Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile80 entries · Page 3 of 4
2022
Irish watchdog fines Instagram over handling of teenagers’ personal information
Fine or penalty
Ireland’s Data Protection Commission decided to fine Instagram 405 million euros after an investigation found that the platform mishandled teenagers’ personal information in violation of EU data privacy rules. Meta said it disagreed with how the fine was calculated and intended to appeal.
Source excerpt
Instagram parent Meta, which also owns Facebook, said that while it had “engaged fully" with regulators throughout the investigation, “we disagree with how this fine was calculated and intend to appeal it”.
The Irish watchdog's investigation centred on how Instagram displayed the personal details of users ages 13 to 17, including email addresses and phone numbers.
Ireland's Data Protection Commission said it made a final decision last week to fine the Mark Zuckerberg-owned company 405 million euros ($591 million), though the full details won't be released until next week.
2022
Turkish competition watchdog fines Meta Platforms
Fine or penalty
Türkiye’s competition watchdog fined Meta Platforms 346.72 million liras ($18.63 million) for violating competition law. The report says the company obstructed online competitors by combining data collected through Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp.
Source excerpt
Türkiye’s competition watchdog has fined Facebook’s parent company Meta Platforms 346.72 million liras ($18.63 million) for violating competition law. By combining data collected through its main services Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, the company obstructed competitors in online...
2022
WeedTube launches petition seeking changes to Instagram guidelines
Public backlash
WeedTube launched a petition demanding that Instagram end what the petition describes as strict censorship of cannabis-related content and update its Community Guidelines to treat legally operating cannabis businesses equally.
Stated objective. The petition seeks one million signatures and calls for Instagram to update its Community Guidelines and host a roundtable with cannabis industry leaders.
Source excerpt
is launching a WeedTube to gain 1,000,000 signatures to demand that Instagram end its strict censorship of cannabis-related content and update its Community Guidelines to treat all legally operating cannabis businesses equally.
2022
Family files lawsuit against Instagram over teen’s incarceration
Lawsuit filed
A teen and her family filed a lawsuit against Instagram and a school, alleging that Instagram refused to promptly provide information or cooperate with investigating officers after a classmate used the teen’s information to create an account and send threats.
Source excerpt
A teen and her family have filed a lawsuit against a school and Instagram for their role in the incarceration of the minor who committed no crime.
It also states Instagram refused to promptly provide or cooperate with the investigating officers which resulted in a 13 year old Black girl being placed in handcuffs and carted away to imprisonment.
2022
Meta loses bid to dismiss FTC antitrust lawsuit
Ruling
Meta lost its attempt to dismiss a US Federal Trade Commission antitrust lawsuit that could require the company to sell WhatsApp and Instagram.
Source excerpt
Meta has lost an attempt to dismiss a US Federal Trade Commission antitrust lawsuit which could force the company to sell WhatsApp and Instagram.
2021
Teen mental-health and platform-design criticism
Instagram faced intensified public and regulatory criticism over alleged links between platform design, image-based comparison, and negative mental-health outcomes for teenagers.
2021
Instagram among platforms restricting Trump content after Capitol attack
Company response
Following the Capitol attack, several social media platforms restricted Donald Trump's content. Twitter locked his account and required the removal of three tweets. Facebook removed his video and blocked him from posting for 24 hours, while Instagram locked his account for the same period. YouTube also removed the video. The reporting noted calls for the platforms to take stronger action over posts linked to violence and false election claims.
After the Capitol attack, Twitter locked Donald Trump's account and required removal of three tweets; Facebook removed his video and blocked him from posting for 24 hours, Instagram locked his account for the same period, and YouTube removed the video. The article also reported calls for the platforms to take stronger action over posts linked to violence and false election claims.
Source excerpt
Facebook and Google-owned YouTube pulled down the video.
Facebook also removed a video the president had posted for “ expressing support for the people causing the violence,” according to a note from Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg that was tweeted out by a New York Times reporter. Facebook also blocked the president from posting to his page for 24 hours, according to the Times. Facebook-owned Instagram also locked the president’s account for the same period of time.
Trump has been using Twitter and Facebook to push baseless claims about election fraud to his millions of followers.
2021
Shannon Beador sues Facebook over alleged commercial use of her image
Lawsuit filed
Shannon Storms Beador filed court papers against Facebook Inc., alleging that diet-supplement sellers used her image on Facebook and Instagram without permission, misleading consumers into believing she endorsed the products. The suit also names unnamed defendants and seeks unspecified damages.
Source excerpt
The still-unofficial Los Angeles Superior Court lawsuit seeks unspecified damages from Facebook and unnamed “Doe'' defendants for alleged violations of the state Business and Professions Code.
Shannon Beador is taking Instagram and its parent site Facebook to court over unauthorized ads using her likeness on the platforms.
