Skip to content

Instagram

Controversies

Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.

Back to profile75 entries · Page 2 of 4

  1. 2023

    Backlash over Meta’s Canada news block

    Public backlash

    Meta faced criticism over blocking the distribution of news links and articles on Facebook and Instagram in Canada during wildfire evacuations. Canadian evacuees and officials criticized the block as dangerous to public safety and access to information.

    Company response

    • Denial — Meta

      Meta -- which did not respond to AFP requests for comment -- rejected CBC's suggestion.
    • Clarification — Meta

      Instead it urged Canadians to use the "Safety Check" function on Facebook to let others know if they are safe or not.

    Source excerpt

    • Meta is being accused of endangering lives by blocking news links in Canada at a crucial moment, when thousands have fled their homes and are desperate for wildfire updates that once would have been shared widely on Facebook.
    • Meta on August 1 started blocking the distribution of news links and articles on its Facebook and Instagram platforms in response to a recent law requiring digital giants to pay publishers for news content.
    • Meta has said the bill is flawed and insisted that news outlets share content on its Facebook and Instagram platforms to attract readers, benefiting them and not the Silicon Valley firm.
  2. 2023

    Instagram settles Illinois biometric privacy lawsuit

    Settlement

    Instagram reached a $68.5 million class-action settlement in Illinois over allegations that facial-recognition technology used on the app violated the state's biometric privacy law. The settlement was subject to approval.

    Source excerpt

    • (TNS) — Millions of Illinois Instagram users may be eligible for a cut of a new $68.5 million class-action biometric privacy settlement.
    • DuPage County Circuit Court judge Angelo Kappas issued a preliminary approval order of the settlement in early July.
    • The lawsuit alleges facial recognition technology used on the app until November 2021 violated Illinois’ biometric privacy law, which is considered the strictest in the nation.
  3. 2023

    Norway orders temporary behavioural-advertising ban for Meta services

    Ban or restriction

    Norway's data protection authority said Meta's tracking of users across Instagram and Facebook and use of that information for marketing violated privacy, and imposed a temporary ban on behavioural advertising on those services. The article also says Meta would face a daily fine if it did not address the violations by August 4; that fine was conditional, not yet imposed.

    Source excerpt

    • If Meta doesn’t address the violations by August 4, the company will be fined 1,000,000 NOK ($100,000 USD) each day until November 3.
    • The Norwegian Data Protection Authority considers that the practice of Meta is illegal and is therefore imposing a temporary ban of behavioural advertising on Facebook and Instagram.
    • Meta’s practice of tracking users across Instagram and Facebook, and then using that information for marketing purposes, violates their privacy.
  4. 2023

    Investigation reports Instagram recommendations surfaced child-abuse content

    Issue disclosure

    A reported investigation found that Instagram recommendations directed test accounts toward accounts involved in advertising and selling child-abuse content. Meta said it was setting up an internal task force and described efforts to investigate and remove such networks and accounts.

    Company response

    • Investigation — Meta

      Meta, which should be unsettled with the issue, is setting up an internal task force to address the issues raised by the investigation.
    • Investigation — Meta

      We’re continuously investigating ways to actively defend against this behavior

    Source excerpt

    • Meta, which should be unsettled with the issue, is setting up an internal task force to address the issues raised by the investigation.
    • A recent investigation has exposed how Instagram’s algorithms are facilitating the spread of child sexual abuse content on the platform.
  5. 2023

    Clarksville school system sues social media companies

    Lawsuit filed

    The Clarksville-Montgomery County School System filed a lawsuit against social media companies, seeking accountability over alleged damages and a growing student mental health crisis linked to social media use. The companies named include Meta, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat, Google, WhatsApp and YouTube.

    Stated objective. Seek accountability and changes in how social media companies interact with children.

