Skip to content

Facebook

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile172 entries · Page 2 of 9

  1. 2023

    Tripadvisor apologizes over Gaza hotel advertisement

    Company response

    Tripadvisor issued an apology after an advertisement on Facebook promoted a hotel in Gaza City. According to the company, an error led to the advertisement being generated, and it stated that it had taken steps to prevent a recurrence. The incident involved the advertisement appearing on Facebook and the company's subsequent apology and corrective measures.

    Tripadvisor apologized after an advertisement on Facebook promoted a hotel in Gaza City. The company said an error led to the advert being generated and that it had taken steps to prevent a recurrence.

    Company response

    • Apology — Tripadvisor

      In an email to Stuff, a Tripadvisor spokesperson apologised for the offence the advert had caused.
    • Remediation — Tripadvisor

      We understand the distress this has caused and have taken steps to stop this happening again.

    Source excerpt

    • Despite taking steps to ensure impacted locations are temporarily suppressed by our systems during times of conflict, in this case there was an error on our part which led to this particular advert being generated.
    • We understand the distress this has caused and have taken steps to stop this happening again.
    • Tripadvisor has apologised for advertising a hotel located in Gaza City for Facebook users, following critiques that it was "poorly-timed and triggering".
  2. 2023

    Agcom fines Meta over gambling advertising

    Fine or penalty

    Italy’s communications watchdog Agcom fined Meta 5.85 million euros over content on Facebook and Instagram that it said breached a 2018 ban on gambling advertising. The regulator said the fine concerned content found on five Instagram accounts and 13 Facebook accounts.

    Source excerpt

    • The authority, Agcom, said the fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited.
    • It said its investigation "found promotional material or other advertising, including indirect, for betting or games involving money on 18 profiles/accounts (five on Instagram and 13 on Facebook), as well as 32 sponsored contents."
    • Italy's communications authority said Friday it had fined Facebook's parent company Meta 5.85 million euros ($6.4 million) for carrying gambling advertising.
  3. 2023

    Meta apologizes over fraudulent ads featuring Wissam Al Mana

    Company response

    PYMNTS reported that Meta apologized for fraudulent cryptocurrency scam advertisements on Facebook that featured Wissam Al Mana’s image without authorization. The article also says Al Mana reportedly emerged victorious in a legal battle against Meta.

    Company response

    • Apology — Meta

      Meta Apologizes for Fraudulent Ads Featuring Billionaire Wissam Al Mana

    Source excerpt

    • Meta Apologizes for Fraudulent Ads Featuring Billionaire Wissam Al Mana
    • Qatari billionaire Wissam Al Mana reportedly emerged victorious in a legal battle against Meta over the unauthorized use of his image in cryptocurrency scam advertisements on Facebook.
  4. 2023

    New Hampshire joins lawsuit against Meta over platform design

    Lawsuit filed

    New Hampshire joined other states suing Meta over alleged addictive design features on Facebook and Instagram. The complaint alleges the platforms were designed to prolong children’s use; the filing seeks an injunction and monetary penalties. These are allegations, not a court determination.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Meta

      Meta said it was working to provide a safer environment for teenagers on its apps and has introduced more than 30 tools to support teenagers and families.

    Source excerpt

    • The filing asks the court to enter an injunction requiring substantive changes in how the company operates, and also seeks monetary penalties.
    • New Hampshire has joined 41 other states suing Facebook and Instagram for using “addictive” algorithms that “exploit the developmental vulnerabilities of children and trap them into never-ending use.”
    • Meta was sued by more than three dozen states on Tuesday for knowingly using features on Instagram and Facebook to hook children to its platforms, even as the company said its social media sites were safe for young people.
  5. 2023

    South Korean court rules against Meta in user-information sharing case

    Ruling

    The Seoul Administrative Court ruled against Meta in its challenge to a 2020 fine imposed by South Korea’s Personal Information Protection Commission. The court said Facebook users could not know the relevant legal notices and that the company had taken unfair profits from providing users’ personal information to other operators without their knowledge.

