Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile133 entries · Page 4 of 7
2023
FTC proposes new restrictions on Meta over alleged children’s privacy violations
Investigation
The FTC alleged that Meta misrepresented how children could communicate through Messenger Kids and proposed updates to its 2020 order that would impose additional restrictions on Meta’s use of minors’ data and launches of new products or services. The proposed updates were approved in a 3-0 FTC vote; the source does not report a final order.
Company response
Denial — Meta
Meta responded in a statement by calling the move "a political stunt."
Source excerpt
The agency also proposed updates to the 2020 order that would add additional restrictions, including banning the company from monetizing data of children and teens under 18.
Meta responded in a statement by calling the move "a political stunt."
The proposed updates were approved in a 3-0 vote by the FTC.
2023
Reports allege Threads removed posts and displayed content warnings
Issue disclosure
A report alleged that Meta Platforms' Threads removed a user's post under its Community Guidelines and displayed a warning to users attempting to follow Donald Trump Jr. The source presents these as allegations and does not establish an independent determination. The report concerns content moderation actions on Threads, a Meta-owned platform, and describes both the removal of a post and a warning shown to users seeking to follow a specific account. No further details, outcomes, or independent verification are provided in the source material.
A report alleged that Meta's Threads removed a user's post under its Community Guidelines and displayed a warning to users attempting to follow Donald Trump Jr. The source presents these as allegations and does not establish an independent determination.
Source excerpt
Shaney Yricch of "The Street Poller" was notified that a thread he posted on Threads was removed just moments after he shared it "because it goes against our Community Guidelines."
Numerous accounts that have tried to follow Donald Trump Jr. under the handle "donaldjtrumpjr" are receiving notices asking them if they really want to follow him after all.
2023
Twitter threatens legal action over Threads
Issue disclosure
Twitter accused Meta of using its trade secrets and other intellectual property to develop Threads and threatened legal action. A Meta source rejected the allegation, saying no one on the Threads engineering team was a former Twitter employee.
Company response
Denial — Meta
一位Meta消息人士告訴Semafor,推特的指控毫無根據。
Denial — Meta
一位Meta消息人士告诉Semafor,推特的指控毫无根据。
Denial — Meta
Andy Stone, a spokesperson for Meta, said in a post on Threads, "No one on the Threads engineering team is a former Twitter employee - that's just not a thing."
Source excerpt
社交媒體推特(Twitter)威脅要對Meta旗下Instagram新推出的Threads應用程序採取法律行動。
「Threads工程團隊中沒有人是前推特員工——沒這回事。」消息人士說。
一位Meta消息人士告訴Semafor,推特的指控毫無根據。
2023
Meta apologizes for erroneous Palestinian-profile translations
Company response
Meta Platforms apologized after a translation bug caused some Palestinian users' profile bios to display the word "terrorist" in an Arabic-to-English translation. The company acknowledged that a bug briefly caused inappropriate Arabic translations in some of its products. The incident concerned the appearance of the word "terrorist" in the translated bios of some Palestinian users. Meta's statement did not specify which products were affected beyond referring to "some of its products."
Meta apologized after a translation bug caused some Palestinian users’ profile bios to display the word “terrorist” in an Arabic-to-English translation. Meta acknowledged that a bug briefly caused inappropriate Arabic translations in some of its products.
Company response
Apology — Meta
Following the video's viral spread, Meta issued an apology and acknowledged that a bug briefly caused inappropriate Arabic translations in some of its products.
Source excerpt
Meta, the parent company of Instagram, has apologized for inserting the word "terrorist" into some Palestinian users' profile bios.
Following the video's viral spread, Meta issued an apology and acknowledged that a bug briefly caused inappropriate Arabic translations in some of its products.
Instagram's parent company, Meta, has apologized for an apparent bug that inserted the term "Palestinian terrorists" into the bios of some pro-Palestine users.
2023
Meta responds to EU misinformation concerns
Company response
Meta Platforms shared an updated content-monitoring action plan in response to European Union concerns about misinformation and compliance with the Digital Services Act. According to the company, it created an operations center staffed with Hebrew- and Arabic-speaking experts and described additional content moderation measures. The update was presented as part of Meta's response to the EU's concerns.
Meta shared an updated content-monitoring action plan in response to EU concerns about misinformation and compliance with the Digital Services Act. The company said it created an operations center with Hebrew- and Arabic-speaking experts and described additional content moderation measures.
