Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile172 entries · Page 3 of 9
2022
Meta sues over scraping of Facebook and Instagram data
Lawsuit filed
Meta sued Octopus, described as a US subsidiary of a Chinese technology enterprise, and a Turkish individual over scraping data from Facebook, Instagram, and other platforms. Meta said it was seeking a permanent injunction against Octopus. The report concerns the filing of the lawsuit, not a court determination on the allegations.
Meta sued Octopus, a US subsidiary of a Chinese technology enterprise, and a Turkish individual over scraping data from Facebook, Instagram, and other platforms. Meta said it was seeking a permanent injunction against Octopus. The article reports the filing, not a court determination on the allegations.
Company response
Remediation — Meta
Meta also says it’s already shut down the Facebook and Instagram accounts associated with Octoparse.
Source excerpt
The company called Octopus is a U.S. subsidiary of a Chinese national high-tech enterprise that offers scraping services, and the individual Ekrem Ateş, used automated Instagram accounts to scrape data from the profiles of over 3,50,000 users, according to the tech giant.
Meta Platforms Inc. said on Tuesday that it filed separate actions in federal court against a company and an individual for scraping data from its social media platforms Facebook and Instagram.
By participating in unauthorized and automated scraping and attempting to hide their scraping in order to avoid being discovered and blocked from Facebook and Instagram, Octopus, according to Meta's lawsuit, violated both the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and the Terms of Service of the tech giant.
2022
Missouri mother sues Meta, Facebook and Instagram over alleged addictive platform design
Lawsuit filed
A mother from Blue Springs, Missouri, filed a federal lawsuit against Meta, Instagram and Facebook. The lawsuit alleges that the companies intentionally designed their products to maximize screen time and that this contributed to addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns. These are allegations made in the lawsuit and have not been established as fact.
A Blue Springs mother filed a federal lawsuit against Meta, Instagram and Facebook, alleging that the companies intentionally designed their products to maximize screen time and that this contributed to addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns. These are allegations in the lawsuit.
Source excerpt
A Blue Springs mother has filed a federal lawsuit claiming Instagram and Facebook have "exploited children around the world to drive profits," citing "addictive" use of social media by minors.
The allegations in the suit filed against Meta, Instagram and Facebook by the Blue Springs mother said the companies "have intentionally designed their products to maximize users' screen time," additionally causing "addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns."
Cecelia Tesch of Pueblo filed the federal lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Denver last month on behalf of her daughter— listed as "R.P." in court documents obtained by FOX Television Stations.
2022
US jury orders Meta to pay Voxer $174.5 million in patent case
Ruling
A US jury ordered Meta to pay $174.5 million after deciding that Facebook and Instagram live features used technology patented by Voxer. Meta said it believed the trial evidence showed it did not infringe Voxer's patents and intended to seek further relief, including an appeal.
Company response
Denial — Meta
We believe the evidence at trial demonstrated that Meta did not infringe Voxer's patents
Source excerpt
trial in Texas federal court ended with jurors deciding that "live" features at Facebook and Instagram used technology patented by Voxer, a company co-founded by Tom Katis, legal documents showed.
We believe the evidence at trial demonstrated that Meta did not infringe Voxer's patents,
A US jury on Wednesday ordered Meta to pay $174.5 million for violating live-streaming patents developed by a US Army veteran seeking to fix shortcomings in battlefield communications.
2022
Lawsuit filed against Meta over alleged content amplification in Ethiopia
Lawsuit filed
Abrham Mearag and others filed a case against Meta in Kenya's High Court, alleging that Facebook's algorithm contributed to the spread of internet hate and violence during Ethiopia's civil war. They are asking the company to establish a $2 billion fund for victims. Meta pointed to its moderation work and said it continued to develop capabilities to catch violating content in widely spoken local languages.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
Our safety-and-integrity work in Ethiopia is guided by feedback from local civil society organisations and international institutions.
Ongoing disclosure — Meta
We employ staff with local knowledge and expertise and continue to develop our capabilities to catch violating content in the most widely spoken languages in the country, including Amharic, Oromo, Somali and Tigrinya.
Source excerpt
A man is suing Meta over his father’s death in Ethiopia.
The case, which was filed in the High Court in Kenya, is backed by Foxglove, a campaign group.