    Source excerpt

    • But the Seoul Administrative Court on Thursday ruled against Meta, saying its users were not able to know related legal notices and the company had taken unfair profits from the practice.
    • In November 2020, the Personal Information Protection Commission (PIPC) fined Meta, formerly known as Facebook Inc., 7.8 billion won ($5.78 million) after its probe found that the personal information of at least 3.3 million out of 18 million Facebook users in South Korea was provided to operators other than Facebook without their knowledge from May 2012 through June 2018.
  6. 2023

    Meta faces backlash over automatic Threads cross-posting

    Public backlash

    Meta began automatically cross-posting Threads content to Facebook and Instagram feeds without users’ consent. The practice drew backlash from some Threads users who did not want their posts shared with a broader audience.

    Stated objective. The article says the effort was intended to increase usage of Threads.

    Source excerpt

    • According to an Oct. 23 Egadget report, the move has sparked backlash among some Threads users who intentionally use the app differently than Facebook and don’t want their intimate Threads posts being broadcast to their broader Facebook social circle.
    • In an effort to increase usage of its fledgling social app Threads, Meta has begun automatically cross-posting Threads content directly to users’ Facebook and Instagram feeds without their consent.
  7. 2023

    Appeals court allows Facebook ad-algorithm discrimination suit to proceed

    Ruling

    A California appeals court ruled that Section 230 does not prevent Facebook from being sued over allegations that its ad delivery system discriminated against women and older people in showing insurance ads. The ruling reversed an earlier decision; it did not determine the allegations on their merits.

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit alleges that Facebook’s ad delivery system didn’t show Liapes ads for insurance due to her age and gender.
    • In a September 21st ruling, the appeals court reversed a previous decision that said Section 230 (which protects online platforms from legal liability if users post illegal content) shields Facebook from accountability.
    • In a September 21 ruling, the appeals court overturned a previous judgment that had invoked Section 230, which provides legal protection to online platforms in cases involving illegal user-generated content.
  8. 2023

    Meta faces backlash over blocking wildfire news links in Canada

    Public backlash

    Meta faced accusations that blocking news links in Canada during wildfires endangered lives and limited residents' access to updates.

    Company response

    • Denial — Meta

      Meta -- which did not respond to AFP requests for comment -- rejected CBC's suggestion.
    • Clarification — Meta

      Instead it urged Canadians to use the "Safety Check" function on Facebook to let others know if they are safe or not.

    Source excerpt

    • Meta is being accused of endangering lives by blocking news links in Canada at a crucial moment, when thousands have fled their homes and are desperate for wildfire updates that once would have been shared widely on Facebook.
    • Meta on August 1 started blocking the distribution of news links and articles on its Facebook and Instagram platforms in response to a recent law requiring digital giants to pay publishers for news content.
    • Meta has said the bill is flawed and insisted that news outlets share content on its Facebook and Instagram platforms to attract readers, benefiting them and not the Silicon Valley firm.
  9. 2023

    Australian consumer regulator assesses fines over Onavo data disclosures

    Fine or penalty

    Facebook Israel and Onavo were each assessed a $10 million fine for breaches of Australian Consumer Law. The ACCC said they failed to adequately disclose the extent of consumer data usage to Australians who used the VPN service between February 2016 and October 2017.

    Source excerpt

    • Facebook Israel and Onavo are each being assessed fines of $10 million for breach of Australian Consumer Law.
    • Facebook Israel and VPN service Onavo Protect promised to keep user data private and safe, but were sharing collected personal information with Meta for use in its targeted advertising systems.
    • The Australian Competition & Consumer Commission said that the Meta subsidiaries had failed to adequately disclose the extent of consumer data usage to Australians that made use of the VPN service between February 2016 and October 2017, about 270,000 people in total.
  10. 2023

    EU court upholds German antitrust judgment involving Meta

    Ruling

    The European Court of Justice upheld a 2019 German antitrust judgment involving Meta. The court held that competition authorities can consider data-privacy infractions when assessing whether a business abused market dominance; Meta said it was evaluating the decision.

    Company response

    • Ongoing disclosure — Meta

      “We are evaluating the court’s decision and will have more to say in due course,” Facebook parent Meta stated in a declaration.

    Source excerpt

    • The court upheld a German antitrust judgement from 2019 that threatened to destabilize Meta's business model of selling advertisements tailored to customers based on information obtained from how they use its services.
    • The court held that antitrust regulators can consider any infractions of data privacy standards when determining whether cyber behemoths are abusing their market dominance by shutting out competitors.
    • “We are evaluating the court’s decision and will have more to say in due course,” Facebook parent Meta stated in a declaration.
  11. 2023

    South Korea fines Meta over personal information collection and use

    Fine or penalty

    South Korea's Personal Information Protection Commission imposed an additional fine of 7.4 billion won on Meta for collecting personal information without user consent and using it for personalized online advertising. The commission found that Meta secretly collected Facebook users' personal information through Facebook Login.

