站中列出解決方式,基本上很簡單,就是自己輸入 PIN 碼解鎖
    • 蘋果稍早推出了 iOS 14.7 的更新,雖說此更新修復了不少漏洞,不過卻製造了新的 bug,而蘋果也承諾將在未來的軟體更新中修復。
  14. 2021

    Banks and regulators urge probe of Apple Pay restrictions

    Public backlash

    Major banks and regulators called for a parliamentary committee to probe Apple's restrictions on third parties accessing iPhone payment functions, citing potential competition concerns.

    Stated objective. To ensure the fast-growing digital-wallet market is competitive.

    Source excerpt

    • Banks say smartphones have become “critical gateways” for making payments, but given Apple and Google have payment applications that compete with banks, “competition questions may arise because of their ability to self-preference” Apple Pay and Google Pay over banks’ own apps.
    • Major banks and regulators want a parliamentary committee to probe the restrictions Apple has placed on third-parties accessing the payment functions of its iPhone, to ensure the fast-growing market for digital wallets is competitive.
  15. 2021

    Apple apologizes and refunds a child's in-app purchases

    Company response

    Apple apologized to a child's mother and refunded $1,116.32 spent on in-app purchases. The purchases were made through apps including Roblox and Coin Master.

    Company response

    • Apology — 苹果

      作为回应,苹果向孩子的母亲道歉并退还了在App Store上花费的金额。
    • Refund or compensation — 苹果

      作为回应,苹果向孩子的母亲道歉并退还了在App Store上花费的金额。

    Source excerpt

    • 据外媒报道,苹果在App Store上提供了许多应用和游戏并提供了应用内购买功能。
    • Vasquez表示,她九岁的儿子Thenniel在不知情的情况下从苹果App Store购买了东西并记入了她的账户--1116.32美元。
    • 作为回应,苹果向孩子的母亲道歉并退还了在App Store上花费的金额。
  16. 2021

    Apple fined over gathering at Singapore store

    Fine or penalty

    Apple was fined $1,000 in Singapore over a workplace gathering held at its Orchard Road store on June 18, which the Singapore Tourism Board said involved more than 50 staff and violated pandemic restrictions.

    Source excerpt

    • The company was fined $1,000 for purportedly holding a workplace event at a company store in Orchard Road, Singapore, which occurred last June 18, reports The Straits Times.
    • Over 50 members of the store's staff gathered at an event to celebrate the final day of another employee at the store, according to the Singapore Tourism Board (STB).
    • SINGAPORE: Apple was fined S$1,000 (RM3,101) for holding a social workplace event at its Orchard Road store on June 18.
  17. 2021

    Apple clarifies AirPods Max power-mode behavior

    Company response

    After users reported rapid battery drain, Apple clarified in a support document how and when AirPods Max is designed to enter low-power and ultra-low-power states.

    Company response

    • Clarification — 苹果

      苹果在一份支持文件中澄清说,AirPods Max 被设计为在静止(不放在智能耳机套中)5 分钟后进入”低功率模式”。

    Source excerpt

    • 苹果在一份支持文件中澄清说,AirPods Max 被设计为在静止(不放在智能耳机套中)5 分钟后进入”低功率模式”。
    • 许多用户都发现一夜之间电池耗电量很高,有时是两位数的百分比,但大多数人在耳机不使用时,每天看到的电池耗电量约为 10% 至 12%。
  18. 2021

    EU preliminary report flags potential competition concerns in the smart-home and IoT sector

    Issue disclosure

    The European Commission's preliminary report on the Internet of Things said that a small number of companies, including Apple, might engage in anticompetitive conduct. The report did not conclude that Apple or other companies had violated competition law.

    Source excerpt

    • 初步报告并没有说苹果或其他公司违反了竞争法。
    • 在所有消费物联网领域,大量受访者指出,开发新产品和服务的主要障碍是没有能力与Google、亚马逊和苹果竞争
    • 一份关于物联网的初步报告得出结论,包括苹果在内的少数公司可能存在反竞争行为。
  19. 2021

    Apple settles lawsuit over repair technicians’ posting of customer photos

    Settlement

    Apple paid an unspecified settlement to a woman after technicians at an Apple-approved repair contractor posted explicit photos and a video from her phone to her Facebook account. The article reports that the incident occurred in 2016 and that the settlement amount was reported to be multimillion-dollar.

    Source excerpt

    • Apple paid a multimillion dollar settlement to a woman after iPhone repair techs posted risque pictures from her phone to Facebook, one of the most severe customer privacy breaches yet to be made public, according to legal documents obtained by the Telegraph.
    • Two iPhone repair technicians in Sacramento, uploaded "10 photos of her in various stages of undress and a sex video" to her Facebook account, resulting in "severe emotional distress" for the young woman, according to the Telegraph's review of legal records.
    • The settlement isn't the first time Apple has had to handle the misdeeds of employees.
  20. 2020

    Environmental, sourcing, and repair-policy criticism

    The company has been criticized over materials sourcing, environmental effects, product repair restrictions, and the broader consequences of tightly controlled hardware design.