Controversies
Controversies tied to this brand in public sources. A listing is not a finding of fault.
Back to profile133 entries · Page 5 of 7
2023
Tennessee school system sues social media platforms over student mental health
Lawsuit filed
The Clarksville-Montgomery County School System filed a lawsuit against Facebook, Google, Instagram, Meta, Snapchat, Tik Tok, WhatsApp and YouTube, alleging that social media companies lack adequate controls for student access and appropriate content and seeking accountability.
Stated objective. seeking accountability by social media companies for a lack of controls surrounding student access and appropriate content
Source excerpt
The Frantz Law Group, working with Lewis Thomason, filed the lawsuit the week of May 8 against Facebook, Google, Instagram, Meta, Snapchat, Tik Tok, WhatsApp and YouTube on behalf of CMCSS, according to a news release.
The school system is seeking accountability by social media companies for a lack of controls surrounding student access and appropriate content.
Clarksville-Montgomery County Schools filed its lawsuit earlier this month through the California-based Frantz Law Group and Tennessee-based law offices of Lewis Thomason.
2023
Meta faces backlash over automatic Threads cross-posting
Public backlash
Meta began automatically cross-posting Threads content to Facebook and Instagram feeds without users’ consent. The practice drew backlash from some Threads users who did not want their posts shared with a broader audience.
Stated objective. The article says the effort was intended to increase usage of Threads.
Source excerpt
According to an Oct. 23 Egadget report, the move has sparked backlash among some Threads users who intentionally use the app differently than Facebook and don’t want their intimate Threads posts being broadcast to their broader Facebook social circle.
In an effort to increase usage of its fledgling social app Threads, Meta has begun automatically cross-posting Threads content directly to users’ Facebook and Instagram feeds without their consent.
2023
Arkansas sues Meta over Facebook youth-safety and mental-health claims
Lawsuit filed
Arkansas filed a lawsuit against Meta, alleging that the company manipulated Facebook to maximize the time young people spend on the platform, which the state says helped fuel mental health problems among its youth. These are allegations in the lawsuit.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
Meta on Tuesday outlined steps it has taken to protect teens on its platforms, including age- verification technology and technology that finds and removes content related to suicide, self-injury or eating disorders.
Source excerpt
The lawsuit against Meta accuses the company of manipulating Facebook to maximize the amount of time that young people spend on the platform, which it says has helped fuel mental health problems among the state’s youth.
The state filed two lawsuits against TikTok and its Chinese parent company ByteDance and a third lawsuit against Meta, which also owns Instagram, accusing the companies of violating the state’s deceptive trade practices act.
The lawsuits — one filed against Meta and the other two against foreign-owned TikTok — were filed in the state Tuesday, all under Arkansas’ Deceptive Trade Practices Act, which makes it illegal for companies to engage in false, deceptive business practices.
2023
South Korean court rules against Meta in user-information sharing case
Ruling
The Seoul Administrative Court ruled against Meta in its challenge to a 2020 fine imposed by South Korea’s Personal Information Protection Commission. The court said Facebook users could not know the relevant legal notices and that the company had taken unfair profits from providing users’ personal information to other operators without their knowledge.
Source excerpt
But the Seoul Administrative Court on Thursday ruled against Meta, saying its users were not able to know related legal notices and the company had taken unfair profits from the practice.
In November 2020, the Personal Information Protection Commission (PIPC) fined Meta, formerly known as Facebook Inc., 7.8 billion won ($5.78 million) after its probe found that the personal information of at least 3.3 million out of 18 million Facebook users in South Korea was provided to operators other than Facebook without their knowledge from May 2012 through June 2018.
2023
Ireland fines WhatsApp over EU privacy-law breach
Fine or penalty
Ireland's Data Privacy Commissioner fined WhatsApp 5.5 million euros for an additional breach of EU privacy laws and said the service must reassess how it uses personal data for service improvements.
Source excerpt
The DPC, which acts as the EU's lead privacy regulator for Meta, said WhatsApp must reassess how it uses personal data for service improvements.
DUBLIN Meta's WhatsApp subsidiary was fined 5.5 million euros ($5.95 million) on Thursday by Ireland's Data Privacy Commissioner (DPC) for an additional breach of the EU's privacy laws.
2023
Investigation reports Instagram recommendations surfaced child-abuse content
Issue disclosure
A reported investigation found that Instagram recommendations directed test accounts toward accounts involved in advertising and selling child-abuse content. Meta said it was setting up an internal task force and described efforts to investigate and remove such networks and accounts.
Company response
Investigation — Meta
Meta, which should be unsettled with the issue, is setting up an internal task force to address the issues raised by the investigation.
Investigation — Meta
We’re continuously investigating ways to actively defend against this behavior
Source excerpt
Meta, which should be unsettled with the issue, is setting up an internal task force to address the issues raised by the investigation.
A recent investigation has exposed how Instagram’s algorithms are facilitating the spread of child sexual abuse content on the platform.