    Source excerpt

    • The Korea Times, the PIPC also fined another tech company - Meta Platforms - for the same personal data breach.
    • For this offense, the commission penalized Mark Zuckerberg's company with an additional KRW7.4 billion fine on top of its previous KRW30.8 billion fine that was handed down in September 2022.
    • The organization further discovered that the social media giant secretly gathered the personal information of Facebook users through its "Facebook Login" prompt.
  12. 2023

    Meta faces criticism over fraud on its platforms

    Public backlash

    Meta faced criticism from MPs, consumer groups, and the UK banking industry over allegations that it failed to prevent rising fraudulent activity on its platforms.

    Source excerpt

    • Meta, the parent company of prominent social media platforms Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, gets under fire from MPs, consumer groups, and the UK banking industry for failing to prevent a rise in fraudulent activity on its sites.
  13. 2023

    Facebook reactivates Crawford's account

    Corrective action

    After the judge ordered Meta to pay him, Jason Crawford said Facebook activated his account again. The article does not state when the account was reactivated.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Facebook

      "I felt a little bit vindicated, and they activated my account again," Crawford told the station.
    • Remediation — Facebook

      "I felt a little bit vindicated, and they activated my account again," he said.

    Source excerpt

    • "I felt a little bit vindicated, and they activated my account again," Crawford told the station.
    • 'I felt a little bit vindicated, and they activated my account again,' he said.
    • Because Meta's legal teams failed to respond to the suit, a judge ordered the company to pay Crawford $50,000.
  14. 2023

    Report alleges Planned Parenthood shared sensitive user data with online platforms

    Issue disclosure

    A report says Planned Parenthood had a policy of sharing highly personal information from its website with Google, Facebook, TikTok and Hotjar. The information allegedly included a user's IP address, site behavior, ZIP code, and abortion-related searches.

    Source excerpt

    • The information included her personal IP address, her behavior on the site, zip code, her search for an abortionist and the kind of abortion she wanted.
    • The abortion giant has a policy of sharing highly personal information with Google, Facebook, TikTok, and Hotjar.
  15. 2023

    Clarksville school system sues social media companies

    Lawsuit filed

    The Clarksville-Montgomery County School System filed a lawsuit against social media companies, seeking accountability over alleged damages and a growing student mental health crisis linked to social media use. The companies named include Meta, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat, Google, WhatsApp and YouTube.

    Stated objective. Seek accountability and changes in how social media companies interact with children.

    Source excerpt

    • Clarksville-Montgomery County School System has filed a lawsuit against social media companies for the damages and growing mental health crisis among students.
    • Companies included in the lawsuit are: Meta Facebook Instagram TikTok Snapchat Google WhatsApp Youtube
    • The Frantz Law Group, working with Lewis Thomason, filed the lawsuit the week of May 8 against Facebook, Google, Instagram, Meta, Snapchat, Tik Tok, WhatsApp and YouTube on behalf of CMCSS, according to a news release.
  16. 2023

    UK minister criticizes Meta's Facebook encryption plans

    Public backlash

    UK Security Minister Tom Tugendhat criticized Meta's plans to roll out end-to-end encryption for Facebook messages, saying the change would allow child abusers to operate with impunity. Meta said it had developed safety measures to address abuse while maintaining privacy and security.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Meta

      We don't think people want us reading their private messages so have developed safety measures that prevent, detect, and allow us to take action against this heinous abuse, while maintaining online privacy and security

    Source excerpt

    • The UK's security minister says the social media giant's plans to encrypt Facebook messages would allow child abusers to 'operate with impunity'.
    • We don't think people want us reading their private messages so have developed safety measures that prevent, detect, and allow us to take action against this heinous abuse, while maintaining online privacy and security
    • Meta, which owns Facebook alongside apps such as WhatsApp and Instagram, said it would work with police and child safety experts.
  17. 2023