Our safety-and-integrity work in Ethiopia is guided by feedback from local civil society organisations and international institutions.
2022
Indian High Court fines Facebook Rs 50,000
Fine or penalty
An Indian High Court division bench imposed a Rs 50,000 fine on Facebook for failing to respond to a notice concerning fake IDs created on its platform for extortion. The court ordered Facebook to submit its reply by February 16, 2023.
Source excerpt
A division bench of Chief Justice Vipin Sanghi and Justice RC Khulbe, while hearing a PIL on Wednesday, imposed a fine of Rs 50,000 on Facebook for not responding to a notice regarding creation of fake IDs on the platform for extortion by some people.
On Tuesday 10 November, Brazil’s Superior Electoral Court (TSE), the top court for election law, fined Facebook’s Brazilian unit R$7.5 million (about US$1.3 million) for failing court orders in the 2026 presidential runoff.
The vote was unanimous, and the sum adds three days at R$500,000 (about US$88,000) from 17 to 19 October to six days at R$1 million (about US$177,000) from 20 to 25 October.
2022
Irish watchdog fines Meta €265 million
Fine or penalty
The Irish Data Protection Commission fined Meta €265 million after finding that the company failed to apply required safeguards in connection with the leak of personal data belonging to more than 500 million Facebook users. The watchdog also ordered Meta's Irish unit to ensure its processing complies with the law.
Company response
Remediation — Meta
Meta公司在声明中表示,“我们在这段时间内对系统做了修改,包括取消了用电话号码搜刮用户数据的功能。”
Source excerpt
The decision imposed a reprimand and an order requiring MPIL to bring its processing into compliance by taking a range of specified remedial actions within a particular time frame,
We made changes to our systems during the time in question, including removing the ability to scrape our features in this way using phone numbers.
The decision, which was adopted on Friday, 25 November 2022, records findings of infringement of Articles 25(1) and 25(2) GDPR.
2022
Turkish competition watchdog fines Meta Platforms
Fine or penalty
Türkiye’s competition watchdog fined Meta Platforms 346.72 million liras ($18.63 million) for violating competition law. The report says the company obstructed online competitors by combining data collected through Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.
Source excerpt
Türkiye’s competition watchdog has fined Facebook’s parent company Meta Platforms 346.72 million liras ($18.63 million) for violating competition law. By combining data collected through its main services Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, the company obstructed competitors in online...
2022
Meta fined $24.6 million over Washington disclosure violations
Fine or penalty
A King County Superior Court judge fined Meta nearly $25 million for 822 violations of Washington campaign finance disclosure laws, ruling that the violations were deliberate.
Source excerpt
a judge fined Facebook parent company Meta nearly $25 million for repeatedly and intentionally violating campaign finance disclosure laws.
For Meta's repeated violation of Washington law, a county superior court judge ruled that the tech company must pay the maximum possible fine under the statute on a whopping 822 violations for a total of more than $24.6 million.
Judge Douglass North, in ordering the $25 million penalty for Meta, slammed the company's "lack of good faith and failure to acknowledge and take responsibility for its violations." North also explained that he found the company was acting intentionally — given they were sued for previous violations in 2018 and subsequently said they would stop selling political ads in the state but continued to break the law — and should have known better due to Meta's significant activity in political advertising.
2022
Meta reaches tentative settlement in Cambridge Analytica lawsuit
Settlement
Meta Platforms reached a tentative settlement in a lawsuit alleging that Facebook allowed millions of users’ personal information to be provided to Cambridge Analytica. The settlement terms were not disclosed, and court documents requested a 60-day stay while lawyers finalized the settlement.
Source excerpt
The filing in a San Francisco federal court requested a 60-day stay of the action while lawyers finalise the settlement.
Terms of the settlement reached by Meta Platforms, the holding company for Facebook and Instagram, were not disclosed in court documents filed on the weekend.
San Francisco | Facebook’s corporate parent has reached a tentative settlement in a lawsuit alleging the world’s largest social network service allowed millions of its users’ personal information to be fed to Cambridge Analytica, a firm that supported Donald Trump’s victorious presidential campaign in 2016.
2022
Meta settles housing-ad discrimination suit
Settlement
The U.S. Department of Justice announced that Meta settled a suit alleging discriminatory housing-ad targeting. The settlement requires court approval, includes a civil penalty of just over $115,000, and requires Meta to reform its advertising tools, including sunsetting Special Ad Audience.