Stated objective. Meta said the new setup lets it remove content and fight misinformation faster.
Company response
Ongoing disclosure — Meta
Meta has shared an updated content monitoring action plan
Source excerpt
Meta has shared an updated content monitoring action plan as the devastating Israel-Hamas war continues. It follows a stern letter from Thierry Breton, the European Union's (EU) regulatory commissioner, to Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg about misinformation concerns (such as deep fakes) and compliance with the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA).
In its statement, Meta said that it created an ever-evolving operations center with experts fluent in Hebrew and Arabic
Meta claims this new setup lets them remove content and fight misinformation faster.
2023
Meta sues FTC over proposed privacy restrictions
Lawsuit filed
Meta Platforms sued the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) in a dispute over proposed privacy restrictions. According to the source, Meta sought to stop the FTC from reopening a 2020 privacy settlement and to challenge proceedings that could restrict monetization of children's data. The FTC alleged that Meta repeatedly violated the settlement and monetized younger users' data in violation of COPPA, the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act. The source does not specify the outcome of the lawsuit or further details of the proceedings.
Meta sued the FTC to stop it from reopening a 2020 privacy settlement and to challenge proceedings that could restrict monetization of children’s data. The FTC alleged Meta repeatedly violated the settlement and monetized younger users’ data in violation of COPPA.
Source excerpt
Meta has sued the Federal Trade Commission (FTC)
The FTC, for its part, says that Meta has repeatedly violated the terms of 2020's settlement regarding user privacy. The agency also says that the company has violated the Children's Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) by monetizing the data of younger users.
The dispute stems from a 2020 consent agreement Meta made with the FTC that also had the social media giant pay a record $5 billion fine over privacy violations.
2023
Agcom fines Meta over gambling advertising
Fine or penalty
Italy’s communications watchdog Agcom fined Meta 5.85 million euros over content on Facebook and Instagram that it said breached a 2018 ban on gambling advertising. The regulator said the fine concerned content found on five Instagram accounts and 13 Facebook accounts.
Source excerpt
The authority, Agcom, said the fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited.
It said its investigation "found promotional material or other advertising, including indirect, for betting or games involving money on 18 profiles/accounts (five on Instagram and 13 on Facebook), as well as 32 sponsored contents."
Italy's communications authority said Friday it had fined Facebook's parent company Meta 5.85 million euros ($6.4 million) for carrying gambling advertising.
2023
Meta apologizes over fraudulent ads featuring Wissam Al Mana
Company response
PYMNTS reported that Meta apologized for fraudulent cryptocurrency scam advertisements on Facebook that featured Wissam Al Mana’s image without authorization. The article also says Al Mana reportedly emerged victorious in a legal battle against Meta.
Company response
Apology — Meta
Meta Apologizes for Fraudulent Ads Featuring Billionaire Wissam Al Mana
Source excerpt
Meta Apologizes for Fraudulent Ads Featuring Billionaire Wissam Al Mana
Qatari billionaire Wissam Al Mana reportedly emerged victorious in a legal battle against Meta over the unauthorized use of his image in cryptocurrency scam advertisements on Facebook.
2023
New Hampshire joins lawsuit against Meta over platform design
Lawsuit filed
New Hampshire joined other states suing Meta over alleged addictive design features on Facebook and Instagram. The complaint alleges the platforms were designed to prolong children’s use; the filing seeks an injunction and monetary penalties. These are allegations, not a court determination.
Stated objective. The complaint seeks injunctive and monetary relief to rectify the alleged harms caused by the platforms.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
Meta said it was working to provide a safer environment for teenagers on its apps and has introduced more than 30 tools to support teenagers and families.
Clarification — Meta
We share the attorneys generals’ commitment to providing teens with safe, positive experiences online, and have already introduced over 30 tools to support teens and their families.
Source excerpt
The filing asks the court to enter an injunction requiring substantive changes in how the company operates, and also seeks monetary penalties.
New Hampshire has joined 41 other states suing Facebook and Instagram for using “addictive” algorithms that “exploit the developmental vulnerabilities of children and trap them into never-ending use.”
Meta was sued by more than three dozen states on Tuesday for knowingly using features on Instagram and Facebook to hook children to its platforms, even as the company said its social media sites were safe for young people.