2023
Meta faces criticism over fraud on its platforms
Public backlash
Meta faced criticism from MPs, consumer groups, and the UK banking industry over allegations that it failed to prevent rising fraudulent activity on its platforms.
Source excerpt
Meta, the parent company of prominent social media platforms Facebook, Instagram, and WhatsApp, gets under fire from MPs, consumer groups, and the UK banking industry for failing to prevent a rise in fraudulent activity on its sites.
2023
UK minister criticizes Meta's Facebook encryption plans
Public backlash
UK Security Minister Tom Tugendhat criticized Meta's plans to roll out end-to-end encryption for Facebook messages, saying the change would allow child abusers to operate with impunity. Meta said it had developed safety measures to address abuse while maintaining privacy and security.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
We don't think people want us reading their private messages so have developed safety measures that prevent, detect, and allow us to take action against this heinous abuse, while maintaining online privacy and security
Source excerpt
The UK's security minister says the social media giant's plans to encrypt Facebook messages would allow child abusers to 'operate with impunity'.
We don't think people want us reading their private messages so have developed safety measures that prevent, detect, and allow us to take action against this heinous abuse, while maintaining online privacy and security
Meta, which owns Facebook alongside apps such as WhatsApp and Instagram, said it would work with police and child safety experts.
2023
Meta faces backlash over blocking wildfire news links in Canada
Public backlash
Meta faced accusations that blocking news links in Canada during wildfires endangered lives and limited residents' access to updates.
Company response
Denial — Meta
Meta -- which did not respond to AFP requests for comment -- rejected CBC's suggestion.
Clarification — Meta
Instead it urged Canadians to use the "Safety Check" function on Facebook to let others know if they are safe or not.
Source excerpt
Meta is being accused of endangering lives by blocking news links in Canada at a crucial moment, when thousands have fled their homes and are desperate for wildfire updates that once would have been shared widely on Facebook.
Meta on August 1 started blocking the distribution of news links and articles on its Facebook and Instagram platforms in response to a recent law requiring digital giants to pay publishers for news content.
Meta has said the bill is flawed and insisted that news outlets share content on its Facebook and Instagram platforms to attract readers, benefiting them and not the Silicon Valley firm.
2023
Judge orders Meta to pay $50,000 over Facebook account case
Ruling
A judge ordered Meta to pay Jason Crawford $50,000 after Facebook's legal team did not respond to his lawsuit over his account being restricted. The article does not give the date of the order.
Company response
Remediation — Facebook
"I felt a little bit vindicated, and they activated my account again," he said.
Source excerpt
'I felt a little bit vindicated, and they activated my account again,' he said.
Because Meta's legal teams failed to respond to the suit, a judge ordered the company to pay Crawford $50,000.
The company is now, according to Crawford, refusing to pay
2022
Meta clarifies it has no plan to exit Europe
Company response
In February 2022, after a report by Meta Platforms prompted widespread coverage, the company stated that it had no plan to withdraw from the European market. Meta said it was seeking a solution for transferring users' personal data between the European Union and the United States. The clarification followed the broad reporting of the report's contents.
After its report prompted widespread coverage, Meta said it had no plan to withdraw from the European market and was seeking a solution for transferring users’ personal data between the EU and the US.
Stated objective. To find a solution for transferring users’ personal data between the EU and the US.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
表示絕對沒有計劃撤出歐洲市場,只是希望尋求解決方案讓用戶個人數據能夠在歐盟和美國之間傳送。
Source excerpt
在報告內容被廣泛報導後改口,表示絕對沒有計劃撤出歐洲市場,只是希望尋求解決方案讓用戶個人數據能夠在歐盟和美國之間傳送。
2022
UK watchdog fines Meta over disclosure failures
Fine or penalty
The UK Competition and Markets Authority fined Meta $2 million for failing to notify it about the resignation of three key employees and the reallocation of their roles in connection with Meta's Giphy acquisition.
Source excerpt
According to the CMA, Meta failed to notify the regulator about the resignation of three key employees and the reallocation of their roles.
The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has fined Meta (formerly Facebook) $2 million for failing to disclose key changes regarding its $315 million acquisition of online database and search engine Giphy.
2022
CMA fines Meta for breaching merger enforcement order
Fine or penalty
The Competition and Markets Authority said Meta breached an enforcement order by failing to notify it in advance of staff changes and to seek prior consent before reallocating responsibilities. The CMA stated that this was the second penalty it had issued to Meta for breaching the order.
Company response
Denial — Meta
We are disappointed by the CMA's decision to fine us because of the voluntary departure of US-based employees.
Ongoing disclosure — Meta
We intend to pay the fine, but it is problematic that the CMA can take decisions that could directly impact the rights of our US employees protected under US law.
Source excerpt
The UK Competition and Market Authority (CMA) on Friday announced that it has fined Facebook's parent company Meta 1.5 million ($2 million) for breaching an initial enforcement order from the watchdog.
The latest fine of £1.5m is a result of Meta’s failure to comply with CMA orders to inform the competition authority of any material changes to the business, such as resignations and redistribution of key staff.