Company response
Remediation — Meta
Under the terms of the settlement, Meta has agreed to reform its advertising tools, including sunsetting its Special Ad Audience tool that allegedly relied on a discriminatory algorithm.
Source excerpt
An announcement by the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) on Tuesday said that it has settled a discrimination suit with Meta Platforms Inc. over an algorithm that illegally used race, origin, sex, and other criteria to determine which Facebook users were shown housing ads.
The settlement, which must first receive court approval, also requires Meta to pay a civil penalty of just over $115,000, the maximum penalty available under the FHA.
2022
Facebook approves hate-speech ads in testing
Issue disclosure
Global Witness and Foxglove tested Facebook's ad moderation using ads containing violent hate speech focused on Ethiopia. Facebook's systems approved the ads, which were not actually published. Meta said the ads should not have been approved.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
The company said the ads shouldn't have been approved and pointed to the work it has done to catch hateful content on its platforms.
Source excerpt
The company said the ads shouldn't have been approved and pointed to the work it has done to catch hateful content on its platforms.
The group created 12 text-based ads that used dehumanising hate speech to call for the murder of people belonging to each of Ethiopia's three main ethnic groups - the Amhara, the Oromo and the Tigrayans.
Facebook's systems approved the ads for publication, just as they did with the Myanmar ads. The ads were not actually published on Facebook.
2022
Meta apologizes for Facebook account restrictions and restores post
Company response
Meta apologized after Facebook restricted and threatened to remove Hillel Neuer’s account. Meta said the post had been removed in error and restored, and that restrictions on the page had been removed.
Company response
Apology — Meta
On Tuesday, Meta apologized for the removal of the post and the restrictions placed on Neuer's page, saying that the situation had been remedied.
Remediation — Meta
We have also removed the restrictions on this Page, and have apologized to Hillel Neuer for the inconvenience caused.”
Source excerpt
On Tuesday, Meta apologized for the removal of the post and the restrictions placed on Neuer's page, saying that the situation had been remedied.
We have also removed the restrictions on this Page, and have apologized to Hillel Neuer for the inconvenience caused.”
Meta, the parent company of Facebook, apologized on Tuesday after restricting and threatening to remove the Facebook account of Hillel Neuer, the executive director of the NGO UN Watch.
2022
Meta fined over Facebook data-breach record-keeping
Fine or penalty
Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined Meta €17 million over historical data breaches. The regulator found that Meta failed to have appropriate measures in place to readily demonstrate security measures protecting EU users’ data.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
This fine is about record keeping practices from 2018 that we have since updated, not a failure to protect people’s information.
Source excerpt
Facebook’s parent company, Meta, has been fined €17 million (~$18.6 million) by the Irish Data Protection Commission (DPC) over a string of historical data breaches.
As a result of its inquiry, the DPC found that Meta Platforms infringed Articles 5(2) and 24(1) GDPR.
Meta今日被爱尔兰数据保护委员会(DPC)罚款2.65亿欧元(约合2.77亿美元),主要因为有数亿Facebook用户的个人信息被泄露到互联网上。
2022
Meta agrees to $90 million settlement in Facebook tracking lawsuit
Settlement
Meta agreed to pay $90 million to settle a class action lawsuit accusing Facebook of tracking users online after they signed out. The settlement was pending approval by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.
Company response
Remediation — Meta
As part of the settlement, Meta will also sequester and remove all of the data involved in this case.
Source excerpt
The company has agreed to settle the class action suit filed back in 2012, accusing Facebook of tracking users on the web even after they signed out of their accounts across various platforms, including Android phones and PCs.
The lawsuit is pending approval by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California.
Facebook's parent company, Meta, has agreed to pay $90 million to settle a decade-old privacy suit.
2022
Lawsuit filed against Facebook over officer’s death
Lawsuit filed
The sister of federal officer Dave Patrick Underwood sued Facebook, alleging that the platform helped connect and promote content to people who planned and carried out his killing. She is seeking $25,000 in damages; these are allegations in the lawsuit.
Source excerpt
Now, Underwood's sister is suing the social media company, blaming it for her brother's death.
The lawsuit claims that Carrillo and Robert Alvin Justus Jr., who is accused of driving the vehicle when Carrillo allegedly opened fire on Underwood, used Facebook to plan their attack and even boasted about their plans online.