2023
San Mateo County school board adds Meta to social media addiction lawsuit
Lawsuit filed
The San Mateo County board of education added Meta to a complaint alleging that social media platforms were designed to addict students and contributed to a mental health crisis.
Source excerpt
Meta was sued by the school board in the company's home county for allegedly addicting students to its social media platforms and contributing to a mental health crisis.
The San Mateo County board of education added the parent company of Facebook and Instagram to a complaint it filed March 13 against other social media giants, including Google, TikTok and Snap.
Meta Platforms Inc sued by its home county over social media addiction
2023
Irish watchdog fines Meta €390 million over GDPR breaches
Fine or penalty
Ireland’s Data Protection Commission fined Meta Ireland €390 million over GDPR breaches relating to Facebook and Instagram. Meta said it was disappointed and planned to appeal the decision and fines.
Company response
Denial — Meta
Meta spokesperson said in a statement that it “strongly” believes its approach “respects GDPR”
Denial — Meta
我们坚信我们的做法尊重GDPR,所以我们对这些决定感到失望
Denial — Meta
Meta said in a statement that "we strongly believe our approach respects GDPR, and we’re therefore disappointed by these decisions and intend to appeal both the substance of the rulings and the fines."
Source excerpt
Meta Ireland was fined 210 million euro for breaches of EU data privacy rules relating to Facebook, and 180 million euro for breaches on Instagram.
Ireland’s data watchdog has fined Facebook’s parent company Meta Ireland 390 million euro
Meta said it was “disappointed” by the decision and intends to appeal against “both the substance of the rulings and the fines”.
2023
Norwegian regulator restricts Meta's use of user data for behavioral advertising
Ban or restriction
Norway's data protection authority said Meta cannot harvest user data in Norway, including physical locations, and use it for behavioral advertising. The authority said a daily fine would apply from August 4 until November 3 unless Meta takes remedial action; Meta said it would review the decision.
Company response
Investigation — Meta
Meta said it would review Datatilsynet's decision
Clarification — Meta
A spokesperson from Meta said user data protection was important to the company and maintained Onavo Protect had properly functioned as an online security tool.
Source excerpt
Meta said it would review Datatilsynet's decision and that there would be no immediate impact on its services.
Regulator Datatilsynet said it would charge the fine every day from August 4 until November 3 unless Meta takes action. It said Meta cannot harvest user data in Norway, such as users' physical locations, and use it to target advertising at them, called behavioural advertising, a business model common to Big Tech.
The data protection authority, Datatilsynet, said in mid-July it was temporarily imposing a ban on Meta for carrying out behavioral advertising based on the surveillance and profiling of users in Norway.
2023
WhatsApp AI sticker searches returned weapon imagery for Palestinian-related prompts
Issue disclosure
A report said WhatsApp's AI-generated sticker feature returned images of children with guns for prompts including “Palestine,” while comparable Israel-related prompts did not generate images of people with weapons. Meta said it was aware of the issue and was addressing it.
Company response
Remediation — Meta
We're aware of this issue and are addressing it
Source excerpt
"We're aware of this issue and are addressing it," a Meta spokesperson said in a statement to Mashable.
When users search "Palestinian," "Palestine," or "Muslim boy Palestine," the feature returns a photo of a gun or a boy with a gun, .a report from The Guardian shows
However, prompts for "Israeli boy" generated stickers of children playing and reading, and even prompts for "Israel army" didn't generate photos of people with weapons.
2023
Court denies FTC request to block Meta’s acquisition of Within
Ruling
Judge Edward Davila submitted a sealed decision denying the FTC’s request to take next steps in blocking Meta’s purchase of Within. Meta was still temporarily barred from completing the deal while the FTC considered its next steps, including a possible appeal. The FTC had alleged that the acquisition would be anti-competitive; the reported decision did not resolve that allegation.
Source excerpt
The FTC sued Meta in July to block the purchase of Within, the creators of the VR fitness app Supernatural, alleging that the acquisition would be anti-competitive.
Meta will be temporarily barred from completing the deal while the FTC decides on its next steps, since the agency could still appeal the ruling.
2023
Seattle Public Schools sues social media companies over alleged harms to students
Lawsuit filed
Seattle Public Schools filed a lawsuit against Meta, Snap, ByteDance, and Alphabet, alleging that their social media platforms were designed and operated in ways that exploited users' psychology and contributed to a youth mental health crisis. The lawsuit sought compensatory damages and other civil penalties; these are allegations, not a court determination.