This order required Meta to actively inform the competition authority of any 'material changes' to the business, including resignations of key staff, and then seek prior consent before rehiring or redistributing responsibilities.
2022
Andrew Forrest brings criminal case against Facebook over scam ads
Lawsuit filed
Andrew Forrest brought a criminal case against Facebook in the Western Australia Magistrates Court, alleging that the platform breached federal anti-money-laundering laws by not sufficiently cracking down on scam ads. Meta responded that it takes a multifaceted approach to stop such ads.
Company response
Clarification — Meta
Meta told Nine: “We take a multifaceted approach to stop these ads. We work not just to detect and reject the ads themselves but also block advertisers from our services and, in some cases, take court action to enforce our policies.”
Source excerpt
Forrest, Australia’s richest man and chairman of Fortescue Metals Group, said he was taking the action to stop people losing money to clickbait advertising scams, such as ones using his image to promote cryptocurrency schemes.
Iron ore magnate Andrew Forrest said on Thursday he is launching criminal proceedings against Meta Platform Facebook in an Australian court, alleging that it breached anti-money laundering laws and its platform is used to scam Australians.
The action in the Western Australia Magistrates Court is the first time the tech giant has faced criminal charges anywhere in the world.
2022
Russian court fines Meta and TikTok over LGBT content
Fine or penalty
In April 2022, a Moscow court ordered Meta Platforms to pay a fine of four million rubles and TikTok to pay two million rubles. The court issued the penalties because the companies had failed to delete content that Russian authorities described as LGBT "propaganda." The ruling concerned the companies' handling of such content on their platforms under Russian regulations.
A Moscow court ordered Meta to pay four million rubles and TikTok to pay two million rubles for failing to delete content described by Russian authorities as LGBT “propaganda.”
Source excerpt
The Russian government is fining Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok for refusing to remove LGBTQ content that violates the country's 2013 law against so-called gay propaganda.
On Tuesday, a Moscow court ordered Meta, Facebook and Instagram's parent company, to pay a fine of four million rubles ($53,475). The court also ordered TikTok to pay a fine of two million rubles ($26,711), Today Online reported.
2022
Missouri mother sues Meta, Facebook and Instagram over alleged addictive platform design
Lawsuit filed
A mother from Blue Springs, Missouri, filed a federal lawsuit against Meta, Instagram and Facebook. The lawsuit alleges that the companies intentionally designed their products to maximize screen time and that this contributed to addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns. These are allegations made in the lawsuit and have not been established as fact. The filing concerns the design of the platforms rather than a specific product feature or incident.
A Blue Springs mother filed a federal lawsuit against Meta, Instagram and Facebook, alleging that the companies intentionally designed their products to maximize screen time and that this contributed to addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns. These are allegations in the lawsuit.
Source excerpt
A Blue Springs mother has filed a federal lawsuit claiming Instagram and Facebook have "exploited children around the world to drive profits," citing "addictive" use of social media by minors.
The allegations in the suit filed against Meta, Instagram and Facebook by the Blue Springs mother said the companies "have intentionally designed their products to maximize users' screen time," additionally causing "addictive and self-destructive behavioral patterns."
Cecelia Tesch of Pueblo filed the federal lawsuit in U.S. District Court in Denver last month on behalf of her daughter— listed as "R.P." in court documents obtained by FOX Television Stations.
2022
US jury orders Meta to pay Voxer $174.5 million in patent case
Ruling
A US jury ordered Meta to pay $174.5 million after deciding that Facebook and Instagram live features used technology patented by Voxer. Meta said it believed the trial evidence showed it did not infringe Voxer's patents and intended to seek further relief, including an appeal.
2022
South Korea fines Meta over privacy violations
Fine or penalty
South Korea's Personal Information and Protection Commission fined Meta 30.8 billion won over tracking consumers' online behavior without consent and using their data for targeted advertisements. Meta said it would consider all options, including seeking a court ruling, and stated that it works in a legally compliant way.
2022
Irish watchdog fines Instagram over handling of teenagers’ personal information
Fine or penalty
Ireland’s Data Protection Commission decided to fine Instagram 405 million euros after an investigation found that the platform mishandled teenagers’ personal information in violation of EU data privacy rules. Meta said it disagreed with how the fine was calculated and intended to appeal.
2022
Meta agrees to £600 million settlement in data-breach case
Settlement
Meta Platforms agreed to a £600 million settlement in a United States case concerning a data breach linked to the Cambridge Analytica scandal. The agreement resolves that case, though the available source does not specify the date on which the settlement was reached. The event is recorded as a controversy note concerning the company, based solely on the reported settlement and its connection to the data-breach matter.
Meta agreed to a £600 million settlement in a US case over a data breach linked to the Cambridge Analytica scandal. The source does not specify when the agreement was reached.
Source excerpt
Facebook owners Meta have agreed a £600 million settlement in a US case, over a data breach linked to the Cambridge Analytica scandal.