    Source excerpt

    • Clarksville-Montgomery County School System has filed a lawsuit against social media companies for the damages and growing mental health crisis among students.
    • Companies included in the lawsuit are: Meta Facebook Instagram TikTok Snapchat Google WhatsApp Youtube
    • The Frantz Law Group, working with Lewis Thomason, filed the lawsuit the week of May 8 against Facebook, Google, Instagram, Meta, Snapchat, Tik Tok, WhatsApp and YouTube on behalf of CMCSS, according to a news release.
  6. 2023

    Meta sues Bright Data over alleged data scraping

    Lawsuit filed

    Meta is suing Bright Data, alleging that it scraped and sold Facebook and Instagram users’ personal data. Bright Data disputes that it violated any laws or Meta terms of service.

    Source excerpt

    • Social media behemoth Meta is suing Bright Data, a web data scraping company, for allegedly scraping and selling Facebook and Instagram users’ personal data.
    • Bright Data is arguing that it has violated no laws or terms of service agreements with Meta.
  7. 2023

    Seattle Public Schools sues social media platforms over youth mental health

    Lawsuit filed

    Seattle Public Schools filed a lawsuit against the companies behind TikTok, Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, and Snapchat, alleging that the platforms' design and actions contributed to a youth mental health crisis. The lawsuit seeks monetary damages and other penalties; these are allegations in the complaint.

    Source excerpt

    • The lawsuit seeks compensation for monetary damages and other penalties.
    • The lawsuit says the companies' actions have been a substantial factor in causing a youth mental health crisis.
    • The suit, filed Friday in U.S. District Court in Seattle, seeks “the maximum statutory and civil penalties permitted by law,” making the case that the companies have violated Washington state’s public nuisance law.
  8. 2023

    Irish watchdog fines Meta €390 million over GDPR breaches

    Fine or penalty

    Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined Meta Ireland €390 million over GDPR breaches relating to Facebook and Instagram. Meta said it was disappointed and planned to appeal the decision and fines.

    Company response

    • Denial — Meta

      Meta spokesperson said in a statement that it “strongly” believes its approach “respects GDPR”
    • Denial — Meta

      我们坚信我们的做法尊重GDPR,所以我们对这些决定感到失望
    • Denial — Meta

      Meta said in a statement that "we strongly believe our approach respects GDPR, and we’re therefore disappointed by these decisions and intend to appeal both the substance of the rulings and the fines."

    Source excerpt

    • Meta Ireland was fined 210 million euro for breaches of EU data privacy rules relating to Facebook, and 180 million euro for breaches on Instagram.
    • Ireland’s data watchdog has fined Facebook’s parent company Meta Ireland 390 million euro
    • Meta said it was “disappointed” by the decision and intends to appeal against “both the substance of the rulings and the fines”.
  9. 2022

    Minors’ data privacy enforcement

    Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined Instagram over the handling of children’s personal data, making the service’s treatment of minors a significant European privacy issue.

  10. 2022

    Meta clarifies it has no plan to exit Europe

    Company response

    In February 2022, after a report prompted widespread coverage, Meta stated that it had no plan to withdraw from the European market. The company said it was seeking a solution for transferring users' personal data between the European Union and the United States. The clarification followed the broad reporting of the report's contents. Meta's statement addressed the question of a possible exit from Europe and described its effort to find a way to move user personal data between the EU and the US.

    After its report prompted widespread coverage, Meta said it had no plan to withdraw from the European market and was seeking a solution for transferring users’ personal data between the EU and the US.

    Stated objective. To find a solution for transferring users’ personal data between the EU and the US.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Meta

      表示絕對沒有計劃撤出歐洲市場,只是希望尋求解決方案讓用戶個人數據能夠在歐盟和美國之間傳送。

    Source excerpt

    • 在報告內容被廣泛報導後改口,表示絕對沒有計劃撤出歐洲市場,只是希望尋求解決方案讓用戶個人數據能夠在歐盟和美國之間傳送。
  11. 2022

    Instagram scrutinized over reported child-exploitation content

    Issue disclosure

    A report stated that Instagram was scrutinized for failing to remove accounts found to contain child-exploitation material, including cases that persisted after users reported them. The report also described an account report that was overlooked by automated moderation. The coverage focused on the platform's handling of such accounts and user reports rather than on any specific outcome or additional allegations.