    Seattle Public Schools sues social media platforms over youth mental health

    Lawsuit filed

    Seattle Public Schools filed a lawsuit against the companies behind TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, and Snapchat, alleging that the platforms' design and actions contributed to a youth mental health crisis. The lawsuit seeks monetary damages and other penalties; these are allegations in the complaint.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Google

      Google, which owns YouTube, responded to the lawsuit, telling Axios, “We have invested heavily in creating safe experiences for children across our platforms and have introduced strong protections and dedicated features to prioritize their wellbeing.
    • Clarification — Facebook

      A Facebook spokesperson offered a similar response, stating, “We’ve developed more than 30 tools to support teens and families, including supervision tools that let parents limit the amount of time their teens spend on Instagram, and age verification technology that helps teens have age-appropriate experiences.”

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit seeks compensation for monetary damages and other penalties.
    • The lawsuit says the companies' actions have been a substantial factor in causing a youth mental health crisis.
    • The suit, filed Friday in U.S. District Court in Seattle, seeks “the maximum statutory and civil penalties permitted by law,” making the case that the companies have violated Washington state’s public nuisance law.
  18. 2023

    Irish watchdog fines Meta €390 million over GDPR breaches

    Fine or penalty

    Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined Meta Ireland €390 million over GDPR breaches relating to Facebook and Instagram. Meta said it was disappointed and planned to appeal the decision and fines.

    Company response

    • Denial — Meta

      Meta spokesperson said in a statement that it “strongly” believes its approach “respects GDPR”
    • Denial — Meta

      我们坚信我们的做法尊重GDPR,所以我们对这些决定感到失望
    • Denial — Meta

      Meta said in a statement that "we strongly believe our approach respects GDPR, and we’re therefore disappointed by these decisions and intend to appeal both the substance of the rulings and the fines."

    Source excerpt

    • Meta Ireland was fined 210 million euro for breaches of EU data privacy rules relating to Facebook, and 180 million euro for breaches on Instagram.
    • Ireland’s data watchdog has fined Facebook’s parent company Meta Ireland 390 million euro
    • Meta said it was “disappointed” by the decision and intends to appeal against “both the substance of the rulings and the fines”.
  19. 2022

    Meta clarifies it has no plan to exit Europe

    Company response

    In February 2022, after a report by Meta prompted widespread coverage, the company stated that it had no plan to withdraw from the European market. Meta said it was seeking a solution for transferring users' personal data between the European Union and the United States. The clarification followed the broad reporting of the report's contents, and the company's statement addressed the question of a possible exit from Europe while describing its efforts regarding cross-border data transfers.

    After its report prompted widespread coverage, Meta said it had no plan to withdraw from the European market and was seeking a solution for transferring users’ personal data between the EU and the US.

    Stated objective. To find a solution for transferring users’ personal data between the EU and the US.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Meta

      表示絕對沒有計劃撤出歐洲市場,只是希望尋求解決方案讓用戶個人數據能夠在歐盟和美國之間傳送。

    Source excerpt

    • 在報告內容被廣泛報導後改口,表示絕對沒有計劃撤出歐洲市場,只是希望尋求解決方案讓用戶個人數據能夠在歐盟和美國之間傳送。
  20. 2022

    Andrew Forrest brings criminal case against Facebook over scam ads

    Lawsuit filed

    Andrew Forrest brought a criminal case against Facebook in the Western Australia Magistrates Court, alleging that the platform breached federal anti-money-laundering laws by not sufficiently cracking down on scam ads. Meta, the company behind Facebook, said it takes a multifaceted approach to stop such ads. The case concerns the handling of scam advertisements on the platform and the allegation of insufficient enforcement against them.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Meta

      Meta told Nine: “We take a multifaceted approach to stop these ads. We work not just to detect and reject the ads themselves but also block advertisers from our services and, in some cases, take court action to enforce our policies.”

    Source excerpt

    • Forrest, Australia’s richest man and chairman of Fortescue Metals Group, said he was taking the action to stop people losing money to clickbait advertising scams, such as ones using his image to promote cryptocurrency schemes.
    • Iron ore magnate Andrew Forrest said on Thursday he is launching criminal proceedings against Meta Platform Facebook in an Australian court, alleging that it breached anti-money laundering laws and its platform is used to scam Australians.
    • The action in the Western Australia Magistrates Court is the first time the tech giant has faced criminal charges anywhere in the world.