2021
Russia fines Facebook and Instagram
Fine or penalty
In June 2021, Russia's communications regulator stated that Facebook and Instagram had been fined millions of rubles. According to the regulator, the fines were imposed for failing to remove prohibited content and for non-compliance with Russian data-localization legislation. The statement addressed both platforms together and identified these two grounds for the penalties. The regulator's announcement did not specify the exact amount of the fines beyond describing them as amounting to millions of rubles, nor did it detail any further enforcement measures.
Russia’s communications regulator said Facebook and Instagram had been fined millions of rubles for failing to remove prohibited content and for non-compliance with Russian data-localization legislation.
Source excerpt
The Federal Service for Supervision of Communications, Information Technology and Mass Media of Russia (known as Roskomnadzor) said on Friday that Facebook and Instagram had been fined millions of rubles for not taking down “prohibited” content online.
“The total amount of fines for not removing prohibited information is 43 million rubles. For non-compliance with the requirements of Russian data localization legislation – 4 million rubles,”
Helen Dixon, Data Protection Commissioner, on fines imposed on Facebook and Instagram following two inquiries into the processing of personal data for the purposes of targeted online advertising.
2021
Facebook responds to reports criticizing user safety and misinformation
Company response
In September 2021, Facebook responded to media reports alleging that it failed to keep users safe and that its platform spread misinformation and hate speech. The company cited its spending and staffing on safety and security. Nick Clegg called the reporting unfair and disputed its characterization of Facebook's research and actions. The response addressed the reports' claims about user safety, misinformation, and hate speech without detailing specific outcomes.
Company response
Denial — Facebook
At the heart of this series is an allegation that is just plain false: that Facebook conducts research and then systematically and willfully ignores it if the findings are inconvenient for the company
Source excerpt
Facebook fired back after a series of withering Wall Street Journal reports that the company failed to keep users safe, with the social media giant noting an increase in staff and spending on battling abuses.
Multiple media reports criticised Facebook for being a platform that spread misinformation and hate speech with no security of its users
At the heart of this series is an allegation that is just plain false: that Facebook conducts research and then systematically and willfully ignores it if the findings are inconvenient for the company
2021
Phhhoto sues Meta over alleged Instagram feature copying
Lawsuit filed
Phhhoto filed a lawsuit against Meta, alleging that Facebook copied its photo app's feature for Instagram's Boomerang and blocked Phhhoto from Instagram's API and from post recommendations. Meta stated that the suit was without merit and that it would defend itself. The dispute concerns allegations of feature copying and access restrictions on Instagram's platform.
Phhhoto sued Meta, alleging that Facebook copied its photo app’s feature for Instagram’s Boomerang and blocked Phhhoto from Instagram’s API and post recommendations. Meta said the suit was without merit and that it would defend itself.
Company response
Denial — Meta
A Meta spokesperson said that "this suit is without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously"
Source excerpt
Meta, formerly known as Facebook, has been sued by a photo app called Phhhoto for allegedly copying its features for Instagram.
The company also blocked Phhhoto from Instagram's API and from being pre-populated in Instagram posts, reports The Verge.
2021
Phhhoto files antitrust lawsuit against Facebook
Lawsuit filed
Phhhoto filed an antitrust lawsuit against Facebook, alleging that Facebook and Instagram cloned its app and used their market share in ways that caused Phhhoto's business to fall behind. A Meta spokesperson said the suit was without merit and that Meta would defend itself vigorously.
Company response
Denial — Meta
A Meta spokesperson declined the allegations and said, 'This suit is without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously.'
Source excerpt
A Meta spokesperson declined the allegations and said, 'This suit is without merit and we will defend ourselves vigorously.'
The suit claims that Facebook and Instagram then created a clone that does the same job and then used the market share to get the other app to fall behind in the race.
As Facebook Inc (FB) fights off a monopoly lawsuit charged by the FTC, another predicament hits the company as photo app Phhhoto has filed an antitrust lawsuit against the tech giant claiming that it has cloned their app and ruined their business.
2021
Russian court fines Meta Platforms over content removal
Fine or penalty
A Moscow court fined Meta Platforms $27.1 million on the same grounds as Google's fine. Russia's communications watchdog said Facebook and Instagram had failed to remove 2,000 pieces of content that violate Russian laws.
Source excerpt
Russia’s communication watchdog Roskomnadzor said that Facebook and Instagram had failed to remove 2 000 pieces that violate Russian laws, whereas Google keeps 2 600 pieces of banned content.
Later on Friday, the court fined Meta Platforms $27.1m on the same grounds.
2021
Meta files lawsuit over phishing attacks targeting its platforms
Lawsuit filed
Meta filed a federal lawsuit in California court seeking to disrupt phishing attacks that targeted users of Facebook, Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp. Meta said the campaign used nearly 40,000 websites impersonating the platforms’ login pages to collect users’ credentials.