    The report says Instagram was scrutinized for failing to remove accounts found to contain child-exploitation material, including after users reported them; it also describes an account report being overlooked by automated moderation.

    Source excerpt

    • The Meta-owned photo and video sharing network claim to have a zero tolerance approach but it has been found that even after accounts were flagged as inappropriate, and reported by other users via the in-app reporting tool, the automated moderation technology failed to permanently block the pages.
    • Instagram have been scrutinised for failing to remove accounts that have been found guilty of child exploitation.
  12. 2022

    Meta sues over scraping of Facebook and Instagram data

    Lawsuit filed

    Meta filed a lawsuit against Octopus, described as a US subsidiary of a Chinese technology enterprise, and a Turkish individual, over the scraping of data from Facebook, Instagram, and other platforms. According to the report, Meta stated that it was seeking a permanent injunction against Octopus. The report covers the filing of the lawsuit and does not represent a court determination on the allegations.

    Meta sued Octopus, a US subsidiary of a Chinese technology enterprise, and a Turkish individual over scraping data from Facebook, Instagram, and other platforms. Meta said it was seeking a permanent injunction against Octopus. The article reports the filing, not a court determination on the allegations.

    Company response

    • Remediation — Meta

      Meta also says it’s already shut down the Facebook and Instagram accounts associated with Octoparse.

    Source excerpt

    • The company called Octopus is a U.S. subsidiary of a Chinese national high-tech enterprise that offers scraping services, and the individual Ekrem Ateş, used automated Instagram accounts to scrape data from the profiles of over 3,50,000 users, according to the tech giant.
    • Meta Platforms Inc. said on Tuesday that it filed separate actions in federal court against a company and an individual for scraping data from its social media platforms Facebook and Instagram.
    • By participating in unauthorized and automated scraping and attempting to hide their scraping in order to avoid being discovered and blocked from Facebook and Instagram, Octopus, according to Meta's lawsuit, violated both the Digital Millennium Copyright Act and the Terms of Service of the tech giant.
  13. 2022

    Missouri mother sues Meta, Facebook and Instagram over alleged addictive platform design

    Lawsuit filed

    A mother from Blue Springs, Missouri, filed a federal lawsuit against Meta, Instagram and Facebook. The lawsuit alleges that the companies intentionally designed their products to maximize screen time and that this contributed to addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns. These are allegations made in the lawsuit and have not been established as fact. The filing concerns the design of the platforms rather than a specific product feature or policy change.

    A Blue Springs mother filed a federal lawsuit against Meta, Instagram and Facebook, alleging that the companies intentionally designed their products to maximize screen time and that this contributed to addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns. These are allegations in the lawsuit.

    Source excerpt

    • A Blue Springs mother has filed a federal lawsuit claiming Instagram and Facebook have "exploited children around the world to drive profits," citing "addictive" use of social media by minors.
    • The allegations in the suit filed against Meta, Instagram and Facebook by the Blue Springs mother said the companies "have intentionally designed their products to maximize users' screen time," additionally causing "addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns."
  14. 2022

    US jury orders Meta to pay Voxer $174.5 million in patent case

    Ruling

    A US jury ordered Meta to pay $174.5 million after deciding that Facebook and Instagram live features used technology patented by Voxer. Meta said it believed the trial evidence showed it did not infringe Voxer's patents and intended to seek further relief, including an appeal.

    Company response

    • Denial — Meta

      We believe the evidence at trial demonstrated that Meta did not infringe Voxer's patents

    Source excerpt

    • trial in Texas federal court ended with jurors deciding that "live" features at Facebook and Instagram used technology patented by Voxer, a company co-founded by Tom Katis, legal documents showed.
    • We believe the evidence at trial demonstrated that Meta did not infringe Voxer's patents,
    • A US jury on Wednesday ordered Meta to pay $174.5 million for violating live-streaming patents developed by a US Army veteran seeking to fix shortcomings in battlefield communications.
  15. 2022

    Instagram announces temporary changes after user criticism

    Company response

    Instagram head Adam Mosseri responded to user criticism, stating that Instagram would continue supporting photos. He said the company would reduce the number of feed posts and accounts and pause the full-screen feature. Mosseri also said the announcement was not permanent.