Source excerpt
Seattle Public Schools, the largest school district in the state of Washington, filed a lawsuit Friday against multiple social media giants, in an effort to hold the companies "accountable for the harm they have wreaked on the social, emotional, and mental health of its students," the district claimed.
The lawsuit accuses Meta, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook; Snap Inc., which runs Snapchat; ByteDance, the owner of TikTok; and Alphabet, the parent company of Google, which owns YouTube, of designing and operating their respective platforms "in ways that exploit the psychology and neurophysiology of their users into spending more and more time on their platforms."
The lawsuit seeks compensatory monetary damages and other civil penalties.
2023
Meta re-files lawsuit against Freenom
Lawsuit filed
Meta withdrew its December 2022 lawsuit against Freenom and re-filed it in March 2023, alleging that Freenom ignored abuse complaints about phishing websites and continued licensing domains used for illegal purposes.
Source excerpt
Meta withdrew its December 2022 lawsuit and re-filed it in March 2023.
Meta’s complaint charged. “Even after receiving notices of infringement or phishing by its customers, Freenom continues to license new infringing domain names to those same customers.”
2023
EU court upholds German antitrust judgment involving Meta
Ruling
The European Court of Justice upheld a 2019 German antitrust judgment involving Meta. The court held that competition authorities can consider data-privacy infractions when assessing whether a business abused market dominance; Meta said it was evaluating the decision.
Company response
Ongoing disclosure — Meta
“We are evaluating the court’s decision and will have more to say in due course,” Facebook parent Meta stated in a declaration.
Source excerpt
The court upheld a German antitrust judgement from 2019 that threatened to destabilize Meta's business model of selling advertisements tailored to customers based on information obtained from how they use its services.
The court held that antitrust regulators can consider any infractions of data privacy standards when determining whether cyber behemoths are abusing their market dominance by shutting out competitors.
“We are evaluating the court’s decision and will have more to say in due course,” Facebook parent Meta stated in a declaration.
2023
Charlotte-Mecklenburg school board sues social media companies
Lawsuit filed
The Charlotte-Mecklenburg school board filed a lawsuit against social media companies, alleging that their platforms contributed to a mental health crisis among children and harmed school operations. The allegations are from the lawsuit; no determination is reported.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
Reports from the (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) and others point to growing academic pressure, concerns of safety in schools, the lingering impact of the pandemic and limited access to mental health care as key factors.
Source excerpt
The board filed its 184-page complaint Thursday in US District Court for North Carolina’s Western District.
The suit targets owners of Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok, and YouTube. Defendants include Meta and Google.
The Charlotte-Mecklenburg school board is suing owners of major social media platforms for contributing to a "mental health crisis" among American children.
2023
Spanish media association files lawsuit against Meta
Lawsuit filed
A Spanish media association representing 83 Spanish media outlets filed suit against Meta in Madrid, alleging violations of European data-protection rules and seeking €550 million in damages.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
A spokesperson for Meta said the company shared the commitment of the attorneys general to "providing teens with safe, positive experiences online" and had "already introduced over 30 tools to support teens and their families".
Denial — Meta
That Instagram is damaging to young peoples' mental health is contested by Meta.
Source excerpt
西班牙媒体协会代表83家西班牙媒体,于12月4日向马德里商业法院提起诉讼,指控拥有Facebook、WhatsApp和Instagram的Meta公司违反欧洲数据保护法规。
声明还指出,“Meta公司系统地、大量地使用其平台上的用户个人信息进行跟踪,这使得该公司能够以非法获取竞争优势为基础,在市场保持优势。”
The claims were made in a federal lawsuit, which was announced by dozens of US states.
2023
South Korea fines Meta over personal information collection and use
Fine or penalty
South Korea's Personal Information Protection Commission imposed an additional fine of 7.4 billion won on Meta for collecting personal information without user consent and using it for personalized online advertising. The commission found that Meta secretly collected Facebook users' personal information through Facebook Login.
Source excerpt
The Korea Times, the PIPC also fined another tech company - Meta Platforms - for the same personal data breach.
For this offense, the commission penalized Mark Zuckerberg's company with an additional KRW7.4 billion fine on top of its previous KRW30.8 billion fine that was handed down in September 2022.
The organization further discovered that the social media giant secretly gathered the personal information of Facebook users through its "Facebook Login" prompt.