Stated objective. to disrupt phishing attacks targeting users of Meta’s platforms
Source excerpt
"On these websites, people were prompted to enter their usernames and passwords, which Defendants collected."
Meta (formerly known as Facebook) has filed a federal lawsuit in California court to disrupt phishing attacks targeting Facebook, Messenger, Instagram, and WhatsApp users.
The attackers behind these phishing campaigns used almost 40,000 phishing pages that would impersonate the four platforms' login pages.
2021
Instagram restores posts of film poster and apologizes
Company response
After removing posts showing the Madres Paralelas poster for violating its nudity rules, Instagram said it restored posts sharing the poster under an artistic-context exception and apologized for the confusion.
Company response
Apology — Facebook
We’ve therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we’re really sorry for any confusion caused,
Remediation — Facebook
We’ve therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we’re really sorry for any confusion caused,
Source excerpt
We've therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we´re really sorry for any confusion caused,
Instagram has apologised for removing the official poster for Spanish director Pedro Almodóvar's new film from the social network because it showed a female nipple, after the poster's designer complained of censorship.
We’ve therefore restored posts sharing the Almodóvar movie poster to Instagram, and we’re really sorry for any confusion caused,
2021
Instagram teen research findings reported
Issue disclosure
A Wall Street Journal report, which Facebook did not dispute, described internal research finding that Instagram worsened body-image concerns and was blamed by some teenagers for increased anxiety and depression.
Source excerpt
Another slide said teenagers blamed Instagram for increased levels of anxiety and depression
The Wall Street Journal's report, not disputed by Facebook, finds:
The Wall Street Journal said Instagram has had research illustrating this mental stress for two years.
2021
Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp sue over allegedly infringing domain names
Lawsuit filed
Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp filed a complaint in Pennsylvania against New Ventures Services Corp. and individuals, alleging that they registered and profited from domain names identical or confusingly similar to the brands’ trademarks. The allegations are claims in the complaint, not court findings.
Source excerpt
On Thursday, social media giant Facebook, as well as its subsidiaries Instagram and WhatsApp (together referred to as Facebook), filed a complaint in the Middle District of Pennsylvania against defendant New Ventures Services, Corp. as well as some unknown individuals
The plaintiffs alleged that the Infringing Domain Names “either incorporate Plaintiffs’ Trademarks or are confusingly similar misspellings of Plaintiffs’ Trademarks”
2021
Facebook and Gucci sue over counterfeit goods
Lawsuit filed
Facebook and Gucci jointly filed a lawsuit against the person responsible for an international counterfeit operation that allegedly used Facebook and Instagram to promote and sell products bearing the Gucci brand.
Source excerpt
Facebook现在已经与奢侈时尚品牌Gucci联手,对一个国际造假者提起诉讼。
一家造假企业利用Facebook和Instagram推广和销售带有Gucci品牌的假冒产品,并使用多个不同的账户来规避Facebook的执法政策。
2021
Instagram apologized and removed harmful search suggestions
Company response
Instagram apologized after its search feature prompted some people with eating disorders to search for weight-loss terms such as “appetite suppressant.” Facebook, which owns Instagram, said the inclusion of the terms was an oversight and that they had been removed in an update.
Company response
Apology — Instagram
Instagram has apologised for a “mistake” that meant it promoted weight-loss content to users with eating disorders.
Remediation — Facebook
Apology — Instagram
We're sorry for any confusion caused.
Remediation — Instagram
Weight loss should not have been one of them and we've taken steps to prevent these terms from appearing here.
Source excerpt
Instagram has apologised for a “mistake” that meant it promoted weight-loss content to users with eating disorders.
But some people with eating disorders found the app was prompting them to search for terms like “appetite suppressant” instead, raising the risk of a relapse or worse.
'Weight loss should not have been one of them and we've taken steps to prevent these terms from appearing here. We're sorry for any confusion caused.'
2021
Facebook and Instagram face criticism over removal of pro-Palestine posts
Issue disclosure
The article reported that users and human rights groups alleged that Facebook and Instagram removed hundreds of pro-Palestine posts, with many removals reportedly unexplained. Facebook said some recent glitches had affected sharing and content visibility, and its vice president apologized for mistakenly labeling some posts as incitement to violence.
Company response
Apology — Facebook
Nick Clegg, Facebookâs vice president for global affairs, virtually met with Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh in a virtual meeting on Tuesday, where he apologized for the company mistakenly labeling some posts as incitement to violence.
Source excerpt
The groups say the decisions of Facebook and other tech firms amount to âcensorshipâ of Palestinians
Nearly 500 removals on Instagram and Facebook were documented by 7amleh, a Palestinian digital rights non-profit, between 6 and 19 May.
Nick Clegg, Facebookâs vice president for global affairs, virtually met with Palestinian Prime Minister Mohammad Shtayyeh in a virtual meeting on Tuesday, where he apologized for the company mistakenly labeling some posts as incitement to violence.