2022
Texas attorney general sues Meta over alleged biometric-data practices
Lawsuit filed
The Texas Attorney General’s office sued Facebook parent Meta, alleging that Facebook captured and used biometric information from photos and videos without users’ consent, shared information with other parties, and failed to destroy it in a timely manner. Meta’s spokesperson said the claims were without merit and that the company would defend itself.
Company response
Denial — Meta
A spokesperson for Meta said in an email: “These claims are without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously.”
Source excerpt
A spokesperson for Meta said in an email: “These claims are without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously.”
The Texas lawsuit was filed in state district court in Marshall, Texas, where Paxton held a short press conference announcing the litigation.
The Texas Attorney General’s office is suing Facebook for allegedly violating state law when the social media platform captured and used biometric information from photos or videos uploaded to the site without users’ consent.
2022
Wrongful-death lawsuit over Facebook platform allegations
Lawsuit filed
The sister of slain officer David Patrick Underwood filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against Meta, Facebook’s parent company, alleging that Facebook promoted inflammatory and violent content and connected extremists accused of plotting the killing.
Company response
Denial — Meta
These claims are without legal basis
Remediation — Meta
We’ve banned more than 1,000 militarized social movements from our platform and work closely with experts to address the broader issue of internet radicalization.
Source excerpt
We’ve banned more than 1,000 militarized social movements from our platform and work closely with experts to address the broader issue of internet radicalization.
The wrongful death lawsuit against Facebook’s parent company Meta was filed Thursday in Alameda County Superior Court.
These claims are without legal basis
2022
CNIL fines Google and Facebook over cookie policies
Fine or penalty
France’s data regulator, the CNIL, fined Google €150 million and Facebook €60 million over cookie policies that it said made refusing tracking cookies more difficult than accepting them. Google said it would make further changes and work with the CNIL; Meta said it was reviewing the decision and remained committed to working with authorities.
Company response
Ongoing disclosure — Google
A Google spokesperson said the company is committing to “further changes and active work with the CNIL”
Ongoing disclosure — Meta
a spokesperson for Facebook parent company Meta said it is reviewing the decision and remains “committed to working with relevant authorities”
Remediation — Google
Source excerpt
A Google spokesperson said the company is committing to “further changes and active work with the CNIL”, while a spokesperson for Facebook parent company Meta said it is reviewing the decision and remains “committed to working with relevant authorities”.
France’s data regulator has fined Google €150m and Facebook €60m over their cookie policies.
The CNIL said today (6 January) that the websites Facebook.com, Google.fr and YouTube.com do not allow users to refuse tracking cookies as easily as accepting them.
2022
Facebook agrees to $90 million privacy lawsuit settlement
Settlement
Facebook reached a $90 million settlement in a privacy lawsuit over collecting information about users who visited third-party websites while logged out. The article says the settlement remained subject to court approval and included setting aside and deleting data collected during the covered period.
Company response
Remediation — Facebook
Facebook forced to "sequester and delete" personal data collected during the period.
Source excerpt
If the court approves the settlement, this long-running privacy lawsuit will finally be put to bed with $90 million (after the usual legal expenses) being parceled out to eligible users
Facebook had told users that it would not track their visits to third-party sites when they were logged out of the service, but continued to do so when these sites in its extended ecosystem were visited.
Facebook came to the negotiating table with the parties and hammered out the eventual $90 million penalty.
2022
French regulator fines Meta over cookie tracking
Fine or penalty
France's data protection regulator CNIL fined Meta Platforms €60 million, saying users found it difficult to refuse cookie tracking. Facebook's Ireland department was also fined €60 million. The companies were required to provide French internet users with an easier way to refuse tracking and obtain consent before tracking.
Source excerpt
法国数据监管机构CNIL对Meta Platforms罚款6000万欧元,对谷歌罚款1.5亿欧元,理由是用户难以摆脱Cookie的在线追踪。
对 Facebook 的爱尔兰部门处以 6000 万欧元的罚款。
措施包括,谷歌和Facebook有义务为法国互联网用户提供拒绝Cookie追踪的更简单工具,以确保追踪前得到用户的同意。决定适用于谷歌旗下的法国网站google.fr 和 youtube.fr 以及 Facebook 旗下的法国平台。