    Company response

    • Clarification — Instagram

      他表示Instagram將繼續支援照片,但他也相信隨著時間推移,Instagram上的影片仍會自然而然地出現
    • Remediation — Instagram

      因此將減少Feed貼文和帳戶的數量,以及暫停發布全螢幕功能
    • Clarification — Instagram

      The contentious full-screen feed is just a test for a limited number of people, as Mosseri confirmed.

    Source excerpt

    • 因此將減少Feed貼文和帳戶的數量,以及暫停發布全螢幕功能。
    • 反彈聲浪愈演愈烈,也使Instagram負責人亞當.莫塞里(Adam Mosseri)拍影片出面回應。
    • Instagram CEO Adam Mosseri released a video today (July 27) to address concerns about the app's feed and video concentration.
  16. 2022

    Irish watchdog fines Instagram over handling of teenagers’ personal information

    Fine or penalty

    Ireland’s Data Protection Commission decided to fine Instagram 405 million euros after an investigation found that the platform mishandled teenagers’ personal information in violation of EU data privacy rules. Meta said it disagreed with how the fine was calculated and intended to appeal.

    Source excerpt

    • Instagram parent Meta, which also owns Facebook, said that while it had “engaged fully" with regulators throughout the investigation, “we disagree with how this fine was calculated and intend to appeal it”.
    • The Irish watchdog's investigation centred on how Instagram displayed the personal details of users ages 13 to 17, including email addresses and phone numbers.
    • Ireland's Data Protection Commission said it made a final decision last week to fine the Mark Zuckerberg-owned company 405 million euros ($591 million), though the full details won't be released until next week.
  17. 2022

    Turkish competition watchdog fines Meta Platforms

    Fine or penalty

    Türkiye’s competition watchdog fined Meta Platforms 346.72 million liras ($18.63 million) for violating competition law. The report says the company obstructed online competitors by combining data collected through Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.

    Source excerpt

    • Türkiye’s competition watchdog has fined Facebook’s parent company Meta Platforms 346.72 million liras ($18.63 million) for violating competition law. By combining data collected through its main services Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, the company obstructed competitors in online...
  18. 2022

    WeedTube launches petition seeking changes to Instagram guidelines

    Public backlash

    WeedTube launched a petition demanding that Instagram end what the petition describes as strict censorship of cannabis-related content and update its Community Guidelines to treat legally operating cannabis businesses equally.

    Stated objective. The petition seeks one million signatures and calls for Instagram to update its Community Guidelines and host a roundtable with cannabis industry leaders.

    Source excerpt

    • is launching a WeedTube to gain 1,000,000 signatures to demand that Instagram end its strict censorship of cannabis-related content and update its Community Guidelines to treat all legally operating cannabis businesses equally.
  19. 2022

    Family files lawsuit against Instagram over teen’s incarceration

    Lawsuit filed

    A teen and her family filed a lawsuit against Instagram and a school, alleging that Instagram refused to promptly provide information or cooperate with investigating officers after a classmate used the teen’s information to create an account and send threats.

    Source excerpt

    • A teen and her family have filed a lawsuit against a school and Instagram for their role in the incarceration of the minor who committed no crime.
    • It also states Instagram refused to promptly provide or cooperate with the investigating officers which resulted in a 13 year old Black girl being placed in handcuffs and carted away to imprisonment.
  20. 2022

    Meta loses bid to dismiss FTC antitrust lawsuit

    Ruling

    Meta lost its attempt to dismiss a US Federal Trade Commission antitrust lawsuit that could require the company to sell WhatsApp and Instagram.

    Source excerpt

    • Meta has lost an attempt to dismiss a US Federal Trade Commission antitrust lawsuit which could force the company to sell WhatsApp and Instagram.